4 ms·
Solution: AMD optimizes HairWorks. Reality: complaining is easier. NVIDIA have always claimed that no exclusivity deals are signed with GameWorks. Others have
by zamalek 11y ago
Solution: AMD optimizes HairWorks. Reality: complaining is easier.
NVIDIA have always claimed that no exclusivity deals are signed with GameWorks. Others have [supposedly] always been welcome to assist game developers during the phases that NVIDIA gets proactively involved in.
It's just an extension of the systemic AMD problem: they [very likely] have the best hardware but their Windows drivers are horrific and not only do they not have developer support; they actually play the victim because others take the initiative. For crying out loud, even Intel has game developer support/code. Correction: it turns out that AMD do actually have some open source libraries for game devs.
The problem here isn't NVIDIA. NVIDIA set out to optimize the game as best as they could for their hardware. AMD didn't set out to do anything: once again they sabotaged themselves by not getting involved. If I'm lazy and I get left behind that is my fault, not the fault of the other guy who did what I didn't do.
- chronid 11y agoGood luck optimizing for shader code you have no access to, because that is (was?) the situation, at least for some previous games that used it. Not even the developers of the games have any access to it. Gameworks actually prevents AMDs to optimize paths in their drivers. Exclusivity does not matter a bit. Note that AMD also has a program that help developers write shaders and optimize their engines to work better on AMD cards. But that does not prevent NVIDIA to see the code and optimize their own drivers accordingly. So, to me the problem here seems NVIDIA's attitude to sabotage (for no technical reason, except economics, see the physX on x86 debacle when they refused to compile code for something else that i386) performance on other platforms for their own gain. Like physX, Gameworks is already showing itself for what it is and will eventually fail and be forgotten. And people will believe that AMD is at fault for the next NVIDIA "magic technology" that brought no gain whatsoever to the gaming world.
- fabian2k 11y agoFrom what I read, AMD doesn't have access to the GameWorks source code. These features are also designed with the capabilities of Nvidia GPUs in mind, you can't really optimize around fundamental differences in the GPUs (e.g. the newest Nvidia cards are significantly better at tesselation).
- praseodym 11y agoI don't see why AMD would need to source code to be able to optimise their drivers. Sure, it would be nice, but with a good GPU profiler (they should have one), one will be able to pinpoint bottlenecks and optimise for them. Your point about hardware differences makes more sense; I don't expect AMD to admit that their hardware is simply not as suited for the task as Nvidia's is.
- baldfat 11y agoI find your argument lacking the real world facts. Open Source drivers for NVIDIA suck due to lack of documentation. If AMD has a difficult time than Open Source drivers are doomed. AMD does make good hardware and it has traditionally been a good company. The issue is the lack of a standard. I don't like non-standard solutions with closed code or hardware.
- bad_user 11y agoYou're talking about reverse engineering. This is unfair competition, plain and simple. Depending on how you view their market (general purpose devices versus gaming), Nvidia has a majority marketshare, with over 75% of the market for gamers. That qualifies it for a monopoly status and given this story, we could easily be talking about them violating the antitrust laws. Of course, I may be exaggerating and government interventions are rarely any good for consumers. It would be better if we, as consumers or developers, would acknowledge such abuse and punish such companies with our thoughts and wallets. So no, AMD not having access to that source-code is not OK, plus AMD shouldn't have to patch their drivers for that game, because such a practice has far reaching consequences, affecting indie game developers (Nvidia won't patch their drivers for indie games that aren't as popular as Witcher 3), or any operating system that isn't number 1 (which on the desktop means anything non-Windows).
