7 ms·
A wave of experiments is probing the root of quantum weirdness
- ChuckMcM 12y agoThe exploration of what the wavefunction "means" in terms of the world around us has been one of the more interesting things to watch. When I took quantum physics in school (under the generic heading "Modern Physics") psi and quantum mechanics was very much simply a mathematical treatment of things rather, unlike thermodynamics which was actually visible and "real". Between the teleporation work and recent wavefunction work it seems like a lot more layers of the universe are being revealed.
- Spooky23 12y agoIs there a good resource out there for laymen to explain "quantum stuff" in a meaningful way? When I read articles that are using words like "spooky" and "weird" as terms of art, and using Schrödinger's cat as a way to clarify a topic, I get nothing out of it. And I'd like to be able to explain to my mom what this stuff is.
- akuma73 12y agoSean Carroll does a fantastic job here: http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/eternitytohere/quantum/ http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/eternitytohere/quantum/
- fizx 12y agoIt's very hard to ELI5 quantum mechanics. The only thing we can definitively constructively say is that we have a mathematical system that describes the universe very well at certain time/energy/distance scales. Trying to ascribe meaningfulness to this math is an ongoing struggle. Aside, the terms "spooky" and "weird" are used to describe phenomena that "have no classical analogue." Physicists don't agree on what Schrödinger's cat means. I find that it muddles more than it clarifies.
- BrainInAJar 12y agoThe first two lectures here: http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-computer-science/6-845-quantum-complexity-theory-fall-2010/lecture-notes/ http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-comput... They're kinna mathy, but a lot easier to understand than similar lectures from physicists (because the background knowledge is much greater)
- DenisM 12y agoDid you say "mathy"? http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=2934 http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=2934
- dandelany 12y agoFeynman does a pretty great laymen explanation in part 6 of his "Character of Physical Law" lecture series: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x5RQ3QF9GGI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x5RQ3QF9GGI And goes into greater depth in the Douglas Robb Memorial Lectures series: http://vega.org.uk/video/subseries/8 http://vega.org.uk/video/subseries/8 If you want to go all the way down the rabbit hole there's an exhaustive list of Feynman videos here :) http://www.richard-feynman.net/videos.htm http://www.richard-feynman.net/videos.htm
- amit_m 12y ago"QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter" by Richard Feynman: http://www.amazon.com/QED-Strange-Theory-Light-Matter/dp/0691024170 http://www.amazon.com/QED-Strange-Theory-Light-Matter/dp/069... I read this book in high-school and learned about as much as I did in 4 undergrad physics courses about quantum mechanics. There's no mathematics in this book, so it doesn't teach you how to calculate anything (for this, a physics degree helps), but the principles are presented very nicely.
- tim333 12y agoI second that and after if you are keen it can be good to look at the Feynman Lectures vol III, Chapter 5 where he talks about spin. He deliberately leaves spin out of QED to keep things simple. Also if curious there's the Feynman lectures on Gravitation where he tries to figure out quantum gravity and fails like everyone else. One thing I like about Feynman is his talks are based on experiments - if you fire electrons at two slits this happens (QED) or if you send them past a magnet that happens (Ch 5). This is in contrast to most popular science books which go on about spooky cats or most academic treatments which launch into a bunch of abstract maths without looking that much at what's going on physically. I find it much easier to get my head around the real experiment approach.
