3 ms·
I'm dubious about the "over-screening" problem. At the moment it may be that we would overreact to every pre-cancerous spot. But surely once we're used to scr
by rwmj 12y ago
I'm dubious about the "over-screening" problem. At the moment it may be that we would overreact to every pre-cancerous spot. But surely once we're used to screening and have done the studies over years, we'll know which cancers can be ignored and which ones need to be treated. [This assumes of course that whole body screening can be made very cheap and easy]
- exelius 12y agoIf you look for problems, you will find them. Medicine is a science, but it's not an exact science, so something that's a problem in one person may be normal for another person. There are also so many external factors that go into a diagnosis and recommendation that a simple scan can never give the whole story. Most often doctors do tests just because they can bill for them and it increases the amount of money they make per patient -- this is one of the biggest reasons the US spends so much on health care. And there's no effort going in to doing these studies you describe. Sure, someone somewhere may be doing something, but there's not a critical mass of dollars behind it like there are in pharmaceuticals, medical devices, etc. Health care privacy laws also make it nearly impossible to do these kinds of studies. I used to work for a startup that tried this -- they eventually found a market in Canada and Europe but they ended up going under along with all of their competitors because nobody is willing to pay for these types of studies unless you can prove either a cost reduction or improved quality of care at the same cost.
- jasonmp85 12y agoLook at the thyroid cancer graph: over twenty years the detection rate has increased by about 15x without any concomitant decrease in mortality. With any diagnostic measure, you must ask whether the information it produces is actionable. If anything, they way you've phrased it is backward: first we find a new treatment (via research) and once it gives us an action to perform, then we can justify the screening. If catching a cancer earlier helps, screen. If not (prostate or breast screenings too early in life), don't. Obviously if you have family history, risk factors, or something with high specificity like a BRCA mutation, you treat. But many of those things are discovered with a simple history/physical (H&P), which is the important screening your primary physician should be performing.
- breischl 12y agoBut notice that pretty much every screen has a false positive rate. So some percentage of the healthy people screened are going to be incorrectly told that their sick, and therefore get treated for an illness they don't have. The more people you screen, the more that's going to happen. And when the treatments are things like surgery, chemotherapy, radiation, etc, that's a pretty big deal. Also, not everything that shows up in a screen was going to be a problem. It could be that it might have never been a problem. Quoting Wikipedia about mammography: >> While this ability to detect such very early breast malignancies is at the heart of claims that screening mammography can improve survival from breast cancer, it is also controversial. This is because a very large proportion of such cases will not progress to kill the patient, and thus mammography cannot be genuinely claimed to have saved any lives in such cases; in fact, it would lead to increased sickness and unnecessary surgery for such patients. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breast_cancer_screening#Criticisms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breast_cancer_screening#Critic...