4 ms·
Somehow this headline reminded me of the time the GIMP developers accidentally integrated GEGL in a few weeks. http://gimpfoo.de/2012/04/17/goat-invasion-in-gi
by phkahler 12y ago
Somehow this headline reminded me of the time the GIMP developers accidentally integrated GEGL in a few weeks.
http://gimpfoo.de/2012/04/17/goat-invasion-in-gimp/ http://gimpfoo.de/2012/04/17/goat-invasion-in-gimp/
"What was planned as a one week visit turned into 3 weeks of GEGL porting madness. At the time this article is written, about 90% of the GIMP application’s core are ported to GEGL..."
That was in 2012 and it's still not done. Almost, but not yet.
- guelo 12y agoThat GIMP refactoring looks like the CADT model[1] while these (accepted) Perl patches look more like the work of talented professionals. [1] http://www.jwz.org/doc/cadt.html http://www.jwz.org/doc/cadt.html
- phkahler 12y agoI hadn't seen that before. Good point. The purpose of a rewrite is usually claimed to be that progress can't be made with the code as-is. So one would expect that the rewrite would quickly show some progress beyond the old version.
- Someone 12y agoNot necessarily. If you are near the top of Mont Blanc, there's no way to go up far in small steps. If you are confident Mount Everest exists, you can decide to go walk there, but you certainly won't see progress for quite some time. There are equivalents in software, for example the removal of the GIL in Python (never done sucesfully in the sense that the majority of users started using it) or, equivalently, the effective GIL in OS kernels (done successfully a couple of times, AFAIK, even though it theoretically requires inspection of all driver source code) A JIT-ted Python similarly may eventually be the better choice, but the road getting there may be long and harsh.
- mst 12y agoOn the other hand, these patches are going to be in perl5 version 22, which is just getting its RC cycle started and should be out within a few weeks.
- phkahler 12y agoI guess the similarity to me had nothing to do with timing, but that when someone actually sat down to look at the problem the solution turned out to be relatively easy.