10 ms·
Fantasy must shake off the tyranny of the mega-novel
- guard-of-terra 12y agoSapkowski has a hilarious article on why fantasy authors tend to produce multi-volume monsters. "There is no gold in the Grey mountains", struggling to find it online.
- wakkadakka 12y agoIs it in English?
- guard-of-terra 12y agoI guess there should be a translation somewhere, he's a major writer after all.
- merrua 12y agoA lot of the shorter fantasy goes into the Young Adult category now. Especially since the younger age categories read more books a month. Fish around a bit for your own taste and you will find shorter novels and novellas there http://www.goodreads.com/choiceawards/best-young-adult-fantasy-books-2014 http://www.goodreads.com/choiceawards/best-young-adult-fanta...
- untothebreach 12y agoI tend to see a disdain for YA books in the SFF community. Which is sad, since many in the community still remember the (not-so-distant) past, when all of SFF was looked down upon by those who only read "real" literature. Romance, too, seems to get this attitude.
- OldSchoolJohnny 12y agoPersonally my disdain for them is that currently they are mostly telling the same basic story with different window dressing.
- swombat 12y agoWorth checking out Cory Doctorow's YA novels... they tend to be more varied than the typical fare - a good example of what you can do with the genre. Yes, there's a "coming of age", "figuring out what you want to do with your life" common element to them - but then one might argue that many alleged adults in today's world have not actually come of age yet. Maybe we need more of this stuff in our literature.
- kleer001 12y agoYes, if you can stand Doctorow's breast beating over EFF type themes of autonomy, government, security, etc... Which might be just your thing ;)
- swombat 12y agoHe's not breast-beating, just making a clear, compelling, well argued and well illustrated case... Or, you're right, it might well be my thing :-P
- kleer001 12y agoFair enough, lol. The only reason I call it breast beating is because it's such a clear departure from his very early work.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoThere are bad YA novels, and bad non-YA novels, in all genres, including fantasy. I've seen plenty of cookie-cutter fantasy stories in the standard fantasy section as well. And on the flip side, there are a lot of excellent fantasy novels squirreled away in the YA section where many people will overlook them.
- civilian 12y agoYeah, that attitude is odd. My strategy is to be intentionally clueless as to why anyone would have a problem with 28-year-old-me reading The Hunger Games.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoI find the whole "Young Adult" category strange. In film, most people don't automatically look down on movies just because they're not rated R or NC-17. Any book without blatantly adult-only content (which includes the majority of books) could reasonably be read by "Young Adults".
- kbenson 12y agoI think the problem is that "Young Adult" encompasses a wide level of maturity, and authors may tailor their works towards vastly different levels of maturity, that the quality can vary quite a bit. Some works are targeted for young readers, but are rather mature in their execution (well explained, well reasoned character motivations and plot, etc), while others bank on the possibly lower expectations of the young and inexperienced reader. I've picked up some horrendous young adult fiction before and read it (I'm looking at you, James Patterson!). That doesn't keep me from reading it, but it does make me wary...
- merrua 11y agoI've found word of mouth and reviews to help out with that. But its not 100% proof alright.
- dragonwriter 12y agoCategories are about marketing. "Young Adult" categorization is part of a decision to market primarily to the YA demographic, not a content-based description that the book can "reasonably by read by" young adults in a way that doesn't apply to most other books in a bookstore.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoIt certainly makes sense from a marketing point of view, though even there it's possible to market a book to YA without making it a classification. I just don't think the distinction makes sense as a top-level classification.
- 12y ago
- onewaystreet 12y agoThis is getting to be less and less true with the success of series like Harry Potter, Twilight, Hunger Games, The Maze Runner, Divergent etc. Many of the books listed on that Goodreads link are parts of larger series themselves.
- TillE 12y agoIn terms of format, I appreciate something like Raymond E. Feist's Riftwar Cycle, where you have a series of connected trilogies. You carry over the universe and some of the characters, but the story is tied up at the end of each trilogy. Or Fritz Leiber's Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser short stories, which were the individual adventures of those two characters. There's something obviously appealing about a universe (a "franchise" or "IP", if you must) which goes on and on, but that doesn't mean spending decades on a single story.
- panglott 12y agoFafhrd and the Mouser are an interesting case: There are seven (pretty short) volumes of stories, written over nearly forty years, with the major anthologies halfway through. Lots of those stories are just short vignettes, not more than a page or two long, that were nonetheless published individually. In the books, they seem like brief interludes, but they were originally written/published sometimes years apart from the longer stories. http://panglott.blogspot.com/2010/08/for-re-reading-of-nehwon.html http://panglott.blogspot.com/2010/08/for-re-reading-of-nehwo...
