10 ms·
This has always been the point of NVIDIA's propertary game engine technology for more than a decade now - give it away for free or very often for big titles int
by bhouston 11y ago
This has always been the point of NVIDIA's propertary game engine technology for more than a decade now - give it away for free or very often for big titles integrate it into game engines using NVIDIA developers (who often come to work on site.) Then once the game is released mention that it works better/looks better on NVIDIA technology than on competitors (AMD/Intel) GPU technology. And of course blame it not working well on AMD/Intel on their "inferior" technology.
NVIDIA must be loving this controversy as it was the whole game plan all along.
- SloopJon 11y agoI read something very similar in this anonymous Slashdot post when Assassin's Creed Unity came out: http://games.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=6048819&cid=48382141 http://games.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=6048819&cid=483821... Choice quote: "Nvidia literally doesn't care if bouncing ten simple particles on your screen uses 30% of your GPU performance, so long as the same effect on an AMD GPU takes 80%. Nvidia is this dirty."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rrss1122 11y agoThe thing is, I have an nVidia card and ACU doesn't even run on it. It feels like they are not only trying to deter people from buying AMD, but that they are also trying to deter people from buying lower tier nVidia cards. I have to get ACU down to sub-720p resolution to even get more than 20fps. It's ridiculous.
- mesozoic 11y agoI think the problem there is just that ACU was just a very poorly made game.
- ikeboy 11y ago>So Nvidia 'invented' TXAA- an horrifically bad AA method both in appearance and 'hit' on performance- but a method that runs far better on new Nvidia hardware than it does on new AMD hardware. Why is that, though? Why can't AMD do whatever Nvidia's doing to make it just as fast on their system?
- tarpherder 11y agoBecause Nvidia is playing to their relative strengths. Differences in hardware can't always be overcome in software.
- digi_owl 11y agoSadly this is par of the course of the whole computing industry. Just look at how Apple pretty much gets to set up a store inside university libraries. Or how the likes of Adobe or Microsoft will throw virtually free copies of their products at students. Damn it, is swear Gates has said he would rather see people pirate Microsoft products than adopt alternatives for personal use.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoThese aren't good comparisons. Dev studios work out promotional deals for this tech. This tech isn't just free, they're being paid to put them in games. We saw them do this with Physx and probably with these other technologies. Students don't walk into university libraries and get a $200 check from Apple to use OSX.
- digi_owl 11y agoApple probably would if they could get away with it.
- tormeh 11y ago"If you're a thin, attractive student at an Ivy league university, you get a free Apple suite of hardware, continually renewed until you've finished your studies!" I don't know why they haven't already done it.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoWhy do it when the thin, attractive students are already buying the Apple products?
- benzoate 11y agoThey do get discounts on Apple hardware from Apple of around 10% though (we did at my university at least).
- pauloday 11y ago
- freehunter 11y agoAnd unfortunately it's working. If/when I buy a new GPU... it'll be nvidia. I've owned four ATI/AMD cards and only one nvidia card (integrated in a laptop), but it seems on many big-name games I want to play these days, there's always some problem on AMD. Sure it's shady business tactics, sure it's unfair competition, sure it's sabotage of their competitor, but if AMD can't do something about it, there's no logical reason to stick with AMD. I built a custom AMD computer to meet the recommended specs for Watch Dogs and after launch I find out that the AMD recommended specs don't provide the same performance as the recommended Intel/nvidia specs. Something like 70% of the performance is gone on AMD. I don't want to worry about politics, I just want to play my game.
- Zardoz84 11y agoAMD should begin to fix his crappy drivers. I stooped to buy AMD graphics cards because give a lot of problems related only to the drivers.
- FG_Regulus 11y agoFirst of all, AMD does release drivers and fix issues. It takes a couple weeks but it happens. And if you look at benchmarks the r9 290 still trades blows with the 970, there's no huge disparity like Nvidia wants you to believe and your 70% comment is just plain rediculous. But second, seriously? No logical reason to stick with AMD? You have no moral dilemma here? So you want to continue buYing from the company that lies about their most popular card's specs then refuses to apologize and instead tells you how grateful you should be? A company that intentionally sabotages performance of their last generation of cards because it might make the new one look bad and it may make people buy a new card (then we'll do it again next generation!)? A company that attacks open standards and tries to create schisms in the community? Can you not see what they'd do if they didn't have a competitor? And don't forget - this is all in trade for a 5% performance improvement and some power draw reduction. That's just sad.
- criley2 11y agoWe all have different definitions of "sad". "Sad" can also be accepting inferior products because of emotional and moral reasons. We're not talking about human rights violations or something here, so not everyone has an appetite for moral grandstanding and voting with your wallet. "A company that attacks open standards and tries to create schisms in the community? " Amusingly, many software darlings of Silicon Valley behave poorly. Uber, Twitter, Apple, Google, Facebook all behave aggressively anti-competitively in their own immoral and unique ways. Every company I listed attacks open standards in some way or another and creates schisms in communities on a regular basis (or their entire market is based on such walled schisms of larger markets). If you're the kind of person who assess all hardware and software from a moral perspective, then that's an interesting and rare way to approach your decisions in this space, but not everyone finds it "sad" to use "use the best available".
- abandonliberty 11y agoThis is business, unfortunately. Compared to suing your innovative competitors out of business, then buying and burying their technology like Creative [0] or suing countries for attempting to warn their citizens that cigarettes are bad for your health [1], it's almost ethical. [0]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aureal_Semiconductor#History http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aureal_Semiconductor#History [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_Morris_v._Uruguay http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_Morris_v._Uruguay
- mikeash 11y agoWhy do game makers put up with it? You'd think that an engine that's clearly being built to work poorly on a good chunk of the GPUs out there would be off the table as an option if you're making a big game.
- agapos 11y ago"Why do game makers put up with it?" Money. See the 'Money? What Money? Oh, that money' part of this writing: http://www.tgdaily.com/games/37326-ubisoft-caught-in-a-little-assassin%E2%80%99s-creed-scandal http://www.tgdaily.com/games/37326-ubisoft-caught-in-a-littl...
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoSimilar to how Intel's C Compiler deliberately chose suboptimal code paths when running on non-GenuineIntel CPUs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_C++_Compiler#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_C++_Compiler#Criticism
- thwest 11y agoThe legally mandated disclaimers in their compiler manual are quite scary about this.