8 ms·
Instead of spending $1 on something, you can burn $5 of electricity! Suppliers figure you're more likely to waste some energy than you are to type in a credit c
by wlesieutre 12y ago
Instead of spending $1 on something, you can burn $5 of electricity! Suppliers figure you're more likely to waste some energy than you are to type in a credit card number, so they say go for it.
And as the big ASIC miners get more efficient, your device will generate even less revenue. In two years, you'll be running at a small fraction of the chip's original mining rate, but still wasting just as much energy!
http://media.coindesk.com/2013/09/bitcoin-difficulty-graph.png http://media.coindesk.com/2013/09/bitcoin-difficulty-graph.p...
I'll pass, thanks.
- nosuchthing 12y agoImagine if someone made the opposite of this device, an energy generating device which could supply you with revenue [after the subsidy is paid off] and was not restricted to any particular currency ecosystem.
- bduerst 12y agoYou mean something like solar panels?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- inafewwords 12y agorun the excess energy into a bitcoin farm instead of batteries?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pavel_lishin 12y ago"Hang on, I just rode my bike to the office, let me plug it into my parking spot so I can discharge the capacitor and get paid for the ride up here and I'll come up to your office."
- mentat 12y agoReminds me of The Calorie Man which is quite good if disturbing. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7805265-the-calorie-man https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7805265-the-calorie-man
- def_illiterate 12y agoWe're having fun at this, but I think you may have just found a way to better gamify wellness initiatives...
- nols 12y agoBicycle riders only produce a few hundred watts, while an average kilowatt/hr is worth 12 cents.
- wcoenen 12y agoIt's kilowatt-hour, not kilowatt/hour. Multiply, not divide.
- bryogenic 12y agoIt's kilowatt*hour not kilowatt-hour. Multiply, not subtract.
- michaeldunworth 12y agoHaha, thought the same.
- pablovidal85 12y agoExercise bikes that mine bitcoin. Hey Tesla, who needs batteries if you can store energy as monetary value.
- IkmoIkmo 12y agoIt'd be like putting a tiny solar panel on your retail consumer grade router, one that degrades very rapidly over time, and generates electricity at a higher cost than to simply buy it (from industrial grade dedicated solar parks), in a world where you can send energy as easily as sending email, or for that matter, bitcoin. It's ridiculous. I'm curious about the bigger picture because they have a stellar team, backing, board and bank account right now.
- zapdrive 12y agoThe graph you linked is very old. The hashrate is plateauing[0]. 0 https://blockchain.info/charts/hash-rate?showDataPoints=false&show_header=true&daysAverageString=7×pan=all https://blockchain.info/charts/hash-rate?showDataPoints=fals...
- wlesieutre 12y agoOh good. The one I linked was just what showed up first on Google. Still, I doubt hashrate will level off entirely. And if 21 is successful (I hope not...), they'll continue to drive it up further than it would have gone otherwise.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- notsony 12y agoThe perpetual SHA256 hashing machine... Did anybody tell 21 that pure proof-of-work hashing was just an experiment and could go the way of the dinosaur? Ethereum, Nxt and other cryptocurrencies are already using proof-of-stake or some other hybrid process...
- DennisP 12y agoEthereum isn't using proof-of-stake quite yet, that's planned for a later version in a year or so. They're starting out with a proof-of-work algorithm that's designed to be ASIC-resistant. (It's heavy on memory bandwidth, which is already optimized in GPUs.) Not that this makes any difference to your point, of course.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- woah 12y agoAre you sure?
- DennisP 12y agoYes. Here's the forum on ethereum mining: https://forum.ethereum.org/categories/mining https://forum.ethereum.org/categories/mining And a blog entry from half a year ago that describes their plans: https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/12/17/ethereum-dξv/ https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/12/17/ethereum-dξv/
- daggerhashimoto 12y agodagger hashimoto
- oska 12y agoMore like spend 5 millionths of a cent's worth of electricity to receive a transaction token that trades for 1 millionth of a cent. But that token (1 satoshi) has much more utility than as just a store of value and has been loaded onto your personal device without you having to do anything. And can be used by software on your personal device to give you extra functionality without again you having to do anything. Or even really understanding how it works or what is going on at the technical level. People walk around with extra apps on their phones consuming battery life all the time. If a user was presented with an option to turn on some hardware in their phone that gave them all sorts of interesting additional functionality and at the same time were warned that it would decrease the battery life of their phone by 1 or 2 percent then I think you have a viable proposition.
- monochromatic 12y agoWhy not have a background app that periodically purchases a satoshi now and then?
- bri3d 12y agoBut provided a Satoshi has a magical value beyond as a way to make transactions, why not spend 2 millionths of a cent where electricity is less valuable (i.e., before it's been converted in a lossy fashion many times and stored in my pocket where it's worth a lot more) and just transfer that Satoshi to a wallet on the phone? This play only makes sense if someone is extracting the actual currency value of a Bitcoin somewhere along the line. If that value is going to me as the consumer, it's a terrible trade because it's taking the electricity that's gone through the most conversion losses from me in the place where it's most valuable. I might as well buy Bitcoin elsewhere. If some of that value is going to the chipset manufacturer or a middleman like 21, it's a straight up scam where somebody is stealing the electricity I put into my phone. An HSM for Bitcoin wallets in a phone makes a small degree of sense to me, a mining ASIC makes none whatsoever.
- joeyspn 12y ago> And as the big ASIC miners get more efficient, your device will generate even less revenue. I think that the period where plain bitcoin was seen as a mere store of value is about to end. We are entering a more exciting period which is the "bitcoin as protocol" stage, where sub-currencies (like Colored Coins, BitShares, etc) will be more valuable than bitcoin itself. And for this, tiny amounts of btc suffice. This is why I think that Balaji and his team are taking the right direction. The goal is trying to make the system as much autonomous and frictionless as possible. The first key here is autonomy: IBM has already forked Ethereum for its IoT with SmartContracts (ADEPT) [0], where for instance fridges could detect when you're running low of X and place an order for you. Generating your own tokens gives you greater autonomy and makes you relatively independent of the big mining operations/pools. The second key here is friction: the current state of UX in bitcoin-world (and crypto in general) is extremely horrible and preventing the big adoption everybody in the space is aiming for. So building and integrating a chip that generates tokens w/o the user intervention is one way of bypassing this huge UX flaw. Maybe is not the most efficient way but it's the first serious take we've seen. Extrapolating: Why should a user have to configure an account so your browser can generate/read http requests/responses? The same way, it makes sense being able to generate/read crypto tokens. The value of those tokens are not in the current (or future) stock valuation of bitcoin, but in the valuation of the objects that the tokens will be associated with: financial tools, real estate, legal contracts, etc [0] https://www.theprotocol.tv/adept-demo-ibm-samsung/ https://www.theprotocol.tv/adept-demo-ibm-samsung/ PS: btw I think Ethereum and distributed PoW/PoS is a more efficient use of the blockchain tech.