3 ms·
The issue with renewables has always been cost, not theoretical efficiency limits. I recall computing (and then finding that others had computed on the Interne
by nostrademons 12y ago
The issue with renewables has always been cost, not theoretical efficiency limits. I recall computing (and then finding that others had computed on the Internet) that a 50x100mi array of solar panels in the Arizona desert could power the U.S. with energy left over, and that was at efficiency levels of a decade ago.
I talked to a couple founders at this year's startup school that said that solar was poised to reach grid parity with coal this year, i.e. without tax subsidies it would become cheaper to install solar panels than to buy that electricity from the electric company over the life of the panels. Pretty exciting times, if true.
- happyscrappy 12y agoNo the issue with renewables is storage.
- pkaye 12y agoDid you factor in the transmission losses to move the electricity from the Arizona desert to the rest of the US?
- SapphireSun 12y agoYou don't have to put it all in AZ, though I'm not sure what the efficiency impact would be. The AZ concept is a thought experiment to demonstrate a simple capability, not a fully engineered solution.
- CyberDildonics 12y agoNothing goes over my head, my reflexes are too fast.
- jonknee 12y agoAlso, night time.
- aidenn0 12y agoThat's only about 5% if we build HVDC lines.
- drostie 12y agoWell, it could power the U.S. if transportation weren't an issue. I worked with the Wind Energy Project Group several years back at the TU Delft and when I asked why the US didn't just exploit its huge reserves of wind and solar energy available, say in the Midwest, an engineer who worked there with me thumbed through some books and came up with some ballpark statistic, which I think was something like "1% power loss per hundred km" or so -- basically it meant that this was potentially feasible for powering Chicago with a wind farm in Iowa, or possibly even getting energy from Canada to New York City, the rest of the possibilities were far more limited. Maybe someone on HN is an actual engineer for one of these power companies and can give a more reliable figure? Solar grid parity would definitely be pretty awesome. Do you know whether the gains come from better efficiencies, or from cheaper manufacture? In any case, I'd caution HN on that: don't expect an immediate turn-over. It's sort of like how poor people are constrained by their food budgets to eat an obesity-inducing diet: solar power works well if you can buffer the more-up-front costs (investment, maintenance, the volatility in the electric bill induced by weather) with your budget in exchange for the long-term payoff, but that's just a really hard sell to people who are in the middle and lower-middle class.
- nostrademons 12y agoI'm going off a handful (~3-4) conversations with people in the industry, but my impression is that a large portion of the cost reductions come from economies of scale, particularly being driven by early-adopter industrial customers. The big problem with solar is that you need a large up-front R&D and tooling/manufacturing investment before you can produce any working installations at all. Amortized over a small production run, this isn't cost effective enough to get any companies off the ground. But the tax subsidies that the government poured into the industry were enough to make it cost effective enough to bring on some early industrial companies like Google profitably. The profits from industrial customers can then be used to subsidize early-adopter consumer R&D, which at sufficient scale operates profitably on a unit-installation basis, which can then be used to fund mass-market adoption. Positive feedback cycle, where eventually a tipping point is reached and solar takes over. As for getting it out to consumers: that's what financial arrangements are for. A friend of mine (in cloudy Massachusetts) has an interesting deal where he rents the solar panels from a company that basically charges him a flat fee < his electric bill, and guarantees a certain power output regardless of weather conditions (so they'll pay his electric bill if the panels don't generate what they say they'll generate). The company owns the panels, books any tax subsidies, pays for installation, and has the freedom to upgrade & reinstall as newer models come on the market. As a result, it's zero risk for him, and the company presumably has the industry knowledge and economies of scale to manage their risk appropriately. They could, for example, swap out his 1st gen panels as newer models come on the market and then send them to a sunnier location where they'd perform fine.
- dpierce9 12y agoElectricity costs vary considerably and solar is already at or better than grid-parity in a lot of places (e.g. Hawaii, Germany). Grid-parity is obviously a goal but does anyone think the current price of electricity contains the fully-loaded cost of carbon pollution and related externalities? Suppose you price carbon at $22 a ton. This is an order of magnitude less than the cost suggested by a team at Stanford. The result would be to drive up the average rate to about 15 cents per KWh. At that price, solar is better than grid-parity almost everywhere (on average etc). Whether that makes it a good investment is a different issue.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoIt seems silly to compare to coal because coal benefits from an enormous external subsidy: the coal power industry dumps its waste products into the atmosphere at no cost to itself.