- dghf 12y agoAsk a Mathematician / Ask a Physicist (askamathematician.com) is pretty good, with a bias towards the Many-Worlds Interpretation†: http://www.askamathematician.com/2011/11/q-according-to-the-many-worlds-interpretation-every-event-creates-new-universes-where-does-the-energy-and-matter-for-the-new-universes-come-from/ http://www.askamathematician.com/2011/11/q-according-to-the-... http://www.askamathematician.com/2010/10/q-copenhagen-or-many-worlds/ http://www.askamathematician.com/2010/10/q-copenhagen-or-man... http://www.askamathematician.com/2013/08/q-are-there-examples-of-quantum-mechanics-that-can-be-seen-in-every-day-life-or-do-they-only-show-up-in-the-lab/ http://www.askamathematician.com/2013/08/q-are-there-example... http://www.askamathematician.com/2011/11/entanglement-omnibus/ http://www.askamathematician.com/2011/11/entanglement-omnibu... http://www.askamathematician.com/2010/06/q-how-it-is-that-bells-theorem-proves-that-there-are-no-hidden-variables-in-quantum-mechanics-how-do-we-know-that-god-really-does-play-dice-with-the-universe/ http://www.askamathematician.com/2010/06/q-how-it-is-that-be... † The Nature article characterises the Many-Worlds Interpretation like this: "In the many-worlds picture, the wavefunction governs the evolution of reality so profoundly that whenever a quantum measurement is made, the Universe splits into parallel copies." The first of the links above explains that this is a mischaracterisation.
- rmidthun 12y agoIt depends on what you mean by layman. I found the book Quantum Computing Since Democritus by Scott Aaronson to be very easy to understand, but it does require some linear algebra and complex numbers. I don't think you can get a good overview of entanglement (where the madness lies) without that basic level. Check http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/ http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/ and see if it works for you. Otherwise, you are in the realm of popularizers like John Gribbin, who I found entertaining but not very enlightening.
- kansface 12y agoIn the early 20th century, math ordinarily used to describe waves was applied to very small systems of particles. This was both strange and extraordinarily successful at modeling systems (if only probabilistically). Applying physical meaning to the math has proven to be more or less intractable. Because the models are so successful in their domain, most physicists tend to brush aside ascribing meaning to the math.
- deciplex 12y agohttp://lesswrong.com/lw/r6/an_intuitive_explanation_of_quantum_mechanics/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/r6/an_intuitive_explanation_of_quant...
- datashovel 12y agoI found this debate (moderated by Brian Greene) enlightening. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DbCl4p5TDPc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DbCl4p5TDPc
- godzilla82 12y agoThere are a lot of examples in the book "In search of Schrodingers cat" which can be explained in layman terms. There's double slit experiment, then radioactive decay rate, then double polarization of light. That is what I can remember right now. But i remember, the book has lot many other examples.
- return0 12y agoSo we still have little progress in the interpretation problem, but the planned experiments are going to shed light?
- jitan 12y agoPractical quantum field experience -> Meditation, no cat needed.
- fizx 12y agoI'm going to try to explain this in programming terms :) There's a longstanding interpretation that the wave-particle duality is actually caused by (e.g. electrons) being particles riding invisible waves. This interpretation (Bohmian mechanics) has been largely ignored as "valid but uninteresting." A key reason why this isn't historically that appealing is that the state of the "invisible waves" in the neighborhood of a single particle is mathematically dependent on the instantaneous state of every other particle in the universe. If you assume the universe is a simulation, then the programmer would be a freshman computer science student who unnecessarily made stepping forward in time quadratic! The oil-droplet experiments are an accidental existence proof that you can get behavior similar to quantum behavior in particle+wave systems without the quadratic global update rule. Is it enough? There's still tons of open questions, and possibly (likely) yet another dead end.
- stephengillie 12y agoI feel as though this hypothesis was recently disproven - a measurement confirmed that the waves and particles were really the same thing, not one thing riding on the carrier wave of another.
- fizx 12y agoThere's at least four mathematical representations of QM, ascribed to Shrödinger, Heisenberg, Dirac, and Bohm respectively, which are all mathematically equivalent. So you aren't really going to disprove only the Bohm picture, because it makes the exact same claims as the more common Shrödinger picture.
- justifier 12y agowhere is the contradiction here? my understanding of 'natural' physics is as a relation between particle(s) and every other particle in the universe and our physics calculations trying to understand and predict those natural events wave away those relations valued insignificant to the desired probability threshold? contrived but applicable example, "assume you are on a frictionless plane with zero wind resistance" or in one of the most amazing results of applied physics in recent news : "Fred Jansen, Rosetta's mission manager at ESA, said officials predicted a 70 to 75 percent probability of a successful landing by Philae before the mission's launch in 2004. But that number assumed the comet was a rounded body, not the oddly-shaped world found by Rosetta."