- iamlolz 11y agoMost fantasy readers tend to dismiss Feist's work, it's good to find someone else who appreciates it.
- teirce 12y agoThis is one reason why I really like Neil Gaiman. His works tend to be on the shorter side and self-contained, yet still managed to be quite entertaining.
- mklim 12y agoI grew up just reading whatever I could pull off the shelf from my local library—finding the SFF short story scene in my late teens was a huge and welcome discovery. Not sure why, and it could just be confirmation bias, but in my experience the quality of writing in short stories tends to be a lot higher than the writing in a novel, or series. Short form has some of my favorite works now, and I tend to read that first since it's much easier to make time for. It's really worth looking into it if you've only been exposed to published novels before. Tor.com is free and has a great collection. Clarkesworld and Asimov's both charge subscription fees but are completely worth the price.
- markbnj 12y agoOh Lord, yes. Signed. Upvoted. Just give us good stories with a scope the author can deal with in a human lifetime.
- m3mnoch 12y agoit feels like it's starting to get shaken out. the whole mega-popular digital book thing is enabling wider distribution of formats like novellas. heck, even sanderson is getting in on the gig with all of his recent success with the shorter novels like "the emperor's soul" or "legion" -- which are both fantastic, btw.
- davidwparker 12y agoIt's interesting that they mainly start around more recent series, mentions older ones "Les Mis", but don't say how this is and always has been a thing. I remember reading most of the Xanth series (first book published in 1977!) when I was in high school (1999)- and there were already 20+ books in the series. I like long stories about characters I care about. When I stop caring about the characters (or if the plots get too out there), then I stop reading the books. I think it's fine if people want to read singular episode books as well. As @teirce says, this is why I also like Neil Gaiman (currently my favorite author). His stuff is self-contained and quite enjoyable. It's up to the author to decide what they want to do with their characters, and I'll be game for it either way.
- svachalek 12y agoAs I remember them, the Xanth stories had an order but mostly stood on their own, like the detective novels TFA mentions. In contrast, there's hardly anything in Game of Thrones that isn't tied tightly to everything that precedes or follows it. The division between books is largely arbitrary and you could have divided them up in a million different ways that would be no better or worse than the way they are now. Not that this is qualitatively better than the older series or serial style, but I do agree with the article that it's "different".
- beat 12y agoSprawling multi-book series work kind of the way fast food does. It's a known quantity in a world of unknown quantities.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoIt's also the most reliable path to income for writers.
- mynegation 12y agoIt is somewhat surprising result in the world of short attention span. I stopped watching Game of Thrones after 3.5 seasons, stopped reading Terry Goodkind's Sword of Truth after 4.5 books and Zelazny's Chronicles of Amber after 2.5 books (notice the pattern of dropping the things halfway through the installment). For me it sort of goes downhill from production value and/or captivating action to a pointless nonsense _with no end in sight_.
- jerf 12y agoI've noticed that my brain has developed an actual revulsion to fiction that never ends attains closure on anything. It is starting to feel very similar to the dream most of us have had of the quicksand we can't get out of because however high we go it's always higher. I don't mean that as a metaphor, I mean, I really do get a very similar feeling out of both. So many of these things seem to start out tight, then just drag out forever. I have more experience in the TV-series side. I am happy to not have all the answers, I'm happy to watch something overarching that goes on for a while, I'm even happy to watch something that ends ambiguously. But I've got little and ever less tolerance for those authors who think the way to make their universe last longer is to never resolve anything. No... you resolve things, and then there are more things. Preferably consequences, anticipated and otherwise. Just like, you know, real life. Don't simply stretch your story out... and out... and out... and out... Stargate SG-1 attained the nearly-perfectly-correct balance for me. And it made some of the developments in that series legitimately surprising to me, when they actually upended their universe a bit in several of the season finales, because I so casually expected "nothing to ever change" in a series like that. (Now it's more normal, but at the time especially I was surprised by their boldness. They never did quite take the step of making the program public knowledge, though...) (Special callout for Alias, by the way, who also scraped against my brain in such a way that I'm also extremely irritated by "but wait, there's a conspiracy behind that"... by the fourth or fifth time it's like the dream hallway that never ends. And my suspension of disbelief really breaks down too... how, exactly, does one become the guy in change of the conspiracy under the conspiracy under the conspiracy under the conspiracy under the conspiracy under the conspiracy? Is there a college track I should be focusing on for that? Does the n+1th conspiracy conduct secret interviews? Is a member of conspiracy-4 really supposed to be surprised to discover conspiracy-5?)
