4 ms·
We sell SSL certificates and we're quite proud of it. > can't offer SGC certificates We could sell SGC products today if we wanted to - we have the API keys,
by nailer 12y ago
We sell SSL certificates and we're quite proud of it.
> can't offer SGC certificates
We could sell SGC products today if we wanted to - we have the API keys, a partner account with another certificate provider (not Digicert), and a node module written for the relevant REST API. We don't want to.
> are basically whinging that their competitor is marketing their certificates on a feature people don't need.
Marketing certificates on a feature people don't need - and making it seem as if they need it - is wrong.
> That's basically par for the course when selling to businesses, especially where non-technical people are in a position of deciding whether to buy, and which vendor to chose from.
Being common does not make it right.
If you think it does: what's the name of your startup? Your bio is empty, and I think most of HN would be interested in knowing the name of a business that thinks this is OK.
Furthermore it's not 'par for the course': many other CAs don't sell IE5 support as hard as Symantec does. Here's DigiCert writing against SGC (we use DigiCert as our CA) https://www.digicert.com/sgc-ssl-certificates.htm https://www.digicert.com/sgc-ssl-certificates.htm, here's their competitor GoDaddy writing against SGC: http://agrihortico.com/freedownloads/SGC.pdf http://agrihortico.com/freedownloads/SGC.pdf
- dogecoinbase 12y agowhat's the name of your startup? Your bio is empty, and I think most of HN would be interested in knowing the name of a business that thinks this is OK. Ugh, seriously? I was vaguely fine with the blog post before (though it is a bit advertisement-y for HN in context), but this is reprehensible (at least in the context of judging companies by the stances their employees take...).
- javert 12y agoIt's also reprehensible to say that it's OK for companies to cheat their cusomters. I don't think the CertSimple guy was actually trying to boycott that guy's company, he was trying to make a point.
- lanaius 12y agoI read it as a mixed call to boycott (and shaming) together with an appeal to CertSimple's expertise; "I don't see you actually having any startups, and thus your opinion is meaningless. If you do have a startup you certainly are a bad startup."
- nailer 12y agoIt's a simple statement that companies shouldn't cheat their customers, nor should we support companies (including HN startups) that think it is OK to cheat their customers.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoI guess the author of the post, seeing someone defending what Symantec's doing, seems to have mistakenly assumed they are a Symantec employee. Perhaps they jumped to conclusions to quickly.
- bjterry 12y agoIs DigiCert able to provide SGC but they choose not to, or are they unable to do so?
- yuhong 12y agoBrowsers only trusted a limited number of roots for SGC. I wonder if any SGC certs actually were issued off "GTE CyberTrust Root" that expired in 2006.
- vtlynch 12y agoDo you know how to identify if a Root can issue SGC certs? I am seeing an OID (2.16.840.1.113730.4.1) in the EKU field for both End-Entity and Intermediate Certs from Thawte, but nothing on the Root. Was the ability to issue an SGC cert more of a policy thing than an actual flag in the cert? I BELIEVE that DigiCert used to issue certs with SGC if you specially requested it, but I cant find any sources on that at the moment.
- yuhong 12y agoIt was a list built into the browser. For IE/SChannel they hardcoded two roots (into RSABASE.DLL/RSAENH.DLL I think), the VeriSign Class 3 root and "Root SGC Authority". When they added new roots into IE 5.01/NT4 SP6/Win2000, they made some of them SGC capable by shipping cross certificates to this "Root SGC Authority" (you can still see them if you have a WinXP system). The reason Thawte SGC SuperCerts uses the VeriSign root now was that this particular cross certificate expired in 2004.
- nailer 12y agoI'm not sure re: Digicert, we (CertSimple) have an alternate certificate source that can provide SGC certificates, and choose not to.
- alex_sf 12y agoJust so you know, from a third party perspective, this reply looks ridiculous.
- umanwizard 12y agoSince when does everyone on HN automatically work for a startup?
- drzaiusapelord 12y ago>If you think it does: what's the name of your startup? Your bio is empty, and I think most of HN would be interested in knowing the name of a business that thinks this is OK. So much for the recent initiative of a calmer more respectful discourse here at HN. Now its "criticize my company? Fuck you, who do you work for so I can criticize you!"
- yellowapple 12y ago> what's the name of your startup? Why do you assume that every HN user is involved with some startup?