- Xcelerate 12y agoI think it may ultimately turn out that the best explanation for quantum mechanics is simply the set of postulates we already have, minus the Born rule. It's well known that a quantum system continues to evolve unitarily (deterministically) via the propagation operator regardless of whether any subsystems have collapsed. How can you have a discontinuous subsystem within a larger continuous system? You can't. The explanation for the appearance of collapse lies in the phenomenon of decoherence, which basically says that subsystems tend to quickly evolve into something resembling an eigenstate. This evolution must necessarily occur on an incredibly short timescale. It might be possible to design an experiment that would test the assumption that collapse is instantaneous. I think the best definition of "collapse" is that it is the moment in time in which a particular system can no longer be described (to good approximation) as the direct product of two subsystems (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separable_state http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separable_state). The concept of a "good approximation" is of course subjective, but it can always be objectively metricized (totally made that word up) by using some kind of error term. Epigrammatically, collapse is not so much a physical process as it is a characterization of the capability to represent a quantum state in a specific mathematical form. (Of course, this doesn't preclude you from categorizing physical processes as "collapse events"; it just means that collapse isn't a fundamental phenomenon so much as it is an emergent one. Kind of like quasiparticles.) So what about the randomness? I think it's better to refer to it as unpredictability. The difference is subtle but crucial. True randomness (assuming it exists) is the result of absolute indeterminism. On the other hand, if eigenstate selection is merely "unpredictable", then that implies collapse is in fact a deterministic process (specifically e^(-iHt) applied to Ψ over some time interval that we've decided to call a "measurement"); however, we're unable to extract enough information from the environment to make exact predictions because we ourselves constitute the required missing information. In other words, the information necessary for absolute predictive capability is trapped in the subsystem constituting the measuring environment, and it becomes lost when that subsystem becomes entangled with the subsystem being measured. And there's not really any way to prevent that from occurring, because entanglement must occur in order to learn anything about a system. This even applies classically. The only difference is that classical entanglement occurs between localized physical boundaries instead of between subspace boundaries in an abstract Hilbert space. To somewhat reify this, assume (for the sake of argument) that a classical description of physics is enough to describe a human. Then perform a large MD simulation of all the atoms inside a physics lab, including those of a physicist. The evolution of this simulated system is provably deterministic. Yet the physicist appears to have free will, and it appears like he is deciding which measurements to perform on his environment. But he's just an arbitrary collection of atoms that we've labeled "human", and he obeys the same time-transformation rules that the unlabeled atoms in the system obey. Mathematically, it's simply impossible for him to predict everything that occurs within the virtual system -- not because of indeterminism -- but because he isn't so much "choosing" what to measure as he is "appearing to choose". There's a limit to the amount of information any system can obtain about itself (well, maybe there's some fractals that are exceptions, but generally speaking, it holds true.) That said, experiment is always the ultimate arbitrator of truth, and I wonder if there might yet be some clever way to tell whether our universe is simply unpredictable instead of random, despite the possibility that both potential mechanisms might impose the same limits on predictive capability (in fact, Colbeck and Renner recently proved that QM is already maximally predictive, independent of whatever underlying mechanism governs eigenstate selection -- see http://www.nature.com/ncomms/journal/v2/n8/abs/ncomms1416.html http://www.nature.com/ncomms/journal/v2/n8/abs/ncomms1416.ht...)
- andyl 12y agoWhat is the role of the observer? What is the observer? Why does observation cause the wave function to collapse?
- curiously 12y agohttp://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/35328/why-does-observation-collapse-the-wave-function http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/35328/why-does-ob...
- stephengillie 12y agoWhat if we don't have a human observe? What if all data is only ever interpreted by canines and bovines (dogs and cows)? Will the wave function still collapse? How would you isolate an experiment from the potentially-wave-function-collapsing influence of human consciousness, and yet still produce a usable contribution to science?