- thelsdj 12y agoThis is needed if only so I don't have to get sucked into a great first book like Wizard's First Rule to then have to deal with 100 page lectures on Objectivism if I want to find out what happens to the characters later in the series.
- ars 12y agoVery much yes! That series was a disaster. It's not even internally consistent from the first book to the last. The author completely changed his characters to make them fit into his new lectures.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- VieElm 12y agoIf anyone is interested in a great single volume fantasy book, I recommend Tigana by Guy Gavriel Kay. It's a very good book.
- NathanKP 12y agoThanks I'll check it out. I'll add my own recommendation: anything by China Mieville. Although he does have a few books that are set in the same fantasy world they are each stand alone storylines although they may loosely reference each other (kind of like the Discworld series does). He also has quite a few single volume books, each with its own rich and fascinating world.
- smegel 12y agoOh God yes. I look back my days of reading D&D novels (Krynn and TFR mostly) with some fondness. Yes they were part of much larger series, but the books were usually fully contained novels with strong story-lines and conclusions. Sci-fi is in a similar situation (if you did not consider sci-fi to be fantasy in the first place). Remember reading (possibly your parents collection of) Isaac Asimoc novels? Or possibly novelettes by today's standards. Amazing stories and imaginations in what would be the prologue of a 1500 page monster today. And without the constant graphic violence that has become a hallmark of modern sci-fi.
- gknoy 12y agoI've read great short fiction, but nearly every time I read something Really Awesome or Interesting, I end up wanting to read more exploring interesting things in that world. Parallel events, precursors, Lore, etc. I dislike when there's a constant "To be Continued...." (Wheel of Time, Game of Thrones), but love when there's a series of related books that each can stand alone, but also enrich a shared lore. I absolutely devoured nearly everything in the Dragonlance novels and Star Wars extended universe books, for example. Whenever I read the first book of a book like Dune, or Foundation, or Earthsea, or Anne Leckie's Ancillary Justice, or the Diamond Age (or Snow Crash) I end up wishing for more from that same universe of Lore. Sometimes this ends up being something amazing, like the Foundation series, other times the sequel fails to hold me, or goes off the deep end like some fantasy serieses seem to. I think I end up gravitating towards trilogies. I know there's more to the story arc than just one book, and but enough written that I (in theory) won't be left in the lurch. :-) Then again, I also read all [at the time] of the Honor Harrington series, because I loved the characters and political story arc(s), but ended up getting burned out and never reading the more recent novels. I don't even know or recall if it was a feeling that it jumped the shark, I just didn't feel I had the energy to devote to it.
- caseysoftware 12y agoHuge Krynn fan here too. My annoyance with the mega-novels are the sheer number of characters and threads which are happening simultaneously. In the Wheel of Time there are three main characters - which is a reasonable number of threads - but in one of the books, one of them was hardly included at all. It's weird coming back to a character after 300, 400, or even 600 pages. They start to feel like afterthoughts. And GOT is even worse. There are dozens of threads and some of the characters names are similar enough to be annoying.
- colomon 12y agoI have to admit I'm kind of puzzled by this article and its countering article "Fantasy cannot build its imaginary worlds in short fiction." Look. There is great fantasy fiction being written in every length. And that's a wonderful situation! Why spend your time complaining because some works aren't the length you would prefer?
- kbutler 12y agoI think the response is more accurate - that big ideas and epic world-building require a lot of space. http://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2015/may/20/fantasy-imaginary-worlds-george-r-r-martin-robin-hobb http://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2015/may/20/fanta... And I would cite Brandon Sanderson as a good example (and good counter-example to the original article) - smaller ideas get novellas (Legion, Emperor's Soul), medium-sized ideas get novels (Elantris, Rithmatist, Warbreaker), epic ideas get large novels in series(Mistborn, Way of Kings). All excellent, by the way...
- fabian2k 12y agoOne huge point in Sanderson's favor is that he writes fast and consistent enough that his epic series might be finished in a reasonable amount of time. I also get the impression that he plans a lot more in advance than many other fantasy writers, so I doubt he'll add a few more novels to his series at the end.
