3 ms·
> If bridges were as complex as software, would they still be as reliable? No. As a simple example, if there are n software modules, there are n! possible comm
by wallflower 17y ago
> If bridges were as complex as software, would they still be as reliable?
No. As a simple example, if there are n software modules, there are n! possible communication paths. Yes, black-boxing can partition n down but software is not self-healing (yet). Witness the GMail cascading failures.
The bridge supports were undermined because the high-water level flooding generated enormous hydrostatic pressure against the footings (pressure is greatest at the bottom - where the footings meet the earth).
Think of standing in the surf and getting knocked down by a wave - the force, whether you know it or not, is greatest at the bottom (near your feet - which is why you can lose your footing).
http://www.csus.edu/indiv/h/hollandm/ce135/Viewgrph/SluicGat/sggraphs/sluicemomentum.gif http://www.csus.edu/indiv/h/hollandm/ce135/Viewgrph/SluicGat...
http://www.csus.edu/indiv/h/hollandm/ce135/Viewgrph/SluicGat/SGViewGr.htm http://www.csus.edu/indiv/h/hollandm/ce135/Viewgrph/SluicGat...
- hxa7241 17y agoI am not sure how to measure and compare complexity of buildings and software. But I wouldn't immediately dismiss buildings as being all simpler than all software. > if there are n software modules, there are n! possible communication paths. We deliberately build software so it does not join every part to every other. That is fairly evident from top to bottom, and really it couldn't have a distinct coherent function if that wasn't the case. So I think a stronger argument is needed . . . which I would be quite willing to accept if good . . .
- wallflower 17y agoGood questions. I tried to answer your question by replying to your other comment a few minutes ago. The answer to your question lies in the idea that the more software can adhere to rules (assertions, aspects, closures) the more rule-driven the virtual model+behavior the software will have. Rules are good. It's good that we always fall towards the ground. It's bad a buffer overflow or exception will gum up a running software process.