4 ms·
The pragmatic (in the non-philosophical sense) argument is that it is less than helpful to be a Spinozist or Cartesian or whatever without knowing it, and witho
by cafard 11y ago
The pragmatic (in the non-philosophical sense) argument is that it is less than helpful to be a Spinozist or Cartesian or whatever without knowing it, and without knowing the strengths and weaknesses of the position. C.S. Peirce (who trained as a chemist) remarked that much of what was called "plain common sense" was simply Aristotle. I encountered a teacher in an NLP course who quoted Aristotle's four types of causes without having any idea that it came from Aristotle. Listen long enough and you will Kant's Antinomies of Pure Reason argued forward and back by people who haven't cracked The Critique of Pure Reason.
The other argument is that it is a challenge and a pleasure to follow some of the strongest minds as they make, elaborate, and challenge theories. Not everyone will find it a pleasure. Still, I suspect that the difference between encountering Plato or Locke in a one-semester summary and actually reading Plato or Locke is comparable to the difference between encountering "The Marriage of Figaro" in a plot synopsis and in attending a competent performance.
Beyon
- johnchristopher 11y agoThe pragmatic in me would rather meet Plato and Locke in a one semester summary than reading Plato or Locke and working out the exegesis out of it. I agree these are different experiences that bring different kind of pleasure though. Yes, I also hit wikipedia to know how the Fringe and Life on Mars would end because the fillers were too much to bear.
- cafard 11y agoThe advantage of your approach is that philosophers in general are responding to their predecessors and the difficulties they have found there. Reading any given philosopher without sufficient context will be unprofitable. Still, I think that if you find time, you are better off getting the context and reading the source.
- msutherl 11y agoIndeed, ignorance of the history of ideas leads people to miss that "common sense" arguments were once revolutionary ideas, thought up and explained, or at least distilled, by a single person.
- romaniv 11y agoThe pragmatic (in the non-philosophical sense) argument is that it is less than helpful to be a Spinozist or Cartesian or whatever without knowing it, and without knowing the strengths and weaknesses of the position. Because that forces you to actually think through your positions and argue for them using your own words, rather than deliberately obscure academic slang? In natural sciences and math the simplest theory that works is the preferable one to use. In "modern" philosophy and various branches of academic criticism everyone tries to outdo each other in complexity. The practical result of it is that many people operate under false assumption: the assumption that if no one understands you, you automatically "win". This does nothing to improve the quality of reasoning or discourse.
- Retric 11y agoThere are a few mental tools that show up from watching arguments get torn apart on a regular basis. The failure points of Bayesian probability is a great example of this. Suppose I start drawing cards from a 52 card deck of cards and I ask you to estimate the odds that the next card will be a 6H. You work though the math and everything looks fine. I draw AH, JC, 2S, 6H, and all is well with the world, except the next card is another JD. Now what? What if the next card is a picture of an Apple followed by a 2S? PS: The failure point being you need a probability that your prior probability estimate is right, and then a probability that that prior estimate is right recursively.
- A_COMPUTER 11y agoTrying to learn physics solely through experimentation instead of a from a book of the accumulated efforts and failures of generations of people, would be a phenomenal waste of time. Philosophy isn't any different in that regard.
- romaniv 11y agoWe're not talking about learning theoretical physics. We're talking about presenting arguments, usually involving relatively mundane subjects. "If you can't explain it to a six year old, you don't understand it yourself." - Albert Einstein