4 ms·
This is pretty common outside finance as well. "We can't let our data touch any one else's network!" And, of course, we can't bother to get our IT group on the
by mcguire 12y ago
This is pretty common outside finance as well. "We can't let our data touch any one else's network!" And, of course, we can't bother to get our IT group on the smarts wagon, so we're massively inefficient all the way around.
- Someone1234 12y agoI'm playing devil's advocate a little: There are sometimes legitimate legal hurdles to having your data hit external networks. For example, if you're a medical insurance company, then you have to get everything HIPAA legal.
- sologoub 12y agoLooks like AWS is HIPAA complaint at least for some services: "Customers may use any AWS service in an account designated as a HIPAA account, but they should only process, store and transmit PHI in the HIPAA-eligible services defined in the BAA. There are six HIPAA-eligible services today, including Amazon EC2, Amazon EBS, Amazon S3, Amazon Redshift, Amazon Glacier, and Amazon Elastic Load Balancer." http://aws.amazon.com/compliance/hipaa-compliance/ http://aws.amazon.com/compliance/hipaa-compliance/ Notably, I don't see Elastic MapReduce. It seems that if you wanted to run heavy data crunching, you'd have to run you own cluster on EC2.
- jtbigwoo 12y agoI've been on projects where we used Rackspace cloud servers or Amazon EC2 for HIPAA-compliant insurance enrollment systems. There was extra paperwork and we did a bunch of security testing, but it wasn't too bad. In both cases the projects were controlled by marketing departments who were much more concerned with cost per customer than with maintaining total control over every aspect of the system.
- mcguire 12y agoSure, sure, and some of our data is even sensitive in that way (cough, HR, cough). But I'm sure Amazon or someone else can handle that kind of requirement. We can't even open the discussion, though.
- the8472 12y ago> "We can't let our data touch any one else's network!" In some industries that can be necessary if you want to stick to the letter of the law, especially here in europe. You can outsource the processing, but then your provider has to meet fairly stringent certifications, you have the necessary "submitting to 3rd parties for purpose-specific processing" disclaimers in your privacy policies and a signed data processing agreement covering personal data compatible with national laws, which vary between countries. The microsoft ireland email case[1] also made some data protection ombudsmen suggest that the whole safe harbor deal with US companies should be considered null and void because they cannot effectively guarantee the safety of your data, even more so given the threat of national security letters + gag orders. And without that deal you can't use their cloud solutions for sensitive data. Personally identifying data has pretty high hurdles. Medical data (which might be processed by insurances?) raises even higher bars.
- sseveran 12y agoIn fact AWS will sign a HIPAA business agreement for medical data (http://aws.amazon.com/compliance/hipaa-compliance/ http://aws.amazon.com/compliance/hipaa-compliance/).
- kejaed 12y agoThey'll even help you with ITAR controls too: http://aws.amazon.com/govcloud-us/faqs/ http://aws.amazon.com/govcloud-us/faqs/
- superuser2 12y agoWhere is the line? Everyone seems to think "cloud" services threaten user privacy, but "cloud" is a marketing term. What about traditional VPSes? Managed dedicated servers? Ordinary dedicated servers? Leased servers collocated in a 3rd party datacenter? Owned servers collocated in a 3rd party datacenter? What if you use their "remote hands" service? Is there a meaningful difference between your leased office floor and your leased datacenter space? I would argue not. Do you have to own the land? What about leased vs. owned servers if they're in your office? Even if you have outright owned servers on outright owned land (unlikely b/c mortgage, but whatever), how are they managed? In many small businesses (including medical practices), they're managed by a "small business IT consulting" company which has both remote and regular on-premise access. You're trusting them to the same extent you would be trusting AWS. Is there a meaningful difference? What about the proprietary software you run? A large Electronic Medical Records package which probably contains extremely sensitive data about you is technically deployed onsite, but deployment and administration are performed remotely by the vendor's team in India. (I worked for a small biz IT consulting firm that supported the underlying hardware/Windows for one of these installations.) What about the Windows and other proprietary software with internet access that's literally everywhere? You may think you've achieved a morally superior position of trusting no one but yourself when you forego The Cloud, but I argue that's generally not the case except in the most extremely self-reliant cases (no vendor support, no contractors, no proprietary software). Those cases are not at all representative of the average business which refuses to go AWS.
- vosper 12y agoYeah. The company I work for was acquired by a big player in the industry, and one of the first things they wanted to do was move us off AWS, because the COO sees Amazon as a competitor and thinks that they'll go snooping in our databases to get a competitive advantage [1]. We managed to stave it off by coming up with a vague plan for how we'd move critical infrastructure to hardware, then shelving it indefinitely. AWS was (and is) critical to our velocity - unlike every other team in the company, we don't wait 6 weeks to start working on something while IT eventually gets around to writing a hardware purchase order and racking the gear. We don't compete for "the staging environment" because we can have as many environments as we want. [1] This is a ludicrous idea. My two main rebuttals are: - AWS takes in more revenue than our company, and they would destroy that business if it ever got out that their engineers were snooping in customer data - Netflix is a much more direct competitor than we are (they compete with Amazon Video) and also a much heavier user of (and cheerleader for, even) AWS
- nimblegorilla 12y agoIt might be time for tinfoil hats, but maybe Amazon only competes with Netflix because Netflix demonstrated how awesome Amazon's servers work for video delivery?
- bashinator 12y agoNetflix doesn't use AWS for the actual video delivery.
- throwawayaway 12y agooh no, never engineers. always maintain a layer of plausible deniability, those engineers might turn coat and rat the organisation out you see.
- hinkley 12y agoI really love it when I have to head up a project that costs the company $100-250,000 in developer time and the only reason we have to do it is that we can't get the business to buy us another $10,000 in hardware. Actually I lied. What I really love is when one customer threatens to walk if they have to buy a $3000 machine to run our new version, and the whole team spends 1-2 months doing nothing but trying to keep that account. When we could just gift them a server and save ourselves a mountain of grief and a ton of development resources for, you know, landing new accounts. If someone could start teaching basic math in business school, that would make me so happy.