3 ms·
Debt is a tool--a really powerful one. Leaving it out of your financial toolbox can be quite limiting and make it harder to achieve financial stability. Most pe
by snowwrestler 12y ago
Debt is a tool--a really powerful one. Leaving it out of your financial toolbox can be quite limiting and make it harder to achieve financial stability. Most people do so out of a vague unease about it, rather than a full accounting for their risks and opportunities.
Yes, taking on debt is a risk, but it is far from the worst financial risk you can face, because it is predictable and often tax-advantaged. If taken on for the right reasons, it can provide leverage to achieve returns that would otherwise be unavailable.
For example, using mortgage to purchase property when you are young provides more time for compound appreciation of your property. And at least in the U.S., people who earn college degrees when they are young have average lifetime earnings improvements well in excess of the typical student loan costs.
- moron4hire 12y ago>> If taken on for the right reasons... Most people don't take it for the right reasons. They take it because they've been told to. And they aren't doing anything towards enhancing their understanding of debt. For example, lots of people will go into debt to go on international trips. We structure our travel on our credit card and pay it off right away because it pays us to fly again! But most people don't have that system in place, they run up the credit card debt and then take 6 months to pay it off. I just plain hate the idea of paying for something today that I used up yesterday. And I don't think the emotional impact can be overlooked. Even if you can make an argument to me that it would be "smart" to carry a transient purchase as debt (and I know you're not going to try to, I'm just making a hypothetical), I'd still feel bad about it, and that bad feeling is going to have a real impact on my quality of life. Before I was finally out of debt, I paid off my student loans before I paid off my car (when I had a car) because even though the APR was higher on the car, I could pay off the student loans sooner. It's a snowballing effect. It felt like an accomplishment and it helped me maintain my frugality. Telling someone with $30k in credit card debt (I know several people like this, it's not that uncommon these days) that they shouldn't run a balance on their credit cards isn't helping them. You've not told them anything they don't already know. But maybe they don't already know that they don't have to have a big house. That's the intention of my story, to try to jolt people out of their half-waking state. People aren't perfectly rational beings and it's probably stupid to expect them to be so. But there are simple rules of thumb that I think people can take to heart that will improve their overall outcome much better than telling them "you need to consider and be careful with the debt". People work much better with all-or-nothing measures, rather than measures that rely on subtlety and restraint. It's probably why no-carb diets work out better than calorie counting. It's not because carbs are particularly unhealthy, it's that people can't constrain themselves to the small portions necessary to count calories while eating complex carbohydrates. I know I can't. So what makes more sense? To repeatedly fail at exercising restraint? Or to succeed at a slightly less efficient plan? Even taking on a mortgage is most of the time a bad call for most people. They live in the house for 5 to 10 years, then move before they get even close to realizing the potential of the property. Then, instead of getting a similar-sized place, they get something larger, something that fits inside their paycheck. Even if they sold their previous house for a net profit, they just roll that over into the new house. The net effect is that they are constantly renting from the bank. That only makes sense if the mortgage costs less than rent for a similar place. If it doesn't, it's smarter to rent a place and sink the difference into a fund for buying a place when it does make sense to buy. But most people aren't going to keep track of their finances like that.
- snowwrestler 12y agoThe general form of the problem is poor understanding of personal finance. I just think that reflexively avoiding debt is more of a symptom of that problem than a solution. For example, the idea that "taking on a mortgage is most of the time a bad call for most people" is just not supported by the data. About 65% of the homes in the U.S. are owned, and most of those are households that are financially stable. Even in the depths of the financial crisis, well under 10% of homes entered foreclosure each year (i.e. 90+% were stable). And there are national correlations between homeownership and positive things like income, academic achievement, lower crime, etc.