3 ms·
I'm not sure why this was down voted - it's a perfectly valid question. There are serious philosophical issues with the idea of an observer, conscious or other
by TheOtherHobbes 12y ago
I'm not sure why this was down voted - it's a perfectly valid question.
There are serious philosophical issues with the idea of an observer, conscious or otherwise, as a useful concept.
Entanglement isn't really the issue, because it doesn't solve the problem. What does it mean to be entangled with a complex state in a state of some form of consciousness?
How much consciousness is needed to make a difference? Why should adult human consciousness be the benchmark, and not semi-consciousness, or distraction, or unconsciousness, or toddler-level pre-verbal awareness, or jellyfish consciousness, or LSD-induced hallucination?
If consciousness is necessary, why doesn't reality stop working when we fall asleep? Why do plants live in a consistent physical reality even though they don't know what a Hamiltonian is?
If physics had code smells, this idea of consciousness might not pass the sniff test.
Of course it's possible it's still the right answer. But if it is, it's interesting there's no useful explanation of anything in the concept yet. Nor is there any formalism to support it. (Obviously there's a formalism for wave function collapse. But so far as I know, there's nothing in the math that says "And these variables are where the observer works his/her/its magic.")
Really it's just something that might be true, maybe, because we have no idea what's going on and it's as good a guess as any other.