8 ms·
Florida Classifies Uber Driver as Employee, Says He Is Eligible for Unemployment
- MichaelCrawford 12y agothis is important. The law in the US as to whether one is an employee or an independent contractor is quite clear. Look up the "twenty factors"; sometimes they're referred to as the "twenty questions". Among the factors is who shoulders the financial risk. If it's not possible for you to lose money, that's one of the factors that qualifies you as an employee. Your title or contractual relationship have nothing to do with it.
- rubbingalcohol 12y agoUber has cleverly saddled their workers with the worst aspects of being employees and few of the benefits of being contractors.
- pckspcks 12y agoWork as few or as many hours as you like. That's a pretty big benefit of contractors.
- makomk 12y agoUber are testing out a new scheme where they penalize people for not working full-time hours by charging a much higher commission for the first few rides they take every week: http://www.wsj.com/articles/uber-tests-30-fee-its-highest-yet-1431989126 http://www.wsj.com/articles/uber-tests-30-fee-its-highest-ye... They obviously don't want people to work for them part time. Lyft are doing the same.
- prostoalex 12y agoThe article also provides an explanation for this: "Uber, which started its business taking a 20% commission on all rides, has raised and lowered that rate in different cities depending on the supply of drivers and rider demand." It seems that one way to deal with over-supply of drivers is to lower rate the rate even further, but they probably don't want to screw around with rates too much. Lowering them drastically might discourage drivers long-term, to the point where they find a different full-time job and swear off Uber.
- dnautics 12y agoIt's super possible to lose money as an Uber driver... Say you drive around in circles in a place where you don't get rides. You will burn gas and lose plenty of money and make none at all. The problem is that these drivers fall on both sides of the questions. Another question is if Uber drivers are employees of Uber in Florida, are taxi drivers now also employees? Many of them (that do not own their own car) are ICs too.
- digitalzombie 12y ago> It's super possible to lose money as an Uber driver... Say you drive around in circles in a place where you don't get rides. You will burn gas and lose plenty of money and make none at all. I'm not trying to be contentious but why does your hypothetical Uber Driver have to drive around in circle? Can't they park somewhere, or do their daily routine and wait for the app to announce a possible passenger? Cause I've met two uber drivers before from what they've talked about they just chill around, do their daily business and if there's a lead they decide if they want to take it.
- symkat 12y ago>> are taxi drivers now also employees? Many of them (that do not own their own car) are ICs too. I spent a few months as a dispatcher in a taxi shop, and drivers weren't ICs, they were more like part of a b2b transaction. They rented the car and medallion from us for a flat rate for 12 hours, and could pick up whomever they wanted off the streets. When we got calls to arrange pickups, I went down the list contacting drivers until someone would take the fare. We only made money from renting the taxis to drivers.
- dnautics 12y agoSo the distinction is that Uber handles the money. I see. Since Amazon handles money in a b2b transaction, does that make people putting things up for sale on Amazon ICs or employees?
- maxerickson 12y ago
- paulsutter 12y agoUber drivers buy a car, pay for insurance, gas, etc, and certainly run the risk of losing money. They also have total control over their time and work. They can switch on or switch off anytime they like, and choose whether to accept each ride request. There are lots of reasons to criticize uber. Classifying the drivers as contractors isn't a reasonable one.
- mattmanser 12y agoYou are joking right? There are a mass of articles and discussion about this that shows your 'reasonable' classification is in fact 'highly contentious'. Whatever else you say about Uber, it's pretty obvious that the contractor/employees are in a grey area where they have some traits of contractors and some traits of employees.
- dnautics 12y agoI think you're missing that the poster's adjective 'reasonable' is modifying the word criticism, not the word classification.
- dnautics 12y agoI agree that "classifying the drivers as contractors is not a reasonable criticism" of Uber. But strictly in terms of the operation of classification, they are in a somewhat grey area. In my opinion, on balance, Uber drivers are more like ICs than they are employees (and by a very wide margin). The problem is the 20 point test is totally ridiculous and doesn't give clear guidelines as to how much to 'weight' each of the criteria and thus gives great leeway for anyone to make a 'strong' claim in either direction by selectively ignoring the points that don't fit their preconceived opinion.
- sokoloff 12y agoThe federal tax code has to work for literally hundreds of millions of people and billions of situations. The presence of grey areas is a design feature not a bug, IMO. Yes, it can be annoying and frustrating to not know with a bright line test of executable English law code the outcome, but I can only imagine how much worse it would be if we tried to reduce every situation down to exhaustively testable 0/1 pure-white/pure-black codification. The disambiguation is lazily evaluated (sometimes at significant expense) by the tax courts, or you can request an evaluation ahead of time in a private letter ruling (at very reasonable expense). I believe this is still better than eager/greedy evaluation of all situations. Almost irrelevantly, I also think that Uber drivers are significantly more ICs than employees.
