5 ms·
The point is to ensure they can contact you. Same reason websites have email confirm links, basically.
by derefr 12y ago
The point is to ensure they can contact you. Same reason websites have email confirm links, basically.
- Coding_Cat 12y agoYes, but the point the OP is making is that it is a worthless guarantee. You can just use a throw-away email. And given the target audience, this is should not even be considered a significant barrier.
- corin_ 12y agoI presume it's attempting (badly) to deal with website owners who aren't contactable by mistake, not those who actively wish to be uncontactable.
- lisper 12y agoDisabling their domains seems like a pretty heavy-handed way of dealing with owners who can't be contacted due to an honest mistake. I mean, geez, a false positive from a spam filter can cause you to lose your domain!
- puredemo 12y agoDomains are suspended, not deleted from the registry.
- talideon 12y agoWell, blame the law-enforcement agencies: they're the ones that forced ICANN's hand on this. The registrars, particularly the European ones, fought back, and the policy is nowhere near as bad as it once was going to be. However, even before now, you could easily lose your domain due to a missed email. For instance, if you don't have your domain on autorenew, it can end up in redemption (which is expensive), and eventually deleted. And, as of the 2013 RAA, if you don't renew your domain, your registrar is required to park the domain with a non-renewal notice a few days after its expiration date. Fun, eh?
- talideon 12y agoA throwaway email address would be a bad idea, as you periodically have to confirm the address works.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- eli 12y agoBut if they're able to contact you then the exercise was pointless and if they're NOT able contact you they disable your domain. How does that help anyone?
- dangrossman 12y agoAssume that the purpose of this exercise is to ensure there's some way to deliver a court order, subpoena or other law enforcement notice to a domain owner. In that context, this is going to ensure either (a) there's at least an e-mail on file that reaches the current owner, or (b) the domain can't be used for any illegal purpose, so the issue is moot. It's not a perfect system, but it'll probably do the job in 99%+ of cases.
- ghshephard 12y agoExcept that I would never want my name/email associated with a domain name - spam central. My registrar has my contact information when it comes to renewal, or to contact me for an issue, but the domain names all have dummy values.
- talideon 12y agoGet WHOIS privacy from your registrar. If you've provided invalid contact information on the domain, you're in breach of the TOS, as ICANN requires that domains have accurate contact data on them.
- eli 12y agoThat's ostensibly why the system is good for lawyers and law enforcement. It seems like it's only bad for domain owners. And I really question how useful it is for even the purpose you outlined. Considering that a) your registrar could easily be subpoenaed for this information if there's a genuine need and b) Anyone who has the tech savvy to register a domain with plans to do something illegal with it surely also realizes they can register a free email under a bogus name.
- PeterisP 12y ago