18 ms·
Nasdaq experiments with Bitcoin's blockchain
- Angostura 12y agoOne question from someone who isn't very well versed in Blockchain technology. As I understand it, it is potentially possible to attack Blockchain integrity by amassing the majority of computational capacity among the people computing the blockchain. Who would be computing blockchain changes in the NASDAQ case and what are the implications of this kind of attack for NASDAQ? Apologies if this is a silly question.
- bwood 12y agoI'm assuming that they're specifically using the Bitcoin blockchain, not necessarily starting their own from scratch. If they want their own blockchain, then they need to distribute the mining just like Bitcoin has done, or else it defeats the purpose of having a blockchain (i.e., might as well just run their own centralized service without a blockchain). So, assuming they're building on the Bitcoin blockchain, then Bitcoin miners will be computing the blockchain changes and NASDAQ will be participating by issuing special transactions that enable whatever it is that they're building.
- markkat 12y agoAll miners 'compute on' the same blockchain. That is, they compete for the priviledge of adding the next block for the mining and transaction rewards that come with it. Thus, NASDAQ transactions (as all bitcoin transactions) are secured by the hashing power of the global network. In short, that's why NASDAQ is using bitcoin rather than their own blockchain app, as it is the most secure blockchain in terms of a computational attack.
- jackgavigan 12y agoNasdaq is (apparently) using the Bitcoin Blockchain, so the same people who mine bitcoins will be adding Nasdaq's transactions to the Blockchain. Anyone with a large amount of Bitcoin mining capacity is implicitly incentivised to not mount an attack on the integrity of the Blockchain because doing so would probably dent confidence in Bitcoin, causing the price to drop. That would reduce the "net present value" that the miner can expect to receive going forward, likely by more than the short-term "win" they could achieve through a successful attack. However, if the Blockchain is being used for other purposes (e.g. recording ownership of high-value assets) and the potential gain to someone with a large amount of mining power of attacking/rewriting the Blockchain is large enough that it significantly outweighs the "net present value" that can be realised from normal mining operations, then the incentive to not attack the Blockchain is somewhat diminished.
- this_user 12y ago> Anyone with a large amount of Bitcoin mining capacity is implicitly incentivised to not mount an attack on the integrity of the Blockchain because doing so would probably dent confidence in Bitcoin, causing the price to drop. That would reduce the "net present value" that the miner can expect to receive going forward, likely by more than the short-term "win" they could achieve through a successful attack. That's the argument Bitcoin advocates always use, but it oversimplifies the problem. The assumption is that no one would do this, because it is not in their long-term best interest. What it leaves out that mounting one attack of a series of attacks in quick succession may actually make it worth the costs in the short-term. This is especially true when we talk about large amounts of real assets. Furthermore, there may be malicious entities that are prepared to pay the costs just for the sake of wreaking havoc. The argument that 51% attacks cannot happen has, in fact, already been disproven since there is evidence that the GHash mining pool did perform such an attack [1]. All it takes for something like this to happen is one rogue employee in an organisation that controls enough hashing power. [1] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=327767.0 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=327767.0
- kens 12y agoNot to be paranoid, but there's always the possibility that some government agency has built >>50% of the mining capacity, just in case they want to take control. And if they're mining with it now (split among pools), this capacity would partially pay for itself. You'd never know they have control until it's too late.
- wardb 12y agoNasdaq is doing an experiment. Not going all-in with Bitcoin as the title suggests.
- sanswork 12y agoOverselling non-news into massive victories is basically what the bitcoin community does. I could list 25 things that were going to bring Bitcoin mainstream over the past 2-3 years without even trying that have all failed to pan out. Since failures fade away silently most of the time they are left wondering why these 'victories' aren't leading to increased prices and repeating the phrase "how can we have all this good news and no increase in price?".
- drcross 12y agoBitcoin has also died over 70 times- http://bitcoinobituaries.com http://bitcoinobituaries.com so maybe it's not a bitcoin community problem but just journalists creating linkbait.
- sanswork 12y agoHave you ever read through that list? Most of them don't say it has died they say it is dying. Given the amount of investment, the number of new services, and the publicity it has received over the past 2 years the complete lack of interest from the general public says it probably is. Will it disappear anytime soon? Not a chance. Is it past its peak? Did it miss its chance at mainstream success? Quite possibly.
- IkmoIkmo 12y ago> Is it past its peak? Did it miss its chance at mainstream success? Quite possibly. Quite possibly but it's too soon to tell. The fact is that price isn't always the best proxy for success. More people using it, more companies getting involved etc, can be more important. When we look at price historically we can find strange things like the price being a fraction of a dollar (some 70 cents or so) in April in 2011. Only a few months later, in June 2011, the price was $30. And then it collapsed that very same year and the price dropped to $2, a few times more than it was earlier, but far from the peak. It'd have been pretty myopic to then conclude that bitcoin was past its peak, even though in the short term it was, having lost more than 90% of its value at peak. It'd also have been wrong to say it missed its chance at mainstream success. Today the price is an order of magnitude larger, and users, usage and involvement with mainstream (large) companies has grown even more. So again, it's quite possible, but I think too soon to tell. As for the lack of interest from the general public... I think bitcoin at its core is a utility, like you could say the internet is. The internet is extremely uninteresting to people, very few get it, nobody is excited about it. But the web is huge, as is emailing and skype and netflix. That's completely different from the Internet though, the boring platform/utility/infrastructure that supports it. I can't blame someone not being interested in bitcoin. But internet of things having digital wallets and doing payments, contracts, deeds etc on the bitcoin ledger, where all the consumer sees is that it 'just works', that's interesting. It's up to companies then to build ontop of bitcoin, and there is tons of interest from companies, both startups and traditional (tech) companies. Which means it's not very surprising to see companies and VCs get excited, but the general public not, in the same way that few got excited about the Internet, but Internet entrepreneurs did, who built companies like Amazon or Skype that people did get excited about. The fact that bitcoin couldn't start out like that and had to grow based on a small amount of fanatics looking to avoid the dollar/euro/etc and live on a new currency is probably a great source of distraction from the larger point of bitcoin as a platform, as it reduces bitcoin to being a currency used to shop online and not many feel like doing that, making it look as there is no interest from the general public and nobody will ever use it etc.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- VikingCoder 12y agoI hate "proof-of-work." Sure, it's possible it's the only way to get all of the benefits that we all love. But I really wish there was a better way.