- zamalek 11y agoThis hails back to the early Guild Wars 2 days, which might predate HairWorks: developers take 'responsibility' for the GameWorks code once NVIDIA leaves. They can't open source it, but they do have the source and by extension so would AMD if they ever walked through the door. Disclaimer: complete hearsay. What you say about HairWorks optimization is true, but you can't hold the fact that AMD has failed invest against NVIDIA. Look at it this way, if TW3 hadn't added HairWorks everyone would have the static hair meshes. As a game developer I would integrate HairWorks so that I could shine on compatible platforms (albeit I'd probably disable it by default for AMD, instead of having a bad first experience). It's a pity that the consumer gets caught up in all this. Who's to blame is a lot more difficult to determine than most people think. Purely in terms of graphics cards, NVIDIA has great post-sales support. If I buy an NVIDIA I know games will run well on it because NVIDIA makes sure that they do. This is a pro-consumer post-sales service that I get at absolutely no cost. They are also running up against AMD users in the way that people describe in the comments of that article. It's not a black and white situation but AMD is certainly not helping in even an insignificant way. AMD customers should be demanding answers from AMD before (not in exclusion to) they demand answers from NVIDIA.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> It's just an extension of the systemic AMD problem: they [very likely] have the best hardware but their Windows drivers are horrific and not only do they not have developer support You are strongly misrepresenting the actual situation. AMD is painfully aware that their drivers lack compared to Nvidia but they disagree with the reason. AMD does not want to put nearly as many hacks into the drivers as Nvidia does. They went quite far (by making Mantle) to make the drivers leaner and more predictable. Nvidia traditionally detects misbehaving game code and patches it up with various degrees in the driver. > AMD didn't set out to do anything: once again they sabotaged themselves by not getting involved. AMD made the right step and backed the only thing that will evolve the situation from the status quo: Mantle and now Vulkan/DX12. Otherwise they would always end up playing this game of magical drivers that NVidia supports but nobody likes.
- lsadam0 11y ago> ...as many hacks into the drivers as Nvidia does. That sounds like an absolute nightmare to maintain.
- bhouston 11y agoIt sucks actually because when I've written custom game engines, one doesn't know if one is using OpenGL properly because NVIDIA just makes things work even if you did a bad call. Then when you try to run it on other drivers that are more compliant, it all fails all over the place. The solution I guess is to try and find a highly compliant, picky driver, and develop using that, because it is easier to get it right at the beginning than to go back and try to fix things.
- mrec 11y agoSee also: HTML. I think there are debug wrapper for GL; too much overhead to run in production, but should tell you if you're Doing It Wrong (tm). Have you tried something like Regal?
- zamalek 11y ago> Mantle and now Vulkan/DX12 The issue here isn't that at all. The issue is a turn-key hair rendering solution. ~~Which AMD does not provide.~~ Correction: AMD provides TressFX, which had bad NVIDIA performance before NVIDIA stepped in and fixed it. ~~In fact I can't find any graphics code samples on their website, contrasted with the abundance on the NVIDIA website.~~ Correction: AMD does have samples.
- bhouston 11y ago> Solution: AMD optimizes HairWorks. Why didn't NVIDIA make HairWorks, NVIDIA's software, run properly on AMD cards? Given that NVIDIA has the full source, that should have been possible.
- agapos 11y ago"Solution: AMD optimizes HairWorks." How do you optimize code you have no access to? "It's just an extension of the systemic AMD problem: they [very likely] have the best hardware but their Windows drivers are horrific and not only do they not have developer support; they actually play the victim because others take the initiative." Like how a Project Cars developer or spokesman claimed that AMD did not help for months only to be completely disputed later on? Also, ask Kepler owners about their current driver support in recent titles. They are not happy. "NVIDIA set out to optimize the game as best as they could for their hardware." AMD helped optimise several titles that worked just as well on NVidia (excep that one Tomb Raider fiasco, what was solvable doe to the openly available TressFX code. Can we say the same about hairworks?). But somehow many NVidia titles are optimised in a fancy way that always hits hard on AMD cards (Crisis 2 and Batman AA come in as uncovered examples). "AMD didn't set out to do anything: once again they sabotaged themselves by not getting involved." I guess you can back up that statement. Edit: wording, grammar
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pearle 11y agoI really don't understand the AMD driver complaints. I've been running AMD cards off and on for years (Last 2 cards were AMD, previous one was Nvidia) and I have zero problems with AMD drivers. And Nvidia? There are a large number of reports that the latest drivers cause crashes and there have been problems in the past too. I don't think the difference between AMD and nvidia is nearly as wide as nvidia fans want you to believe.