4 ms·
Your comment makes me think of this comic: https://xkcd.com/277/ https://xkcd.com/277/ I often times have the same thoughts, but I have a feeling there are lot
by cortesoft 12y ago
Your comment makes me think of this comic: https://xkcd.com/277/ https://xkcd.com/277/
I often times have the same thoughts, but I have a feeling there are lots of considerations that we aren't taking into account when we create our solutions.
- remarkEon 12y agoI thought of that yesterday when they turned on these new meters on I5 that seemed to do nothing. One thing the DoT could do to assuage our negative feelings is put the methodology out in the public after it's implemented. Show how the sausage is made, if you will. Then again, it's probably people who would otherwise be predisposed to looking up how a simulation would run in this case that would be less likely to whine in the first place. So it probably doesn't really matter, other than on principle.
- joshuahutt 12y agoWhy not open-source the methodology before it's implemented? They might get good feedback.
- stephen_g 12y agoAre you talking about ramp metering? If so, I was involved in a trial in Melbourne, Australia on a major highway there. In peak times, it can actually improve travel times by 50% and massively reduce congestion around the choke points you get just ahead of on-ramps. It depends on what algorithm they use to determine timing though - this was a coordinated, dynamic algorithm, but sometimes they are just manually set which isn't as good.
- remarkEon 12y agoI am! Do you have any datasets that you can release that I could look at? Or what the algorithms looked like? I'd love to be armed with some real facts the next time I get annoyed or my coworkers start complaining.
- stephen_g 12y agoHere's the best one I can find: http://ersilia.net/origami/docs/vicroads.pdf http://ersilia.net/origami/docs/vicroads.pdf Up to 58% increase in average speed in one test, which was probably the figure I was thinking of (it was a while ago!)
- Anechoic 12y agoOne thing the DoT could do to assuage our negative feelings is put the methodology out in the public after it's implemented. It likely is public - there may be an environmental assessment (EA), Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) or Environmental Impact Report (EIR) that will have an appendix containing the detailed traffic engineering study behind the metering. It's probably based on MUTCD guidelines [0]. Assuming you are referring to I-5 through CA, a Google search for "california ramp metering study" brings up a lot of studies and documentations sponsored by Caltrans. [0] http://mutcd.fhwa.dot.gov/htm/2009/part4/part4i.htm http://mutcd.fhwa.dot.gov/htm/2009/part4/part4i.htm
- remarkEon 12y agoI'm actually referring to I-5 up here south of Seattle...right outside JBLM where I work. I have looked and unfortunately I haven't found anything. I did find a bunch of stuff that talks about ramp metering at large, but nothing specifically about the on-ramps here that just got metered. Anecdotally, traffic inside JBLM has been significantly negatively effected because of this. I read in another comment that ramp metering speeds up traffic on the freeway...I really hope that's the case. Because it's really annoying to sit in my car while trying to leave and I hope I get to make that up on the aggregate. And to my earlier point...it isn't immediately clear that I will...because the methodology isn't open.
- sp332 12y agoI was thinking of https://xkcd.com/793/ https://xkcd.com/793/ Just jump in and fix it, can't take more than an afternoon right?
- ubernostrum 12y agoI feel a bit weird about this, because my father actually worked for the local highway department and I ended up learning about the stuff that goes into road design and engineering... and most of the payoff of that is that I complain when I see stuff done wrong. And it's not just light timing; my single biggest gripe is when I can tell from driving on a road that its speed limit has been set significantly differently from its design speed (in either direction -- there are some local streets obviously set too low, but also some highway stretches that are obviously set too high).
- pkulak 12y agoI'd say there are a lot of local streets with speed limits to high, designed for speeds MUCH to high. http://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2010/11/22/confessions-of-a-recovering-engineer.html http://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2010/11/22/confessions-of...
- ubernostrum 12y agoEhhh... that guy seems a bit off. It is true that often residents demand something be done to force the average speed of traffic way below the design speed of the street, but generally it's not because some engineer slapped a major arterial into a cozy residential neighborhood. Rather, the common pattern is the residents moved in because they liked being conveniently on some minor artery that would get them to/from work quickly, but then decided after moving in that it had to change into a quiet residential street so their kids could go out and play in it. The result, if the neighborhood can pull off enough local political clout, is usually that a street designed for good amounts of traffic doing 40+ mph starts getting its limit lowered to 35, then 30, then 25, then roundabouts and speed humps start showing up to enforce it, and you just get a mess.
- cafard 12y agoYes and no. The neighborhood where I live was laid out eighty or ninety years ago. Most families probably had a car by 1940, but I doubt many had two. Most had garages, some had driveways but no garage. Now I suspect that we are unusual in being a two-adult household with one car. A neighbor across the way has four vehicles--three cars and a pickup truck, all of which they must park on the street. The increase in cars per household means that for a good ways in every direction, any side street will have cars parked on both sides. Two ordinary sized American cars can pass each other in what is left, but drivers usually find it safer to look for an unparked space where one can pull over a little. Twenty-five miles per hour does not feel slow on these streets (particularly from the right front seat). You are completely correct about the residents wishing to slow things down. Thirty years ago one could get onto 13th St. NW in downtown Washington, and with a bit of luck hit no red lights all the way to Maryland. Now there are stop signs sprinkled between the lights. In Chevy Chase, there is I think one path left that takes one through the neighborhoods from Jones Bridge Road to Beach Drive where once there were many, the rest now blocked by barriers.