4 ms·
I think there's more to it than this. The effect of your bragging will be different on different people: some will be annoyed at it, while others will be happy
by nostrademons 12y ago
I think there's more to it than this. The effect of your bragging will be different on different people: some will be annoyed at it, while others will be happy for you. People have freedom in who they associate with.
I suspect that people (often subconsciously, sometimes consciously) use self-promotion as a way of filtering out the people who don't really like them anyway. If you let everybody know when something good happens to you, then everybody who's annoyed by good things happening to you will go away. Everybody left is genuinely happy for your success, because otherwise they would've stopped listening to you (or if they don't, it's their problem). So this is a way of culling your friends and acquaintances to optimize your social relationships.
- netcan 12y agoInteresting concept. I imagine there are a lot of very minor effects like this. One of the real mechanics behind woo ideas that people seem to be drawn to.
- pekk 12y agoThe article may have made this unclear, but just being happy about good news for you isn't self-promotion. Like if you just had a baby or whatever, and you share that news, that isn't self-promotion. Self-promotion is bragging to others about how awesome you are. It's narcissistic. "I'm a 10x developer." "You can't contradict me, I run big services in production at scale." "Everyone knows I'm the best PHP coder around." Okay... So if people are annoyed by your bragging, it doesn't mean they are envious people annoyed by good things happening to you. It might mean that they are annoyed at self-absorbed, arrogant or full of shit you are. These aren't really good traits. You say that being a self-promoter will "optimize your social relationships" because it filters out people who are simply annoyed that you have good news. I'd call people who simply hate others' mere good news just envious haters. But since self-promotion isn't just talking about good news but bragging, the people you are filtering out with self-promotion are not envious haters. They might just be realists who are into action over talk, not being anxious to take credit from others, not trying to look better than others and make team projects into competitions. That stuff generates conflict, it isn't nice, and the collapse of the reality distortion field can be painful. You probably want some of those people in your life, unless the whole point of your life is to service a fragile ego.
- nostrademons 12y agoMy point is that "envious", "self-absorbed", "arrogant", "hater", and "full of shit" are not objective qualities that a person can intrinsically possess. Rather, they are value judgments that one person labels another with. "Nostrademons is an arrogant twat" is not an objective statement; it is a subjective one, with an implicit "I think that..." prefixing it. "Pekk thinks that nostrademons is an arrogant twat" is an objective statement (hopefully false in this case, it's provided for example only). For any given person's actions, there will be a cloud of value judgments around that action. What's arrogant and obnoxious to one person may seem self-confident and assertive to another. And in general, people are happier when they don't hang around people they find obnoxious. So there's some degree of self-selection going on. If taken too far, you may end up in the situation where nobody wants to hang around with you, and that's probably a good reason to tone it down a little with the bragging. Similarly, if you find that the only people who want to hang around you are folks who you don't want to hang around, you may want to either change your actions to attract folks you actually want to be with, or change your definition of who you want to be around. But there's no intrinsic good or bad level of self-promotion, only the level at which you personally are uncomfortable.
- McUsr 12y agoWhat I find personally annoying, is when "you" are in a "competetive pond", and then people drags in stuff from outside the pond, into the pond for competetive purposes. That is unedible, and "foul play" in my book. :)
- TheOtherHobbes 12y ago>Rather, they are value judgments that one person labels another with. Not quite. Reputation is collective, not individual. If enough people agree that someone is self-absorbed and arrogant, that person has a problem. Now, it could be a problem with the collective, not the individual. Most collectives have a reversion-to-the-mean feedback loop which punishes outliers - with a possible get-out where they demonstrate exceptional effectiveness and value. But that doesn't mean there isn't an objective reputation consensus, with objective consequences. So the "That's just your opinion, man" defence isn't always going to work.
