3 ms·
In essence, the EITC rewards work and provides an incentive for workers to improve their skills. Equally important, it does not distort market forces, thereby m
by analog31 12y ago
In essence, the EITC rewards work and provides an incentive for workers to improve their skills. Equally important, it does not distort market forces, thereby maximizing employment.
I wonder about this. In a perfect market system, it's impossible to pay below-subsistence wages, because you can't work if you've starved to death. I think Adam Smith pointed this out. So, any public support for wage earners distorts the market by driving wages downward.
It's arguable that the government should subsidize wage earners, so that wages can be lower. Low wage earners receive a lot of things that they don't pay for out of their own pockets, such as education, which I support. But it should not be offered as a protection of the free market.
- monochromatic 12y ago> In a perfect market system, it's impossible to pay below-subsistence wages, because you can't work if you've starved to death. You might not starve to death if you start committing crimes on the side though.
- analog31 12y agoTrue, and it raises an additional point, which is that an isolated consideration of economics generally overlooks the willingness of people to cooperate with the myriad of written and unwritten rules that govern civil society.
- lumberjack 12y ago>I wonder about this. In a perfect market system, it's impossible to pay below-subsistence wages, because you can't work if you've starved to death. Exactly. It's no hard to see how those who praise it so much get to immediately benefit from it by being able to hire people for wages that are ridiculously low and forcing the taxpayer to foot the bill for the rest.
- DalekBaldwin 12y agoAny non-market action will distort market forces. What he means is that the EITC is a softer kind of distortion. Since the EITC is essentially a matching contribution to the employee's earnings, it still allows decisions about wages to be made at the margin, as opposed to a minimum wage which mandates a hard cutoff.
- greggyb 12y ago>In a perfect market system, it's impossible to pay below-subsistence wages, because you can't work if you've starved to death. I urge you to think about the many people who are part of a household who can contribute materially with less-than-individual-subsistence wages. A retiree supplementing their retirement savings with a part time job; the vast majority of teenage workers. Almost anyone working while in school. There are plenty of people who do not depend on their wage for 100% of their livelihood, but whose outcomes you worsen by pricing them out of marginal work.
- analog31 11y agoAh, yes. I forgot about that too. It's actually a matter near and dear to my heart, as a musician. The economics of live music are strongly affected by people for whom music is not a vital source of income, and as a result, gig pay can actually drive towards zero or even negative if your locale has a "pay to play" music scene. And admittedly, I play some gigs for free.