It certainly doesn't have a right to publish those materials. It has every right to index them. I agree that Google News will need to die if the publishers do

It certainly doesn't have a right to publish those materials. It has every right to index them. I agree that Google News will need to die if the publishers don't want them to list their news there, but the actual search engine itself? Indexing is not publishing. How many times do we have to fight this battle?