41 ms·
Where is the value in this article? The author tells us he likes to relax and so doesn't work full-time, therefore no one should. Beyond stating the obvious of
by chrisacree 11y ago
Where is the value in this article? The author tells us he likes to relax and so doesn't work full-time, therefore no one should.
Beyond stating the obvious of having more free time, he never really states any benefits of working part time. And he doesn't mention the hardships the undoubtedly come with it like lower salary and how they might be abated.
Overall, just feels like a brag about how great he is.
- aluhut 11y agoAnd an unspoken brag about how much money he must have besides his job. Maybe we should mail him and ask for a job.
- gregd 11y agoBut you don’t have to listen to me, part-time mountain dweller and full-time maverick. Here’s Carlos Slim, the world’s second richest man: “We should be working only 3 days a week.” It is time, he says, for a radical overhaul of our working lives. We need more time to relax, for quality of life. Quoting the world's second richest man as a backup to your argument (about working less), comes off as pretentious. Those of us that work as hard as we do, want the same things, working less, enjoying life more, slowing down. Unfortunately, life is expensive. Our incomes have stagnated and our dollar buys less. I'd love to only work 3 days a week, but at my current salary, I'd have to live in a tent with my family of 4 and eat ramen and the occasional squirrel.
- andegre 11y agoYep, if he'd pay my salary for the other 2 working days per week, I'd do the same thing...
- basseq 11y ago> I'd have to live in a tent with my family of 4 and eat ramen and the occasional squirrel. Or a "stone cottage in the Kumaon". We've been trained to maximize the curve: could you live an albeit different life on 60% of your pay and work three days a week? Most of us work five days a week: why don't you work all seven days a week and make 40% more?
- gregd 11y agocould you live an albeit different life on 60% of your pay and work three days a week? Yes. It consists of a tent, eating ramen and the occasional squirrel.
- balabaster 11y agoYou haven't really considered the alternatives available to you. A non-exhaustive list of possible solutions include: Do you have a yard or patio space? Start growing your own produce. Seeds are cheap and with a bit of time and love will pay you back forever more. Tomatoes, peppers and herbs will all grow well on a window sill. Potatoes, onions and garlic will all grow in a bag in the back of the pantry if you let them. You can multiply potatoes, onions and garlic quite easily. A big bag of flour can be found cheap (Costco for instance), make your own bread/pasta. That way you can supplement your Ramen with nutritious meals without breaking the bank. If you're in California (or somewhere else with a high amount of sunlight, which many HN readers appear to be) perhaps think about the option of solar panels on your roof to reduce your power bill (flyers and auctions are great places to find these cheap, Google will help you with installation and then you just need to find an inspector). Actually look at everything you spend money on in a month and ask yourself if there's a cheaper way to get those things without costing you so much money... and really look for solutions, you'd be surprised what you can find with a bit of ingenuity/creativity.
- gregd 11y agoHow would you know I haven't really considered the alternatives to living cheaper? I don't have a yard to grow vegetables. We live in an apartment. When we lived in Portland, we had a yard to grow vegetables but our monthly water bill was prohibitively expensive (we're talking hundreds of dollars every 3 months). Costco has a yearly membership fee, which I think at a minimum, is up to $75/year. I work full time and my wife is in school full time in another city. We have 2 children (I have 4 altogether) who are school age. How the fuck am I supposed to make bread and pasta? Our rent is just shy of $1400/month. Buying solar panels? What do solar panels cost nowadays and how much is installation? I can't install solar panels in my apartment. I don't have a car payment because our only car is paid off. Except for student loans, we are debt free. Edited to add: The other huge expense for us now is healthcare. The cost of healthcare for a family of 4 is astronomical.
- balabaster 11y agoNot bad for a guy I never heard of before... I'm working towards this myself. Homesteading is an easy way to move in this direction without needing such riches. It's not as much work as everyone says - though the work there is, is mostly physical. Your math/programming skills will help immensely if you want to build and automate everything yourself, which will make your life even easier in the long run. Your dollar buys much more when you grow all your own produce, dairy and meat. Seeds are cheap, a couple of cows, a couple of pigs and a handful of chickens will cost you far less than your annual meat/dairy bill and give you all the meat/dairy you could want indefinitely. The only thing that's prohibitive is growing enough wheat for flour - and only prohibitive from a space standpoint; but flour is cheap and making your own bread is easy. You don't need to live off Ramen and Squirrel. Rabbits breed like... well, rabbits and they're pretty tasty, cheap to keep, pretty hassle free and their manure is great for compost. Of course, slaughter isn't a pleasant experience, it's not all sunshine and light. I'm just an average guy, with an average income working an average 40 hours a week with a family. If I can afford it, then I'd wager that a decent portion of HN readers can afford it too. Life can be expensive if you let it, but there are many ways to live cheap and have a fulfilling life. If city life is too expensive for you to have a good work/life balance, you're living in the wrong place and working in the wrong job or working for the wrong company... unless you live to work, if you do, then more power to you.
