4 ms·
At root, this is all just a quibble over terminology. The fundamental problem is that there are two reasonable time standards for different applications: mean
by lisper 12y ago
At root, this is all just a quibble over terminology. The fundamental problem is that there are two reasonable time standards for different applications: mean solar seconds for ordinary day-to-day timekeeping, and cesium seconds for applications that require a precision of more than a second per year. These two standards drift, so you have two choices:
1. Let them drift
2. Introduce a computational complication (leap seconds) to synchronize them
But the dispute is not over which of these is "right", the dispute is over which of these two options gets to go by the label "UTC". This could be easily resolved by simply defining two UTCs, one with leap seconds, and the other without. You could call them UTC-L and UTC-N (or UTC-S and UTC-N if you wanted to mollify the French ;-).
- Zikes 12y agoI should imagine it would be easier to use the cesium seconds for UTC and just bundle everything else into the time zone offsets, which everyone is already using to turn scientific timekeeping into something "meaningful" for human consumption.
- SEMW 12y ago"Like UTC but without adding leap seconds" already exists; it's called TAI (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Atomic_Time http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Atomic_Time)
- lisper 12y agoThen what is really at issue here? Is it really a dispute about whether WWV broadcasts (what is currently known as) UTC or TAI?
- gpvos 12y agoBasically, yes. (Not only WWV, but also DCF77 et al., of course.) Several countries have enshrined UTC in law, so it's a pretty big thing.
- gpvos 12y ago...and just to add that this enshrining in law was most likely done with the general expectation that UTC would keep a close relationship with solar time.
- imh 12y agoWe already have these. UTC keeps the the time lined up with an earth day, while GPS and TAI are absolute times.