- hluska 12y agoThe problem is that the law really isn't very clear. The weighing of the factors is based wholly on context and, in most situations, it's fairly easy to come up with arguments for either side.
- dylanjermiah 12y agoFrom the IRS: "You are not an independent contractor if you perform services that can be controlled by an employer (what will be done and how it will be done). This applies even if you are given freedom of action. What matters is that the employer has the legal right to control the details of how the services are performed."
- dnautics 12y agoDefine 'controlled'. If I hire a plumber to come fix my toilet, I am saying, You are going to fix my toilet, and please do it this way. Does that make the plumber my employee?
- dylanjermiah 12y agoI didn't create the law, I don't think I'm qualified to define anything. I do however think it's intentionally hazy and open to interpretation.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoIf you find yourself telling a plumber which specific way a toilet should be fixed, you are either an employer, or should take some engineer pills. http://dilbert.com/strip/1990-09-13 http://dilbert.com/strip/1990-09-13
- jasode 12y ago>What matters is that the employer has the legal right to control the details of how the services are performed. You can't just pick one bullet point and imply it's an open & shut case. It's a combination of factors. If parents contract a painter to paint a mural in a child's bedroom and says specifically: - I know you prefer acrylic paints but I specifically want latex paint - I know your website portfolio had examples of light blue but I specifically want Pantone #2945 dark shade of blue - I know you prefer to work 9-5 but I need you to work onsite from 5pm to 9pm because that's when I'll be home from work and can give live feedback as to how it's done - I know that if I leave you to your own judgement, you'd prefer to paint Greek & Roman nudes but I need this room to be rated G so if you can paint a depiction of Mickey Mouse fighting Batman, that's what I'm looking for. - ... and so on... The homeowner can be excruciatingly specific about how & when the work is exactly performed but most reasonable people will not insist that the painter is an "employee." It takes more factors than just control of the work method. Maybe Uber's combination of other factors does ultimately mean drivers are employees but your extraction of one IRS guideline is not convincing.
- pekk 12y agoThe elephant in the room is that the tech industry is FULL of companies who are using contractor status to shift tax burden and avoid paying benefits. Almost nobody ever calls this out and those who do are likely to get blackballed. If Uber is hiring drivers and treating them as employees while classifying them as contractors, that isn't special to Uber, it's just the application of the tech industry's way of doing things to taxi drivers.
- lucaspiller 12y agoSame in the UK as well. There are a load of rules, IR35, designed to prevent this sort of thing but they are pretty easy to bypass, and the only real benefit I've seen is accountants can now charge £300+ for a contract "review" to check you are covered. As an example of how easy it is, a friend of mine is contracting long term for the government. In order to ensure he is covered and classed as a contractor, over his summer holidays he will be sub-contracting out to someone else.
- makomk 12y agoOne of the problems with classifying Uber drivers and the rest of the so-called "sharing economy" as contracting is that they're not allowed to subcontract out the work like your friend did.
- floody-berry 12y agoCompanies like Uber are much worse than that. They're a glorified web app profiting off of hundreds of thousands of people who do all the work and bear all the risk while the only people getting rich are the scum at the top and their reprehensible backers. Uber, Airbnb, etc. should make their slogan "Loopholes 101: Exploitation on a global scale. You do the work, we make the money. Fuck you, we don't care!"
- ahallock 12y agoYour comment is filled with vitriol -- did you something happen to you? Why would Uber drivers be getting "rich" anyway? A decent living might be possible, but I don't think driving cars is valued as much in the economy as those creating jobs, nor should it be. And to say Uber bears no risk is completely false--people invested money into Uber without any guarantees. And I'm not saying that these companies are without criticism or that they don't exploit workers. I'm just more baffled that alternatives haven't come along to disrupt them -- say a completely open, peer to peer network of drivers using open source applications that get paid through Square, Stripe, etc.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lawnpuppies 12y agoI never see anyone discussing whether the IRS should change its classifications based on the world be live in now, as opposed to when they created those rules.
- lazyant 12y agoIn Canada a similar argument could be made http://www.cra-arc.gc.ca/E/pub/tg/rc4110/rc4110-e.html#workers_employment_status http://www.cra-arc.gc.ca/E/pub/tg/rc4110/rc4110-e.html#worke...