3 ms·
I agree that "classifying the drivers as contractors is not a reasonable criticism" of Uber. But strictly in terms of the operation of classification, they are
by dnautics 11y ago
I agree that "classifying the drivers as contractors is not a reasonable criticism" of Uber. But strictly in terms of the operation of classification, they are in a somewhat grey area. In my opinion, on balance, Uber drivers are more like ICs than they are employees (and by a very wide margin). The problem is the 20 point test is totally ridiculous and doesn't give clear guidelines as to how much to 'weight' each of the criteria and thus gives great leeway for anyone to make a 'strong' claim in either direction by selectively ignoring the points that don't fit their preconceived opinion.
- sokoloff 11y agoThe federal tax code has to work for literally hundreds of millions of people and billions of situations. The presence of grey areas is a design feature not a bug, IMO. Yes, it can be annoying and frustrating to not know with a bright line test of executable English law code the outcome, but I can only imagine how much worse it would be if we tried to reduce every situation down to exhaustively testable 0/1 pure-white/pure-black codification. The disambiguation is lazily evaluated (sometimes at significant expense) by the tax courts, or you can request an evaluation ahead of time in a private letter ruling (at very reasonable expense). I believe this is still better than eager/greedy evaluation of all situations. Almost irrelevantly, I also think that Uber drivers are significantly more ICs than employees.