- mattmanser 12y agoBrandon Sanderson is a truly unique author though, his output at the moment is phenomenal. I'm not entirely sure what the point of the original article was though, mega-novels, otherwise known as series to normal people, are a common thing in sci-fi and fantasy and always have been.
- panglott 12y agoThere's no way that page counts are a reflection of the size of the ideas in the book. You can huge ideas and absolutely marvellous worlds in under 200 pages. Maybe the book doesn't have 1000+ named characters. but why would that be an important metric?
- vanderZwan 12y ago> that big ideas and epic world-building require a lot of space. That's not the same as requiring a mega-novel. You can have a series of stories set in one universe. Just look at Discworld. Or superhero comics, for that matter.
- gaius 12y ago
- adwf 12y agoI've completely given up on reading multi-volume epics. Either stick to a defined 3 or 4 novel series (ie. call it a trilogy from the start), or go with a series of interconnected, but standalone, novels like Iain M Banks Culture books. The major problem I find is that I just can't be bothered to re-read the previous books. Yet inevitably, I will have forgotten a lot of characters and plot (particularly with character dense fantasy), and must re-read or be completely lost when reading the new book. This isn't really a problem with trilogies, usually I don't need to re-read at all for the final book, or even if I do it's relatively quick. But the moment you start writing huge, 5-6+ novel series I get very annoyed with authors. Take George RR Martin for example. I still haven't read the latest book, simply because there was a 5 year gap, then a 6 year gap between publications of the last two. During that time, I've nearly completely forgotten what went on in the books. I re-read after the first gap, but I'll be damned if I'm doing it again... There are successful authors who manage to write large, interesting worlds/stories without needing to descend down into the muck that is the mega-novel series. Like Iain M Banks with his standalone Culture novels that form a coherent world over time. Or Terry Pratchett, with the Discworld.
- dkersten 12y agoThe major problem I find is that I just can't be bothered to re-read the previous books. Agreed. I've found this happen a few times. For example, in one series, I read about 6 books and then didn't have time or for some other reason didn't continue. I thought about going back and finishing the series maybe a year and a half later, but didn't feel like rereading the previous 6 books but felt too lost without doing so. This happens to me with TV programs too.
- Eridrus 12y agoI love myself some big epic fantasy, The Malazan Book of the Fallen series was a huge favourite of mine, followed closely by A Song of Ice and Fire, but this is a pretty real logistical problem even for me. I have gone and read the Ian Esslemont books in the Malazan universe though, precisely because they are disconnected from the main plot. Maybe I'll go back and re-read these series after they're complete.
- lobster_johnson 12y agoThe reason fantasy (and also much scifi these days) needs the length is partly because once you've gone to all that effort of establishing a world, you'll want to stick that world. A short novel with a completely unique setting would turn a fantasy story into something closer to a fairy tale or fable, or be entirely about the setting (as is often the case with scifi; Lem's "Solaris" is a great example). Of course, you can still tell completely separate stories set within a single world. Which authors do: Banks with the Culture books, for example, and I rather prefer that form of non-serial storytelling. G. R. R. Martin himself has written spinoffs set in the Westeros world. Gene Wolfe's novels are often set in the same universe. The second aspect of serial, "long-form" storytelling that everyone enjoys is the continuity; you may have lots of small stories told over the course of several seasons of a TV series, but it's the same, familiar world, and you don't need to be introduced to a completely new setting every time. As someone who greatly enjoys books (though not so much fantasy) but has a huge problem getting past the opening chapter or even the opening page, I completely understand the attraction. (That said, there's no excuse for bloat. G. R. R. Martin seems to have entered into a kind of narrative tailspin as a result of having plotted himself into several corners. Rather than chopping away at the narrative and making some shortcuts to get the characters in the position he had planned for them to be in, he apparently decided the solution was... more plot. The end product was the long and tedious boat journey that was "A Dance With Dragons".)
- panglott 12y agoNot just mega-novels, it seems like the long novel of 400-600 pages are more common too. Seems like back in the day you could get a good story in 150-200 pages. But now reading books is a bigger commitment. I think I'm going to start on the "novella" category of the Hugo winners =/
- seasoup 12y agoI agree! My book is 175 pages because I tried to keep in the good parts and trust the reader to figure out why character A got to point B without explaining the entire journey. Skip to the interesting parts and let a couple lines of some dialogue explain the in between.
- cwbrandsma 12y agoBetter are books that can be read on their own...and are part of an expansive series * Foundation * Dune * Discworld * Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy * Hyperion Even worse are 5 book sets (Belgarion and Eddings novels)