2 ms·
The real story is that our spy agencies are indiscriminately spying on us with no oversight, despite the fact that they are not supposed to, and that they tell
by btilly 12y ago
The real story is that our spy agencies are indiscriminately spying on us with no oversight, despite the fact that they are not supposed to, and that they tell people who should give oversight (eg Congress) that they aren't.
All of the variations and permutations of that are part of the same story.
PRISM was a particularly egregious example. And US companies are now losing billions/year because people in other countries won't trust data to them. Furthermore it was shocking to me that it was carried out in such a way that the people in charge of the companies were not allowed to know about what was happening inside of their own companies.
That said, nobody has been shouting from the rooftops what I consider the most disturbing part of what I understand about it. And that is that any NSA analyst who wishes to get involved in politics can simply start digging up information on what is happening inside campaigns they don't like, and then can feed it to campaigns they do like. Nobody has to know about it. The campaigns already hire people to follow other campaigns, and those people already get tips. So you've just got a really good anonymous tipster. Think of it as a version of Watergate on steroids with plausible deniability and no physical burglary to leave traces.
But it gets better. According to the interpretation of the Constitution that the NSA operates under, deliberately attempting to find out which NSA agents were looking at Americans is a search of said Americans, which is prevented by the 4th. This is why they could not, by their own rules, tell Congress how many Americans had been accidentally searched.
If my understanding of this policy is correct, then the NSA is operating under rules that mean that they cannot even try to monitor for rogue agents who are doing what I just suggested.
Now let's suppose that we trust 99.9% of NSA agents to be good people, following the internal rules and operating in good faith.
It just takes ONE acting in bad faith to distort our political system. And enough thousands of people have access that I consider it guaranteed that this nightmare scenario is actually happening.
Scared yet?