- gregd 11y agoI'm not arguing against homesteading and it's actually been a dream of mine. However, marriage and children has altered my reality in ways that affect my ability to create a homestead. Here in the states, you still, at a minimum, have property taxes, utilities, car/gas, etc to pay for even if you want to live a homesteading life. I lived this way for a decent portion of my childhood. We had no running water and a 12 volt electrical system in the middle of nowhere in Northern California.
- balabaster 11y agoI've got a family too... I was your typical city dweller/consumer until very recently. I'm not saying that you have to give up everything that comes with city life, I'm merely suggesting get creative. For sure taxes still need to be paid... do you have a spare room? Could you AirBnB to supplement your income? Could you reduce your utilities by switching up some stuff in your house? Perhaps it would be cheaper for a gas stove than electric? Could you put solar panels on your roof to sell electricity back to the grid? Could you get a bike and ride more places to use less gas? Would having septic save money on waste? Could you hang dry your laundry instead of using a dryer? Not saying that all or any of those are feasible for anyone/everyone, just offering some solutions that many people overlook when they think they're stuck and unable to reduce their costs any further and these things can be switched up without changing your lifestyle much/any. Some of them have a (in some cases large) up front cost, but then your monthly expenses can be reduced significantly which reduces your longer term income needs. ...and I don't know how you lived without running water, that's something I just can't give up, along with my washer and dishwasher.
- chrisBob 11y agoIn the US reducing your hours is often ever worse than just taking the fractional pay cut: part time jobs don't typically include benefits, so you end up with much less than 60% pay for 60% of the work. If it weren't for health insurance this would seem like a much more reasonable option.
- humanrebar 11y ago> If it weren't for health insurance this would seem like a much more reasonable option. If health insurance (or childcare or disability insurance, etc.) weren't tied to employment, this would be a much more reasonable option. The first step towards more flexible work arrangements is to eliminate gap in taxes between self-purchased benefits and employer-provided benefits. This goes for everything from snacks to health insurance. It's silly and really an fairness issue (should the little guy needs a big employer to take care of him?).
- panjaro 11y agoPoint is: Why do we work more when we have machines that do work? Aren't machines build to help us? Doesn't that mean we should have more time for ourselves?
- crusso 11y agoThe people who own the machines that do the work do have more time for themselves.
- balabaster 11y agoThe people who own the machines still charge for the products those machines produce for profit. Their profits have gone up, the retail cost of the products they produce hasn't gone down. Consumers still need to find the same money to purchase those products and so they still have to work to make that money. Having machines doing most of the work helps nobody reduce their workload. All it does is make those that can afford to buy the machines to do their jobs have more time and/or long term profit. If you can't afford to buy a machine to do your job, there is no opportunity to reduce your income needs without reducing or finding more creative ways to provide for your material needs.
- prostoalex 11y ago> the retail cost of the products they produce hasn't gone down. I disagree, with almost anything that has both a handmade and a mass-produced version, the mass-produced variant will be cheaper - t-shirts, soap, mugs, suits, etc.
- prostoalex 11y agoThe society still needs a homo sapiens to intervene when the machine flashes "Unknown item in the bagging area", though. Also, define "we". There used to be an entire substrata of people whose job was to pull the elevator to the right floor when requested by the customers entering the elevator. It looks like those guys are all finally relaxing somewhere on the beach now that we've invented automated elevators eith buttons.
