3 ms·
It certainly makes sense from a marketing point of view, though even there it's possible to market a book to YA without making it a classification. I just don'
by JoshTriplett 12y ago
It certainly makes sense from a marketing point of view, though even there it's possible to market a book to YA without making it a classification. I just don't think the distinction makes sense as a top-level classification.
- dragonwriter 12y agoThe two purpose top-level classifications serve is (1) identifying where to look for retail customers, and (2) discussing distinct business market segments. I think it makes pretty good sense from both of those perspectives. It probably doesn't from the point of view that classifications should fit some neat content-description role, but that's never been the function that they actually serve except insofar as content descriptions have utility to the other purposes mentioned.
- JoshTriplett 12y ago(2) could be solved by marketing the same book differently. I agree that (1) has value, and (2) has some value when classifying customers. However, this thread started because many adult sci-fi and fantasy readers look down on YA books. That's the purpose for which I'd suggest that the distinction doesn't make much sense.