2 ms·
> If a retailer were to let a customer leave before confirming receipt of a payment, they would be opening themselves up to fraud This is already the case with
by yellowapple 12y ago
> If a retailer were to let a customer leave before confirming receipt of a payment, they would be opening themselves up to fraud
This is already the case with credit/debit transactions, which can often take upwards of 24 hours to finalize.
The 10 minutes required for a Bitcoin transaction to complete mostly deal with peer verification. The actual publication of that to peers is much quicker, and said publication is usually when a retailer would interpret a payment as having been "received".
The only way to speed this up further - with either fiat or cryptographic currency - is to distribute it physically. In the case of fiat, this would be cash. In the case of cryptographic, this would be a paper wallet with a verifiable balance and totally-secret private key, not known to even the person who's paying with it (which is feasible, hypothetically, by using a machine that could print paper wallets with the private key obscured by "scratcher" film like what lottery tickets use; said machine, however, would need to be entirely disconnected from any form of telecommunications, generate truly-(pseudo)random (i.e. not pregenerated) keys, and have no means of storing keys on non-volatile memory in order to be trustworthy, however, but all three of these things are possible with today's technology by not including a NIC, using a PNRG (in software or hardware), and using ROM and a RAMdisk exclusively, respectively). Upon receipt, the recipient can either hang onto it as physical currency or "cash it in" by scratching off the concealing film and extracting the funds.
- davidgerard 12y ago> The 10 minutes required for a Bitcoin transaction to complete We've been seeing longer and longer transaction times of late, into the hours. > with either fiat This Bitcoin misuse of the term "fiat" is irritating. It means any currency without a physical backing. This includes Bitcoin. In practice, conventional currencies are considerably better-backed than Bitcoin. (This misuse of "fiat" originates in early goldbug pamphlets and was cut'n'pasted into the Bitcoin memetic sphere.)
- yellowapple 12y ago> We've been seeing longer and longer transaction times of late, into the hours. The longest I've seen so far was maybe two hours. That's still 12 times faster than most credit/debit transactions. Now granted, if confirmation time keeps growing like it has been, then yes, the Bitcoin folks will need to figure out some kind of solution (it's not like other cryptocurrencies haven't already found such solutions). Keeping it under 24 hours, however, means it's still on par with expectations for credit/debit transactions, which was my point. > It means any currency without a physical backing. Wikipedia [0] disagrees with you on the definition of fiat: "Fiat money is currency which derives its value from government regulation or law." I'm too lazy right now to go corroborate that with a dictionary. Bitcoin - unlike fiat currencies - isn't based on a government declaring its value. It's much closer to commodity or representative money (the defitions of neither requiring the "commodity" in question to be a physical commodity - just one that's difficult to reproduce, a trait which blockchain entries possess). [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_money https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_money