- ndarilek 11y agoI didn't get that at all. In particular, he lists several regrets that those dying experience about their lives. My impression is that many of those regrets stem from spending too much time on things that others, rather than the self, find important in life. Speaking for myself, there was a time in my life when I wanted to create and raise a family, wanted to own a house, because that's what people told me I should do. Yet here I am in my 30s. I have a happy relationship that for various reasons isn't aimed at having kids or owning property. I rent an apartment in a co-op community which, while it certainly offers its own challenges, also brings rich memories that I may not have had were I living in my own house in the suburbs. I'm bootstrapping a software company, which is significantly easier without a mortgage and 2.5 additional mouths to feed. And I'm happy. I wake up when I like, put in 20 or so hours per week of real work, then spend time reading or exercising or working on fun projects. That's not to say I'm better than anyone else, and not everyone has the luxury to choose as I have. But I'd likely not be here, with the freedoms and lack of stress I have had I chosen the life others said I should, which is what I took away from reading this. And it's not all easy. Sometimes I look at those of you who are younger and have done more in your 20s than I could ever imagine, and question my choices. Then I realize that my life brings its own rewards, and it's good to externally be reminded of that sometimes. There are certainly plenty of other reminders that someone with my talents could likely be raking in lots of money right now if they pursued a different path, and sometimes those are hard to disregard. :) Also, as someone who has chosen to not pursue the rat race, I often feel pushback and criticism from those who have chosen it, as if my choices directly threaten their own. If an article seems more boastful than maybe it should, perhaps it's a reaction against having one's personal choices questioned, dissected and ultimately put down by someone working 80 hours a week with a family to support and a mortgage to pay, attacking others with the Gaul to not have taken on those obligations. Again, nothing wrong with our individual choices, and I don't put anyone down for making them. I just often find that not everyone shares that view.
- ammnyc 11y ago"Also, as someone who has chosen to not pursue the rat race, I often feel pushback and criticism from those who have chosen it, as if my choices directly threaten their own." great response
- chime 11y agoI might be the odd one here but I don't think this article was about the practicality of working part-time but rather a motivator. Here is the key point: > When we were done, they took me to chai, and asked me about my life in the mountains, my time in theater. “I can also say ‘I want to go and live in the mountains.’ But who will let me?” one of them asked. > “Remember this,” I laughed, “you need no one’s permission to be yourself.” When I got back, I read The Top Regret again—”I wish I’d had the courage to live a life true to myself, not the life others expected of me.” It is a weird coincidence that this is the exact debate I'm having with my wife right now. I make more than enough for us to live well and I'm trying to show her how wonderful her life can be if she goes part-time or quits her job. I've told her that she can finally do all the things she really wants to do - more time to spend with our newborn, joining mommy groups, more time to exercise, cook/eat healthier, time for hobbies etc. She keeps coming back with her worries of future career prospects, financial problems in case I can't work, her prestige in her line of work etc. I counter with the fact that she was the valedictorian of her medical masters class with numerous open job offers with no expiration date, how we can buy sufficient life/disability insurance, how she can continue to work part-time or teach an advanced class or two if she wants to remain involved in her profession without a lapse. For me, this would be the dream. I'd love to work half as much as I do but I can't because of finances. She CAN work half as much without worrying about finances but she is still afraid of the major change. Frankly, it is just too alien of a concept for her. I would never force her to pick a specific path so all I can do until she makes up her mind is to offer her suggestions and paint a picture of what life could be if she picked the unconventional path.
- abrahamepton 11y agoSounds like maybe she should work full-time, because perhaps she wants to, and you should work part-time or not at all, as you clearly sound like you would prefer.
- lukego 11y ago> For me, this would be the dream. I'd love to work half as much as I do but I can't because of
- zellyn 11y ago
- hahamrfunnyguy 11y agoHe is basically saying you will have a fuller life, since you will have more time to experience other things. I think many people work at jobs that are at best "just work" and at worst miserable experiences. I want more time to learn new things, help people, and do work that I am passionate about.
- willholloway 11y agoWalden by Henry David Thoreau was a brag: "Thoreau pitched his Walden in this key; he claps his wings and gives forth a clear, saucy, cheery, triumphant note ... the book is certainly the most delicious piece of brag in literature ... It is a challenge and a triumph, and has a morning freshness and élan..." - John Burroughs Stories like this give hope to all those trapped, and existentially unsatisfied in the rat race. The internet (and USPS, UPS and Fedex) are the most amazing of all human inventions. It lets us live like Thoreau at Walden with access to the global economy. I've been doing just that for the last 8 months, and it saved my life. I suppose many will take that as a brag. Kindred spirits will be inspired, and maybe, just maybe we will coalesce into a liberation movement, and join together to make escape cheaper and accessible for more and more people.
- onnoonno 11y agoIf we'd all live like Walden, the planet would be a suburbian dystopia. I sincerely hope many people WANT to live in cities.