4 ms·
> Where is the line? There is no bright white line. It's more a thing of legal compliance. A death by a thousand cuts/thousand checkboxes. If I rent an office
by the8472 12y ago
> Where is the line?
There is no bright white line. It's more a thing of legal compliance. A death by a thousand cuts/thousand checkboxes.
If I rent an office floor and run my own datacenter then I'm legally responsible for all of it. There is no need for a data processing agreement because i'm not having my data processed by a different legal entity.
If I colocate in a datacenter but the servers are my property then i'm still legally responsible and only have to show that the servers are physically protected from unauthorized access (locked cage and such)
If I buy a managed server things already get dicier. It means a 3rd party has access to the data. But at least you can find a hoster in your own country which removes a lot of headaches because it's fairly easy for them to comply with local laws. You sign a data processing agreement, they secure their datacenter (physically/organizational/networking) and you're done. In case of a data breach you might have to hash out responsibilities.
Cloud services on the other hand easily span continents, are run by foreign companies and span multiple legal systems and the machines they offer are a lot more ephemeral and more tightly integrated into a shared management architecture, which makes it much more difficult to audit and demonstrate isolation of your machines.
If your system gets audited then either your auditor will have to inspect the system himself or will require certifications of your providers adhering to specific legal standards. Having a large, international, tightly interwoven provider makes those certifications more difficult because they have to comply to multiple, possibly conflicting legal systems. If they cannot offer those certifications then you cannot use their services because your auditor will reject them.