3 ms·
No, the serotonin insufficiency explanation for depression is mostly bullshit. Here is exactly the link for you: http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/04/05/chemical-i
by derefr 12y ago
No, the serotonin insufficiency explanation for depression is mostly bullshit. Here is exactly the link for you: http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/04/05/chemical-imbalance/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/04/05/chemical-imbalance/ (and a sequel: http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/04/18/polemical-imbalance/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/04/18/polemical-imbalance/)
> but there's a reason why first line treatment for depression or for anxiety disorders in the UK is not meds but is a (more expensive) talking therapy
It's not actually that the evidence is stronger (as in, there is more supporting evidence) but rather that the evidence suggests the effect size is stronger. Talk therapy is a really good way to treat anxiety in particular. It's a good prosthetic!
I'm not arguing that there's a 1:1 mapping of neurochemicals to disorders; in fact, that's almost certainly the opposite of the case, and one of the main reasons drugs don't seem to beat placebo is that there are bimodal distributions where a given drug will only work on the subset of people with a given symptom where that symptom is caused by that particular chemical imbalance.
Sometimes what clinical depression needs is a dopaminergic (e.g. Wellbutrin). Sometimes what social anxiety needs is an SNRI. It's all a mess. But that doesn't mean that it's not all chemicals, and that there isn't a combination of chemicals that wouldn't put things right in proper dosages. Neurotransmitters are how your brain does multicast electrochemical signalling; any message that's not just a local one between two synapses is travelling via a neurotransmitter.
(I apologize for feeding the troll; I just wanted to write that post above for a long time, and figured this would be a good time to do it. To said troll: I will note that I'm not arguing for the pharmaceutical industry as it stands. My own personal desire is to figure out a set of non-invasive tests that can measure effective "executive weight normalization" on various axes the way dual-N-back measures effective IQ, and then give people a "chemistry kit" of various -ergics, reuptake inhibitors, and inhibitors, and let them do their own science.)