- jules 12y agoWave function collapse is not a global thing. It can collapse for one observer but not for another, if two observers are completely isolated. So even if some other human observes it, then the wave function does not necessarily collapse for you. So whether the observer is a human or a cat or a computer or even a rock does not matter.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y agoI'm not sure why this was down voted - it's a perfectly valid question. There are serious philosophical issues with the idea of an observer, conscious or otherwise, as a useful concept. Entanglement isn't really the issue, because it doesn't solve the problem. What does it mean to be entangled with a complex state in a state of some form of consciousness? How much consciousness is needed to make a difference? Why should adult human consciousness be the benchmark, and not semi-consciousness, or distraction, or unconsciousness, or toddler-level pre-verbal awareness, or jellyfish consciousness, or LSD-induced hallucination? If consciousness is necessary, why doesn't reality stop working when we fall asleep? Why do plants live in a consistent physical reality even though they don't know what a Hamiltonian is? If physics had code smells, this idea of consciousness might not pass the sniff test. Of course it's possible it's still the right answer. But if it is, it's interesting there's no useful explanation of anything in the concept yet. Nor is there any formalism to support it. (Obviously there's a formalism for wave function collapse. But so far as I know, there's nothing in the math that says "And these variables are where the observer works his/her/its magic.") Really it's just something that might be true, maybe, because we have no idea what's going on and it's as good a guess as any other.
- jivos 12y agoSomeone more knowledgeable about solitons can chime in on this... A friend of mine modeled soliton interactions. When one soliton passes through another, information can be exchanged such that colliding solitons contain bits of each other when they move apart. No matter how far apart these solitons get, the soliton "children" still "chat" with their "parents". One soliton can contain multiple elements of other solitons, all of them interacting at a distance. Their behavior can mimic "spooky action at a distance". Also, solitons can have wave like behavior or particle like behavior depending on how they are observed.
- snarfy 12y agoMy own layman theory on this is that time has a wave like nature to it, not the particles. The idea is to rewrite the wave equation solving for time using the minkowski metric (space and time are related through relativity). The results should be the same, but it is a different interpretation.
- ciokan 12y agoOne of those posts where I read the comments and I realise how dumb I really am.
- anoncoder 12y agoSee http://arxiv.org/abs/1401.4356 http://arxiv.org/abs/1401.4356, a paper by Ross Anderson and Robert Brady. They've since expanded the theory greatly, with other papers on arxiv. Also, check out this fascinating debate about these matters on Scott Aaronson's blog. Link is http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=1255 http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=1255 Brady and Anderson have many posts in this debate, and IMHO, wind up winning. It's looking more and more like physics took a wrong turn with the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics.
- jeffsco 12y agoI am biased as a Scott A. fan and as somebody who knows essentially nothing about QM. However I see no way to conclude that Anderson and Brady even know what they're talking about, much less that they win the debate on the linked Scott Aaronson page. I just read through it again to confirm my recollection (skipping the Motl and Sidles posts fwiw).
- anoncoder 12y agoThe main reason I felt Scott A. (and company) lost the debate is because he could not point to a single experiment that actually uses qubits to do a calculation above a very small threshold. There is much written about experiments that seem to show entanglement of multi qubit systems, but none of them actually do any calculations with the qubits. Brady and Anderson's point is that it's not a qubit until you can calculate with it. And their theory suggests it will get exponentially harder for each qubit above 4 (I think), which throws out all of the interesting quantum algorithms. I also felt Brady and Anderson silenced every objection. After one or more of their rebuttals, they were no longer challenged. The most recent post about Feynman is also interesting. In any event, it is a fascinating blog post.
- rjdagost 12y agoOne question I have: if a pilot wave description of quantum mechanics was in fact the "right" one, would quantum computers be impossible? It's confusing because many articles claim that the various interpretations of QM yield the same predictions, and yet the irreducible randomness of the Copenhagen interpretation seems to be a prerequisite for quantum computing.
- anoncoder 12y agoSee my comment below. Anderson and Brady seem to think that quantum computing is impossible. It reduces to analog computing.
- opneg 12y agoGood article on the original PBR paper: http://mattleifer.info/2011/11/20/can-the-quantum-state-be-interpreted-statistically/ http://mattleifer.info/2011/11/20/can-the-quantum-state-be-i...