3 ms·
In general, re-implementing a software product from open specifications has been protected by the courts. There are numerous examples, from the original IBM BIO
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
In general, re-implementing a software product from open specifications has been protected by the courts. There are numerous examples, from the original IBM BIOS to Microsoft BASIC to PostGres and BSD Unix. That said, the Google case is casting a shadow on programatic APIs, but 'look and feel' are essentially fair game.
What are protected and protectable are Trademarks. So using the word 'Slack' in the name or anything that looks like it came from the Slack web site (see the recent "Open Trello" flare up) will cause you legal issues and should be avoided entirely.
The most interesting "middle" case is if you want to host third party integrations which work on your system and Slack's then you're going to get some push back. But again, caveat things like patents, being enough workalike (or my favorite phrase bug-for-bug compatible) is well trodden and has consistently been shown to be ok. (see the latest Keurig fiasco for that!)
- bcg1 12y agoI'd like to add... the key test for trademarks is whether or not the use will cause confusion in the marketplace as to the origin of the product. So calling something "Open Slack" would almost assuredly not be fair game... while claiming that the product is "mostly compatible with the Slack API" would probably be fine, especially since it almost self-evidently implies that the product is not Slack. In any case, best to tread lightly with the use of their name at all, and certainly don't use it for marketing or promotion. Unlike patents and copyright, the only way to obtain and keep a trademark is to use it and defend it, so companies are rightfully aggressive in that regard.
- gergles 12y agoCan you share more info on the "Open Trello" thing? I didn't hear about that and it sounds interesting to see how it was resolved.
- toomuchtodo 12y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8936701 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8936701 https://github.com/libreboard/libreboard https://github.com/libreboard/libreboard https://github.com/libreboard/libreboard/issues/92 https://github.com/libreboard/libreboard/issues/92