5 ms·
I see the Times playing up the nationalistic components but the truth is that people go to companies, learn stuff, and start new companies doing the same thing
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
I see the Times playing up the nationalistic components but the truth is that people go to companies, learn stuff, and start new companies doing the same thing only better all the time. It is perhaps even more rampant in California with its employee protection laws but it isn't unusual anywhere in the US.
The question I have is that if several students of a prominent professor at Harvard go to work at Intel and AMD as electrical engineers, and then later get together to form their own company, still in the US, to make a really energy efficient x86 equivalent processor, is that economic espionage or innovation? Generally we've held it to be the latter.
And then there is the number of students getting advanced degrees in the US from really bright professors, but are unable to get a Visa to actually work in the US?
It is hard for me to be outraged here.
- snissn 12y agoThanks for very eloquently expressing my reaction to the article!
- spcoll 12y agoIt does sound like witch hunting with a McCarthyist nationalistic vibe. Overall the brain drain from China to the US has been working to the benefit of the US, for years. I expect we will more and more such propaganda pieces in the NYT and elsewhere, as China is being increasingly positioned as "the Adversary".
- jtzhou 12y agoYes. Chinese Americans earn on average 30% more than other U.S. adults. http://www.pewresearch.org/daily-number/asian-americans-lead-all-others-in-household-income/ http://www.pewresearch.org/daily-number/asian-americans-lead... While regrettable, the loss of some technology does not compensate for all of the advantages to the States of highly skilled immigrants from China. The top ranked comments on NYTimes are ignorant and do not describe the full picture.
- meric 12y agoParents of Chinese Americans would have had to have been well-off almost by definition to afford sending their children to the U.S. It is true a lot of that wealth would have been spent or deflated due to living standard differences by the time they arrived, however the education they've previously attained as well as the mindset of trying to achieve a better future stays with them. The Chinese who bum around unemployed rorting government benefits and/or family generosity would not have come to the U.S. looking for a better future.
- formulaT 12y agoThere is an inversion in politics, where the left are more anti-Asian than the right. Letting people express anti-Asian sentiment (even though equivalent sentiment against other groups would be verboten) is both a convenient escape valve for the populace (see the LA riots) and also makes the left seem less extreme. See also the #cancelcolbert controversy[0]. Imagine if this had been any "oppressed" group instead. [0] http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-campaign-to-cancel-colbert http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-campaign-to-canc...
- mturmon 12y agoIn the case of porcelain technology, the process you describe went in reverse: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/François_Xavier_d%27Entrecolles http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/François_Xavier_d%27Entrecolles
- jsmthrowaway 12y agoYour comment lacks the context of China's economic policy. As bizarre as it sounds, Top Gear actually hit on it during one of their specials: http://youtu.be/K0bNf-jcVU0 http://youtu.be/K0bNf-jcVU0 I know it's easy to discard what you're reading as nationalism, but the Chinese have a long history of theft of intellectual property and protecting it at the state level. It isn't about national pride at all, for me; our industry is one that is directly targeted. A new iPhone is copied in weeks, and that's not only a direct shot at American exports, it's a direct shot at my work. Why should I put the work into innovating when cheap copies will flood the market? There's a slight difference between incremental improvement and the economic espionage described in the article, though I grant you the line is fine. You're potentially starting to see more desperate maneuvers (this isn't the first, and I agree with you that it's a potential stretch) because it's really hard to prosecute most of these and it's been an issue for a long time.
- pyre 12y agoThere is a difference between PRC specifically sending agents to the US to steal specific technologies, and a random group of Chinese nationals deciding to take US tech back home and profit off of it.
- jsmthrowaway 12y agoYou're implying that you can discern the difference.
- derefr 12y agoNo, the reverse; the implication is that, since you can't tell the difference, you should be charitable and assume it's just some random people with a coincidental feature of X, rather than an X-ist conspiriacy. A lack of this kind of charity is what creates ideas like "the jews control the banks" or "the gay agenda."
- azakai 12y agoIndeed, and furthermore, because of the sheer size of the population of China, it shouldn't surprise us to see stories about this that involve Chinese nationals. It's not surprising there are lots of great people but also less-great ones as well; it's a big country! To actually suggest that there is some "organized Chinese conspiracy" thing happening, someone would need to show that this happens more often than statistically expected.
- themartorana 12y agoAgreed. More conspiratorially, one comment on the article pointed out how easily this distracts from things like zero indictments of bankers for 2008, any administration officials for Iraq, NSA domestic spying and monitoring, holding Manning in solitary while Petraeus gets a slap on the wrist and a pension, and so on, and so on. It's hard to take it as very conspiratorial, though, because all of the things listed are absolute atrocities.
- qiqing 12y ago+1. It's hard for the U.S. to take the moral high ground on espionage outrage until China's equivalent of the NSA has their fingers in as many pies. But it's conveniently easy for journalists to forget that.
- frigg 12y agoI think your point is interesting but the article refers to company secrets mostly.
- virtuabhi 12y agoFrom the article - "Other emails cited in the indictment run through 2013, and the government contends they included a “stolen Avago design kit” for the chips." You can obviously start a new company in the same field, just make sure you don't violate non-complete clause (if it exists). However, stealing code or product design is a strict NO whether you are in Silicon Valley or a University.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI was wondering about that. Generally you don't need to steal a design kit[1], the manufacturer gives them away at seminars and training in order to help you understand how their parts are used. If I were going to start building a chip to compete with these guys I'd definitely want an evaluation board to test to see if my chip was a work alike to the competitor's chip. [1] http://www.avagotech.com/pages/en/rf_microwave/demo_boards/ http://www.avagotech.com/pages/en/rf_microwave/demo_boards/
- A_COMPUTER 12y agoYour government feeds your kids when your career get "disrupted" by another American company, maybe they took your jerbs but they pay taxes that goes into a pot that helps other Americans. The company goes overseas, and that's jobs and money happening in a system (say, China's) that doesn't owe you a thing if you're made destitute because of it.