- drcode 12y agoWell... you know there's this thing called "proof-of-stake"... (I know, POS is much maligned, but once people see more currencies using it and succeeding I think public opinion will change)
- oleganza 12y agoImagine you are sitting in the bunker and only get some bits of data from outside world. You cannot have any other trusted source of information about these bits except from the bits themselves. And there's a plenty of reasons for someone to actively try to deceive you ("active attackers" as in "hostile environment"). You have no idea how many people are out there and how much they are connected and who is connected to you. You are just sitting in this blinded box with a radio station. Your goal is to make sure that whatever bits you receive are exactly the same as everyone else is seeing. In other words, that it is practically impossible for an attacker to produce alternative bits satisfying your requirements and show them to someone else (and not showing to you). One way to make it is to make these bits fully predictable (like digits of Pi), but that's not useful. Another way is to implement a gigantic ever-growing proof-of-work that implements the condition of "practical impossibility". You receive some bits with such a big pile of PoW that you can be sure it's not possible for someone to quietly build an alternative bunch of bits with the same PoW and unleash it on you or anyone else. Protein folding and proof of stake do not help with this problem. You need abstract ever-growing scarcity implemented by converting energy into a short number. You might ask: why should we be so strict with the security requirement? Well, because history of civilization shows that people always try really hard to build hierarchies of power to manipulate property and human beings. Any system of global consensus outside of existing power structures will face huge amount of resistance and therefore must be designed from ground up to withstand it.
- VikingCoder 11y ago
- k2enemy 12y agoBob Greifeld, Nasdaq’s chief executive, said: “Utilising the blockchain is a natural digital evolution for managing physical securities. Once you cut the apron strings of need for the physical, the opportunities we can envision blockchain providing stand to benefit not only our clients, but the broader global capital markets.” What?
- this_user 12y ago"144 MB per day ought to be enough for anybody." -- NASDAQ The problem with trying to store data that does not represent actual BTC transactions in the Blockchain is that it simply does not offer a lot of storage space. Currently one 1 MB block is added on average every 10 minutes. That's 144 MB a day that the chain can store. The miners operating the network receive a reward of 25 BTC per block plus transaction fees. At a price of 235 USD/BTC that is at least ~5900 USD per MB stored which makes storing anything in the BC extremely expensive. Unless the BTC developers make a decision to implement changes in order to improve the scalability of the network, I really don't see why you would even try to use the BC for something like this. When you start to actually store meaningful amounts data in the BC, you are going to jam the network since there is no elastic supply of storage space. Secondly, the increased demand for inclusion of transactions is going to drive the transaction fees higher. In the end, you will have a high costs for a solution that does not even remotely offer the kind of performance you need.
- vectorpush 12y agoI'm going for a "wait and see" attitude on this one because I suspect there must be some hidden opportunity to extract wealth from the blockchain that I'm just not smart enough to see, but just by reading the article, it seems like this is another case of "groundbreaking because... blockchain." FTA: The company will be creating “coloured coins”, appending special information to the blockchain indicating that a particular fraction of a particular bitcoin can be redeemed according to the terms written into it. That coloured coin can then be passed around just like a normal bitcoin, while preserving a record of who owns the asset it is linked to. Ok. I don't have an inherent dislike for bitcoin. I understand how bitcoin works. I understand the incentives. I've read the whitepaper. I don't see how decentralization is useful for this task. Why would I want to store asset records on the blockchain? What does this make possible that isn't already possible without the massive computational overhead of a global decentralized ledger? I understand the implications that financial assets can be tagged to colored coins and that those coins can be traded without the need for a third party. I understand that it's all public and that the blockchain's data integrity is fortified through global consensus. Why does this matter? What does this make possible? I also wonder how the institutions will react when rich investors start getting their colored coins stolen by hackers. Will the NASDAQ honor the value of APPL colored coins that were pilfered from someone's laptop? What about in situations where coins are lost or accidentally sent to the wrong address? Will some random bitcoiner wake up one day to discover that they're a majority shareholder of Microsoft? As I said, I'll wait and see, because if I was as smart as these finance people then I'd probably have an apartment in the heart of Manhattan to prove it.
- sktrdie 11y agoIt allows one to put a piece of information on the internet, and as long as the network lives, nobody can possibly remove that piece of information. It's stuck there forever. Not sure if that will be useful or not in the future, but that sort of thing was not possible before bitcoin came along. I look at bitcoin more as a breakthrough computer science theoretical finding. It's not just an idea that needs to "make something possible". It exists in nature whether we find a use case for it or not.