3 ms·
There's a lot of back and forth between "we applaud Facebook for this initiative" and "But that's not the right way to do it" in this piece. I usually find EFF
by ekianjo 12y ago
There's a lot of back and forth between "we applaud Facebook for this initiative" and "But that's not the right way to do it" in this piece. I usually find EFF articles well written but this one was particularly painful to read and not really insightful either.
- dmix 12y agoIf you prefer polarized opinions you can find that on any mainstream news venue. In real life people tend to have nuanced and conflicted opinions about many things.
- zatkin 12y agoIt seems that enabling HTTPS on the Internet.org proxy is what the EFF wants out of the project.
- pavanky 12y agoThat is just the technical issue they are against. They also oppose the internet having singular entities acting as gatekeepers. Here is the summary from the last paragraph. We have confidence that it would be possible to provide a limited free Internet access service that is secure, *and that doesn't rely on Facebook and its partners to maintain a central list of approved sites*. Until then, Internet.org will not be living up to its promise, or its name. (emphasis mine)
- Rambunctious 12y agoAlthough slightly more nuanced than a blanket YES/NO, it would have been more helpful if there were more concrete suggestions on acceptable process mechanisms for 'limited free Internet access'.
- nitrogen 12y ago"[L]imited" probably means bandwidth limited.
- ekianjo 12y ago> If you prefer polarized opinions you can find that on any mainstream news venue I'm fine with balanced opinions but there is no need to do the back and forth multiple times through the same article.
- geoffw8 12y agoI actually respected the way they did that. They're trying to make some very serious criticisms without detracting too much from the fact that Internet.org actually got off their arses to do something about the digital divide. I think its fair. They're trying to give some degree of credit where its due, as opposed to an all out attack. Its hard for me personally to agree with an all out attack piece when I'm conscious of the seemingly good intentions of the project (conspiracies aside).
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoIt is like if someone goes to a group of starving orphans and offers them food and board and education, but in exchange they must work. On one hand, you are helping them compared to how others treat them. On the other hand, you are exploiting them for your own gain. Even ignoring the morals of offering a bad deal to someone who only has worse deals to choose from, there is the fear that such an actor would eventually evolve to lock out others who want to help without (or with less) exploitation.