5 ms·
How Symantec upsells Internet Explorer 5 SSL support in 2015
- nailer 12y agoAuthor here. Asides from the 'Introduction to SSL' page mentioned in the article, there's a few other places Symantec mention SGC/IE5 support, including http://www.symantec.com/ssl-certificates/ http://www.symantec.com/ssl-certificates/ - the 1st and 3rd products include SGC/IE5 support and are more expensive than the equivalent (non 'Pro') products without SGC/IE5 support. Hopefully this results in Symantec (and the resellers who use their marketing materials) making it clear that SGC technology only applies to very old browsers, rather than Symantec sending a nastygram to my office.
- yuhong 12y agoThey at least have finally began to switch to marketing ECDSA certificates as the main difference now, especially as SHA1 certs becomes obsolete. Last time I checked Symantec's site I actually have to specifically look for SGC to find this stuff now.
- vtlynch 12y agoYou are right Yuhong. Symantec's "Pro" products used to advertise SGC, now they are using ECDSA instead.
- yuhong 12y agoThawte have at least began hiding the SGC option. Also note that Netscape Step-Up (not to be confused with MS SGC) depends on insecure renegotiation, which is disabled in many servers now (I have a few pcaps I did with Netscape 4 showing this, and I really should factor the 512-bit RSA keys in some of them at some point). Another trivia is when VeriSign began selling EV certs in 2007 they only sold it with SGC, even though it was becoming obsolete even back then.
- coldcode 12y agoVeriSign, GeoTrust, Thawte and RapidSSL are all Symnantec? What a racket. Clever work, Certsimple.
- nailer 12y agoYes: http://www.netcraft.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/certauth_all4.png http://www.netcraft.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/certauth_... And thanks!
- richardwhiuk 12y agoWorth noting that CertSimple is a competitor of Symantec, and can't offer SGC certificates, so they are basically whinging that their competitor is marketing their certificates on a feature people don't need. That's basically par for the course when selling to businesses, especially where non-technical people are in a position of deciding whether to buy, and which vendor to chose from. It'd also be nice if HackerNews wasn't quite so populated with thinly veiled ads for companies disguised as blog posts.
- nailer 12y agoWe sell SSL certificates and we're quite proud of it. > can't offer SGC certificates We could sell SGC products today if we wanted to - we have the API keys, a partner account with another certificate provider (not Digicert), and a node module written for the relevant REST API. We don't want to. > are basically whinging that their competitor is marketing their certificates on a feature people don't need. Marketing certificates on a feature people don't need - and making it seem as if they need it - is wrong. > That's basically par for the course when selling to businesses, especially where non-technical people are in a position of deciding whether to buy, and which vendor to chose from. Being common does not make it right. If you think it does: what's the name of your startup? Your bio is empty, and I think most of HN would be interested in knowing the name of a business that thinks this is OK. Furthermore it's not 'par for the course': many other CAs don't sell IE5 support as hard as Symantec does. Here's DigiCert writing against SGC (we use DigiCert as our CA) https://www.digicert.com/sgc-ssl-certificates.htm https://www.digicert.com/sgc-ssl-certificates.htm, here's their competitor GoDaddy writing against SGC: http://agrihortico.com/freedownloads/SGC.pdf http://agrihortico.com/freedownloads/SGC.pdf
- dogecoinbase 12y agowhat's the name of your startup? Your bio is empty, and I think most of HN would be interested in knowing the name of a business that thinks this is OK. Ugh, seriously? I was vaguely fine with the blog post before (though it is a bit advertisement-y for HN in context), but this is reprehensible (at least in the context of judging companies by the stances their employees take...).
- merb 12y agoSSL will never be good, Encryption which only a few can afford is mostly not good. Also most SSL Providers have their seat in USA, which also means that we NEVER knew if the encryption could be decrypted. Encryption which will be held by any "bigger" company will also have this flaw, even from germany or any other european company (any company in any country will have that flaw). The only encryption that would work, would be self made encryption, which is barely supported by browsers. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNS-based_Authentication_of_Named_Entities#Applications http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNS-based_Authentication_of_Nam...
