6 ms·
African-American males are 0.25% of the world's population, but 10% of the world's prisoners.
by pessimizer 12y ago
African-American males are 0.25% of the world's population, but 10% of the world's prisoners.
- Bostonian 12y agoBlack men also commit violent crimes at much higher rates than the rest of the population. Most people are in jail for a good reason. I suggest reading a recent essay "The Smart Way to Keep People Out of Prison" by Megan McArdle.
- viiralvx 12y agoYet, how many of those black men were arrested under "fitting the suspect description" and then forced into pleading guilty out of fear for a longer sentence? Also, did you read the article or just come directly to the comments?
- ChrisArgyle 12y agoIt seems as if you're saying violent crime is a function of race (crazy talk) instead of class status (arguable). Is it possible that, due to race-income inequalities in America, that black males are also more likely to have low/no income at the same "much higher rate"?
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoThe icky point is when you start looking at crime as a function of not just SES but also culture. A lot of people have a hard time nuancing culture from race even though a well traveled person would easily see the difference.
- Bostonian 12y agoEmpirically, crime rates do depend on race, not just class. It's not crazy to recognize reality.
- DanBC 12y agodetected crime rates depend on race. That's not surprising when institutional racism creates a system focused on criminalising black people.
- rhino369 12y agoLook at murder rates that are harder to overlook. The murder rage amongst black men is about 8-10x more then white men. Obviously historical racism is the huge cause here. But you cannot just write off the crime rates due to different policing. Poor Black neighborhoods are simultaneously over and under policed. Gangs and criminals have free reign and then cops capriously make a show of force.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Poor Black neighborhoods are simultaneously over and under policed. They are under policed ("guardian" model) and overmuch hostilely occupied by the police ("warrior" model). They are the places most in need of effective community-oriented policing, and the places that get that kind of policing the least.
- ChrisArgyle 12y agoThere's no way to advance a discussion by simply stating there is a correlation between crime and race. What solutions come from that? Genocide? Internment? Crime is a complex system that involves more than just the two axes race and violence.
- rmxt 12y agoThe racists and/or "human biodiversity" types have come out to play. Better to ignore the disingenuous comments and move on, as they tend not to be here for discussion. Articles on race and crime often draw out these sorts of "arguments". For those that actually believe the GP might have some ground to stand on, the least they could do is to link to some sources or resources.
- millermp12 12y ago1) men commit violent crime at much higher rates than women. Why? 2) sexism? stupidity? Or perhaps "being male" (higher testosterone levels) 3) males who self-identify as black have about 15% more testoterone (courtesy of that racist institution, the National Institutes of Health) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3455741 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3455741 4) is is really so crazy that a population with higher testosterone levels tends to be be bigger, and when they indulgent a violent proclivity, the outcome is more severe than when, say, a japanese women gets upset at the flower shop?
- bilbo0s 12y agoI don't know man... I looked at the numbers. It seems like the violent crime thing is being somewhat overstated here. For example, murder. So... even if we assume that black males committed EVERY murder in the US last year. (I realize they didn't, but I wanted to look at the numbers in a fashion as favorable to your view as possible.) Anyway, even if we assume they committed EVERY murder... that would still only be less than 0.01% of black males committing murder in a year. That would mean that well over 99.99% of black males could not possibly have been involved in a murder. The statistics are similar for crimes like grand theft, rape, attempted murder etc etc etc. All very violent. (Well ... maybe not grand theft... but the fbi had it on the list and, full disclosure, I cut and pasted from fbi dot gov.) Point is... in any given year, black males seem to go to prison or jail at a MUCH higher rate than their violent crime participation rate would warrant. There is probably a reason behind this that is perfectly legal. I think the questions are... what are some of those legal reasons ? And, are those legal reasons "just" ? I think those are reasonable questions.
- merpnderp 12y agoI don't know if it is correct and I certainly think it is a horrible positive feedback loop, but it appears that people with prior convictions are much more likely to get convicted and do jail time. So if you get in trouble as a kid, you're much more likely to get the book thrown at you for minor offenses as an adult.
- Bostonian 12y agoI thought juvenile records were not used to determine sentences of convicted adults. Is that true?
- tcfunk 12y agoUnfortunately, this is almost certainly a result of institutional racism through America's history. NPR has an pretty interesting interview regarding this: http://www.npr.org/2015/05/14/406699264/historian-says-dont-sanitize-how-our-government-created-the-ghettos http://www.npr.org/2015/05/14/406699264/historian-says-dont-...
- pessimizer 12y ago"Only 4% of all American police arrests are for crimes considered “violent” by the FBI, even though those crimes are offered as the justification for enormous public expenditures, wholesale Orwellian surveillance, and every violent aspect of modern policing." source: TFA When it comes to the disparity in non-violent arrests, remember that whites are more likely to abuse drugs than blacks http://healthland.time.com/2011/11/07/study-whites-more-likely-to-abuse-drugs-than-blacks/ http://healthland.time.com/2011/11/07/study-whites-more-like... when you control for socioeconomic status.
- anukulrm 12y agoThat statement is intellectually lazy at best. It is factually correct, but it wholly misses the context of the fact. And that is the centuries of slavery, the decades of Jim Crow, and other policies that have systematically deprived opportunity and framed/define crime to be an African-American tendency. I'd really recommend you read a couple of pieces by Ta-Nehisi Coates [0] before you make up your mind either way. Regrettably, I've argued your point of view before, but it simply shifts the burden of proof and contextualization to the under-privileged and oppressed. [0]: http://www.theatlantic.com/features/archive/2014/05/the-case-for-reparations/361631/ http://www.theatlantic.com/features/archive/2014/05/the-case...
- seiji 12y agoWhite males are [X percent of the world population], but like 99% of the world's billionaires. Success and punishment aren't evenly distributed due to innate corruption/advantages built into The System. How do we fix inequality? Companies run american prisons now, companies control elected officials, and voters are manipulated by basic psychological tricks to keep voting against their own interests (vote GOD, not basic human rights!). That's just one issue among 50 other giant issues america/world is currently failing at "doing the right thing" towards.
- jisaacstone 12y agoOK I feel compelled to tell you that the 99% white billionare thing is incorrect. USA does have the most billionares but they are not all white and also China is currently in the #2 spot with India in #4. Also if you are referring to the proplem of private prisons I do agree it's probably not a good thing but since less than 1/5 of prisons are privately run I don't think it is the main cause of the problem.
- anukulrm 12y agoYes, only 1/5 of the prisons, but it could still be that they wield a lot more influence than that figure suggests. There aren't very many lobbying for the imprisoned, so an organized private lobby of even a small number of private prisons might be enough to shift the scales significantly.
- anukulrm 12y agoThis. Before we can fix anything that requires a majority of the nation's participation, we need awareness and acknowledgement that racial inequality is deep rooted in the American psyche. A lot of posters even here on HN seem to think race is irrelevant or a minor point.