5 ms·
The "Millionaire's Next Door" in that book were working in an environment different than the current, that's a fact. Now whether the current environment is "le
by mistermann 12y ago
The "Millionaire's Next Door" in that book were working in an environment different than the current, that's a fact. Now whether the current environment is "less honest and merit-based" (as I happen to believe), or not, it is certainly different.
Bubbles come and go, some are long, some are short, some are consequential, some are not. For example, real estate bubbles: these are most dangerous because it is usually the most substantial asset purchase an individual ever makes, and it is typically 90% leverage. If you fall ass-backwards into the right spot on the development curve, you can literally turn $50k (down payment) into a million++ dollars - if you guess wrong, you're bankrupt and you pray that you have a non-recourse loan.
- branchless 12y agoOk - downpayment on a house of 50k, 90% LTV. Must be 500K. Doubles in price to $1mm. Let's say it does this in 10 years. Wages haven't appreciated much. Where does that 500k come from? The next generation. Zero sum game. Rampant inequality. Crashing social mobility. As you say it's not merit based. How many people can save 500k in 10 years? Leveraged mortgage debt then becomes the only game in town. Game set and match the banks.
- mistermann 12y ago> Where does that 500k come from? It comes from two places (at least): 1. Debt - someone pushes a few buttons on a computer keyboard and "poof", you've conjured a million dollars out of thin air 2. China - this is real money, but if it gets pointed at one geographical region, it can cause major distortions, especially if that real money can be confiscated at the whim of the politician who happens to be in power at the moment
- branchless 12y agoNo - we are seeing an increase in credit but not wages. Asset prices are running ahead of wealth creation so the young must pledge to work for longer for the same pile of bricks (and land). Yes there is foreign money but still most buying is domestic. Foreign money is a convenient bogey man. It's the same in Canada and the stats do not bear it out.
- mistermann 12y ago> Foreign money is a convenient bogey man. It's the same in Canada and the stats do not bear it out. Actually, no one knows, because stats are (deliberately imo) not kept.
- branchless 12y agoWell here is some info on Canada: http://www.greaterfool.ca/2015/05/14/the-tipping-point-2/ http://www.greaterfool.ca/2015/05/14/the-tipping-point-2/ Vancouver not even in the top 10 yet we are told endlessly HAM is the cause.
- simonreed 12y agoIt comes from inflation. Purchasing power of $1mm in 10 years time will be probably the same as 500k today. The investment works because in 10 years time you own bigger chunk of the asset (Mostly due to inflation but also debt repayment from rent).
- brc 12y agoIf that's what you believe that's the outcome you get. Everyone gets the financial outcome they want.
- mistermann 12y ago> Everyone gets the financial outcome they want. I'm curious what you mean by that?
- brc 12y agoI actually stole it. The original quote is 'everyone gets what they want from the financial markets' Everyone can unpack the statement in different ways, but essentially your financial position is a result of how much effort you put into it. Most people put little effort into it, or even knowingly make bad mistakes like buying new cars on credit, yet shrug their shoulders and do it anyway. In the short term you might have a setback but people with priorities for financial success are able to overcome these and go on to greater heights. An evidenced in these comments there are some people who want to talk about how the deck is stacked against them and they can't possibly get ahead - yet people from all walks of life achieve financial freedom every day, so this is patently not true. The people who think this way are getting the outcome they want, which is to priories blaming over achievement.
- branchless 12y agoThat is a very dumb statement. I think it might even be a joke. In a zero sum game of housing speculation where there is no wealth creation of any kind then by definition if you win it's at the expense of someone else. They are achieving financial freedom by stepping on the throats of their brothers and sisters. If you want to "achieve" financial freedom that way fine, but I'll rest easier on my (cheap) death bed rather than surrounded by trinkets bought after exploiting the poor and needy. Your comment is so wrong it's hard to comprehend the mindset.