- fmela 12y agoRegarding your first point, the people at https://letsencrypt.org/ https://letsencrypt.org/ are working to address that.
- Grue3 12y agoletsencrypt.org seems to be the new GNU Hurd or Duke Nukem Forever.
- ikeboy 12y agoAn SSL provider doesn't have your encryption keys. They could MITM your site, but at a risk that whoever gets MITMed has cryptographic proof that they issued a cert illegally, which if publicised would get them dropped. See google/china for the most recent incident where this happened. Also, if you simply implement public key pinning, you can no longer be MITMed.
- vtlynch 12y agoThese points have been debunked dozens of times. SSL is EASILY affordable. Not only are there free options, but many sites provide widely-trusted certs for around $7/yr. There is little legitimacy behind the claims that the US has backdoored encryption via the actual algorithm. Cryptography professionals have pointed to a few specific ECC curves that may have issues but there is nothing conslusive. Im assuming by "self made encryption" you mean self-signed certs. These will never work - first off they do nothing to compensate for algorithmic flaws which you purport exist. They also provide no identity assurance, which makes it impossible to determine the difference between a legitimate/illegitimate key change.
- JoblessWonder 12y agoI think this is less malicious and more lazy... Isn't this just a super-outdated marketing webpage for a certain global market that was never taken down or redirected to the updated version? I'm able to load the site, but when I click on any of the menu options I'm given a redesigned site with an updated version of the SSL options. [1] I thought it might be a regional thing since this was in Asia-Pacific so I switched the "aa" to "uk" and that tab doesn't even exist anymore. [2] Although I was only able to get to a few pages before my browser session was blacklisted as well. Sigh. Pretty annoying. [3] Luckily it is cookie based and not IP based. (I don't think it needs to be said but I have no relation to Symantec or Certsimple.) [1] http://www.symantec.com/en/aa/ssl-certificates/?inid=aa_ghp_cont1_vrsnsslcerts http://www.symantec.com/en/aa/ssl-certificates/?inid=aa_ghp_... [2] http://www.symantec.com/en/uk/page.jsp?id=how-ssl-works&tabID=3# http://www.symantec.com/en/uk/page.jsp?id=how-ssl-works&tabI... [3] I'm now greeted with: Access Denied You don't have permission to access "http://www.symantec.com/" http://www.symantec.com/" on this server.
- nailer 12y agoYeah it's weird: some locales for 'Introduction to SSL' have the old copy, some have a newer version with SGC removed. (edit: removed ref to Secure Site Pro page - as yuhong points out below, it looks like the Pro product has been redefined to be non-SGC now)
- yuhong 12y agoBut notice there is no mention of SGC anymore, and instead they mention ECDSA now. And you can only actually get SGC by getting a SHA1 certificate.
- vtlynch 12y agoSymantec removed SGC from their products about 1-2 months ago. So you are right, these are outdated - but they are not relics. Symantec was peddling SGC pretty strongly before then, including "SGC" in the name of their products.
- mey 12y agoFor those doing their own research. This is some data I pulled together last year. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1jzZqGzvtHe4egYNnp1L4-df_avGjEqMZiv0FWFP4d4E/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1jzZqGzvtHe4egYNnp1L4...
- iancarroll 12y agoMind if I add certly.io?
- mey 12y agoSend me an e-mail (scott.markwell@gmail.com) with a email to give edit access too.
- nailer 12y agoNice! The main point of CertSimple is 80 second EV application process (including generating the CSR) and EV issuance in an average of five hours - this could be a worthwhile addition to the the 'Notes' column.
- mey 12y agoSend me an e-mail (scott.markwell@gmail.com) with a email to give edit access too.