3 ms·
When people say "trade agreements NEED to be negotiated in secret" this is why. It's hard to pack them with horrors like this, otherwise. You'll be told "blah
by Zigurd 11y ago
When people say "trade agreements NEED to be negotiated in secret" this is why. It's hard to pack them with horrors like this, otherwise.
You'll be told "blah blah regulatory protectionism blah."
When was the last time a regulatory protectionism story was in the news, compared with weakening environmental protections or ratcheting up bad IP laws?
It's not about nationalists clinging to sovereignty. It's not about luddite workers. It's about stuffing treaties with crap like this.
- lumberjack 11y agoWhat's exactly wrong with nationalists clinging to sovereignty? What's wrong with economic protectionism? I see sensible reasons for both.
- jacquesm 11y agoThere is nothing wrong with either if they are transacted out in the open so they can be weighted accordingly. When done in secret you can end up with something that you would not have chosen without protest or input but are nevertheless bound by.
- astazangasta 11y agoThe comparative advantage arguments are not even that great, in my opinion. https://fixingtheeconomists.wordpress.com/2014/05/01/arguments-against-free-trade-and-comparative-advantage/ https://fixingtheeconomists.wordpress.com/2014/05/01/argumen... >Ricardo took the example of trade between England and Portugal. He argued that England, by allowing imports of wine from Portugal, would expand the production and export of cloth to pay for it. Ricardo, of course, was thinking of the English side of the exchange but the analysis is perfectly symmetrical; it implies that Portugal will gain from specialising on wine and importing cloth. In reality, the imposition of free trade on Portugal killed off a promising textile industry and left her with a slow-growing export market for wine, while for England, exports of cotton cloth led to accumulation, mechanisation and the whole spiraling growth of the industrial revolution.