- fredkbloggs 12y agoI think we're talking about several different things here. I'm asserting that there are five essential inputs to one's economic outcome. In no particular order, they are: 1. The activities in which one engages to obtain income. This can be labor, crime, cheating and manipulation, employment of capital, or some combination of these. 2. Starting position: did you enter adulthood with an inheritance or trust fund? 3. Management: what do you do with the income you receive? 4. Environment: macroeconomic conditions and public policy (presently inseparable). 5. Luck, those arbitrary events that affect an individual or small group of people (as distinct from environmental factors that affect everyone). These can be positive or negative. Individuals generally can control (1) and (3), though the available options and their merits are products of external forces. You seem hung up on the notion that these are the only two factors that matter. You acknowledge (5) but assert that it's ultimately irrelevant to outcomes. You don't seem to acknowledge (2) and (4) at all. I am asserting that a high probability of good economic outcomes (i.e., financial independence) requires that at least (3), (4), and (5) all be favorable if we begin from the premise that the only sources of income and capital available are the proceeds of labor and one's own accumulated capital. That is, we're not going to cheat or steal and we weren't born into anything. I am not asserting that good economic outcomes are impossible under other circumstances, only that they are highly unlikely. It would be very useful to bring some data into this conversation. I would like to compare the outcomes achieved by hypothetical pairs of individuals who satisfy our constraints on factors (1) and (2) and are identical in their luck (there are no material events) and management, but differ in environment. For example, suppose that there are two individuals born 20 years apart, one in 1955 and the other in 1975. Both are male Americans, both are employed in full-time, year-round work beginning at age 20, neither is ever unemployed for any reason, and both set aside some fraction of their age-appropriate median-wage income and invest it in one of a few simple ways (we can vary that fraction and how it's invested). Each pays the taxes he legally owes and no more, and for simplicity's sake each is single and lives in a state with no personal income tax. The object of this exercise? To check in with each at age 40 and see, in today's dollars, the purchasing power of their assets and the purchasing power of the income those assets produce. We could then examine other splits; for example, two people born at the same time, one in Japan and the other in Switzerland. Or fraternal twins, one male and the other female. The possibilities are limited only by the availability of data. It would be great to see such a study. If anyone has done it, the results are not particularly easy to find. Most of the data exists: historical tax laws from the Tax Policy Center, historical income data from the Census Bureau, deflators and unemployment data from the BLS, interest rate and bond market data from the Fed, and stock market prices and dividends from the exchanges and many other sources. Some countries keep better records than others. Having looked into what's available, I think someone could put together something reasonable in a week or two. According to your thesis, these studies will show that everyone will obtain approximately the same outcome, because in all cases we have controlled for luck, starting position, income, and management strategy. Only the choice of management strategy will have material impact. According to my thesis, these studies will reveal (a) that environmental factors dominate the outcomes, (b) that there are many environments in which there is no non-oracular management strategy that will yield an outcome as good as that achieved by a male American born in 1955 who employs a simple, moderately frugal management strategy, and (c) that the vast majority of environments that have existed over the past 20 years, including today's, are strongly detrimental to positive outcomes. I assert this despite the ultra-simplified deterministic model I propose to use. I further assert that the stochastic injection of periods of unemployment (in accordance with actual historical rates) will radically worsen outcomes in at least 3 quintiles relative to the above-mentioned baseline. Finally, I assert that these results are obvious. I'm not exactly going out on a limb here. I know I sound like a "progressive". I am not. I do not advocate redistribution, higher minimum wages, more rent control, or a culture of victimhood. Quite the opposite on all counts. What I do advocate are changes to public policy that make it much less likely that decades of any individual's working life will be lived in an environment that strongly penalizes the proceeds of labor and accumulated capital. You should not attack me based on your preconceived ideas about "what I want", from either the markets or public policy. More directly to the point, my original assertion was that teaching a child that factor (3) is the only one of import does him a great disservice. Prudent management of one's finances is almost always necessary but almost never sufficient. Acknowledging this is not casting blame but rather observing the world around us, thinking critically about how it works, and accepting it as it really is: healthy things for any child to do from an early age.
- raintrees 12y agoBut your description sounds like a home the buyer lives in. That is not an investment, from an investor's point of view. Instead, for a specific example, consider a 4-plex my wife and I bought for $65K down ($215K total - it is in an economically depressed area). Rents, when fully occupied (not always the case, we see about a 5% vacancy rate) are $700 a month over all expenses, including debt service. Plus, we put close to 20% down but get 100% of the depreciation. End of the year: $7000 in our pockets, a legal tax loss of $800. And that is assuming no change in value of the asset. If someone offers to buy us out at %200 of the purchase price I would definitely consider it, but until then, I pocket the proceeds. For me, doing the due diligence up front reduced the luck factor, my preferred way of obtaining my goals, when possible.
- brc 12y agoWhat sort of area are you buying in? Where I live you cannot buy any real estate of any type for $200k. Are you buying out of state or out of country? How do you manage the risk?
- raintrees 12y agoDel Norte County California has many houses for less than $250,000, but single family homes do not "pencil out" here - The rents will not pay for the expenses. Multi-family units can, and the more units, the more likely they will. We also bought in Lee County Florida, where a single family home IS cash flowing. If the employment market stays stong, we will look at picking up more, assuming we find deals that are acceptable to us. Risk: Insurance (property and landlord's liability), entity (LLC), and strong property management that is tight on screening prospective tenants. Last, watchful management: We keep an eye on the Property Managers, and provide overall management decisions, like where to keep rents, what improvements/repairs to make, etc. We are new at this, only 5 years in, so we are still most definitely learning.
- raintrees 12y agoAnd I should have put this in the first comment I made: This is not legal advice, nor is it financial advice. Please seek professional guidance for specific situations. This only serves as an example of specific deals I am involved in - H/T to gamblor956 for reminding me to state this.
- WalterBright 12y agoI hear all the time about this time it's different. I heard it when I was young, too. In the early 80's, if you invested $1,000 in Boeing stock it'd be worth $60,000 today. I.e. you don't have to live a Spartan lifestyle to have an investment program, nor do you have to be unusually lucky, or any of that. Just underspend your income by 10 or 20%, and invest the rest in ordinary, boring investments.
- mistermann 12y agoBut I'm saying, that's not true in some places. There are many geographical regions (even countries) where median local wages cannot buy the median real estate - historic ratios are totally distorted.