- escape_goat 12y agoOpinions, here. There is a difference between bragging and letting people know when something good happens to you. Bragging is socially aggressive; it is attractive only to those who thrive on competitive relationships. Bragging is the act of demanding social status and recognition of one's accomplishments or properties. It is explicitly a form of self-promotion. Letting people know when something good happens to you means sharing your happiness (and perhaps even pride) with them. It means being happy and telling people why you're happy. It places them in a position of judgement over your accomplishment. It does not prejudge its value, or challenge them to recognize that value; it inherently risks rejection, and it is a conversation that occurs in the context of your relationship to that person. The self-promotional message, no matter how well handled, is essentially a form of impersonal communication; the information one wishes to share needs to be shared with as broad an audience as possible. I do not think that there are nearly as many people who are annoyed by good things happening to other people as there are people who are annoyed by bragging and self-promotion. Nor do I think that those who are not annoyed by bragging and self-promotion are necessarily genuinely happy for your success. Thus I do not think that self-promotion will optimize your social relationships if their utility is considered to be their ability to support and nurture you as a human. I think that it would optimize your social relationships for the inclusion of self promoters and socially competitive peers, and the exclusion of those who prefer cooperative or individually unique, shared-intimacy-based relationships.
- kazinator 12y ago> There is a difference between bragging and letting people know when something good happens to you. Yes, and about 87% of that difference lies in the listener: for instance, in how much of a small, insecure and self-loathing person they are.
- escape_goat 12y agoObviously my remarks would be focused on the 1/8th of the difference (in your view) that is a difference of performance on the part of the speaker, rather than an imputation of motive on the part of a hostile listener. As I said, sharing personal news leaves one open to rejection, which presumably is what you have been experiencing. If any of your peers are indeed "small, insecure, and self-loathing," as you say, then it is probably a bad idea to try to share your happiness with them in the first place; most especially if you are already braced for a negative response, but sharing the news anyways. Your motive here would be really unclear to me as a third-party witness. I'll accept your assertion that what you're doing isn't bragging, but it seems somewhat confrontational to go ahead and volunteer information regarding your successes under those circumstances. If it accounts for 7/8ths of your problems with people misidentifying your attempts to share happy personal news as bragging, then you may have a more general social problem with knowing how to manage impersonal relationships. I'm pretty bad at that, myself. With regards to that remaining 1/8th, the way the speaker is conducting himself, what do you see the essential difference between bragging and sharing good news to be? What is it in people's demeanor or attitude that makes you, as an audience, feel that they are engaged in bragging?
- Dewie3 12y ago> So this is a way of culling your friends and acquaintances to optimize your social relationships. This is the kind of thing you can only read on HN.
- nostrademons 12y agoKind of a good example of itself, right? There are other communities I'm part of where a statement like that would seem callous and sociopathic. Here, it's currently the top comment, because we've self-organized into a community that values thought-provoking analytical discussion.
- Dewie3 12y agoYes, I see how you could take my comment in that way.
- tdkl 12y agoBefore social media existed, there wasn't a convenient personal broadcaster that had such a broad reach and social acceptance. So when someone was mentioning their success, it was usually expected in the context (close friends gatherings, reunions).
- bootload 12y ago'Are you building your own computer? Terminal? T V Typewriter? I/O device? or someother digital black-magic box?' -- Invitation to first, 'Homebrew Computer Club' 5th March 1975 [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Invitation_to_First_Homebrew_Computer_Club_meeting.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Invitation_to_First_Homeb...
- DanBC 12y agoHere's an example of plans for a tv typewriter http://www.swtpc.com/mholley/RadioElectronics/TV_Typewriter.htm http://www.swtpc.com/mholley/RadioElectronics/TV_Typewriter....
- bootload 11y ago@Dan what great to read. Tweleve years after this article, I was bashing away on a DEC VT100 terminal which is so similar it's not funny.
- throwawayaway 12y agosuspect all you want. people will react differently depending of the day of the week, or even minute of the day. you can "optimize them out" by bragging to build a 'yes' echo chamber, but it is probably a bad idea.
- equoid 12y agoThis is the most delusional piece of self-justification I have read in years. Your use of words like culling and optimise makes me suspect you need to work on your social skills, a lot. No one likes braggers, no one. Sometimes braggarts who have power or some other use are tolerated, but only as long as they have to be.