3 ms·
There is no need these days for brevity with methods since everything is online. Put it all into the SI and be done with it. One problem with many methods is t
by danieltillett 12y ago
There is no need these days for brevity with methods since everything is online. Put it all into the SI and be done with it.
One problem with many methods is the lack of description of the pitfalls and critical steps. When you go to repeat an experiment you often don't have exactly the same equipment or reagents as the original paper. Most of the time this does not matter, but in an annoying number of cases some particular step needs to be performed using a precise piece of equipment or brand of reagent. It is only when you can't get the experiment to work and you contact the person on the bench who did the research that you learn "yeh we tried all the other reagents and only brand x works". If there is something critical put it in the method that it is critical!
- Thriptic 12y agoIn my experience a lot of very critical steps in experiments are frequently never formally defined in literature or even within lab notebooks, existing only as institutional knowledge. What may seem like an obvious step not worth docimenting to the original investigators is non-obvious to people looking to repeat the work, leading to different results.