6 ms·
We Need More Autopsies, to Help Save the Living
- ars 12y agoThe United States is quite large. Even 1 out of 50 is still a very large number. We have plenty of opportunities to learn everything necessary.
- andyakb 12y agoIf that 1 out of 50 was picked by random, then that might be correct, but the article makes it seem as though that isn't the case. Since most of these autopsies are conducted when foul play is suspected or when the cause of death is unknown, that doesn't help doctors improve in the cases where they thought they knew the cause of death but were wrong.
- mikhailt 12y ago1. Many of them are natural causes, third party (murder, suicide, accidents), and so on that are not necessarily caused by diseases or unexpected pathogens of which the doctors want to learn about. Remember the early autopsy reasons in the article: "In the United States, we usually don’t autopsy people unless the cause of death is mysterious or foul play is suspected." 2. What about races, gender, blood types, ages, and so on? The progression of the disease is different in each combination, so when factoring these factors in, 1 out of 50 really isn't that big of a number.
- maaku 12y agoHow do I _prevent_ an autopsy from being performed on me? As a cryonicist, I find what is being advocated for very scary...
- vdaniuk 12y agoWhy would you?
- peter303 12y agoIt is no longer "you" when your body is dead.
- ivank 12y agoYou brain still has all of "you" when you're legally dead though, at least for a few hours, probably longer if cooled properly. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information-theoretic_death http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information-theoretic_death
- maaku 12y agoLegal death is not the same as biological death.
- ggreer 12y agoYou may not remember, but part of the cryo signup process involves declaring a religious objection to autopsy.[1] (No state has an irreligious objection to autopsy, but they don't ask for specifics.) In California, a court order is required to override it. I don't think that has ever happened. A medical examiner would only go to the courts if you were patient zero in some sort of outbreak. 1. http://www.alcor.org/Library/html/certificateofreligiousbelief.html http://www.alcor.org/Library/html/certificateofreligiousbeli...
- mikeash 12y agoUsing a religious objection for this seems appropriate. The belief that you can live forever by if your body is frozen after death is more or less the same as the belief that you can live forever if your body is intact and you worshipped the right deity.
- ggreer 12y agoI don't want to stray too far from the original topic, but your equivocation is unwarranted. Unlike religions, cryonics actually has evidence behind it. Modern cryoprotectants allow for accurate preservation of brain nanostructure. Axons and even synaptic vesicles are kept intact. In fact, Alcor's cryopreservation protocols have already been used successfully on small mammal organs, such as rabbit kidneys.[1] Kidneys are harder to preserve than brains, as they have less vasculature to allow saturation with cryoprotectants. Does all this mean that pumping a brain full of cryoprotectants and cooling it to -196°C will preserve its memories? Possibly, but we don't know. Cryobiologists and cryonics researchers readily admit this, and they're working to find the answer.[2] If that sort of thinking is religious, then call me a zealot. 1. http://www.21cm.com/pdfs/12FahyORG5-3%5B1%5D.pdf http://www.21cm.com/pdfs/12FahyORG5-3%5B1%5D.pdf 2. https://vimeo.com/22766034 https://vimeo.com/22766034 Starting around 33:05, Dr. Brian Wowk talks about memory preservation. He's quite frank about the fact that there's not proof, just a good likelihood that current methods preserve memory and personality. Then he outlines some next steps for research.
- qqqgg 12y ago
- gmarx 12y agoTell your family not to consent to it
- niels_olson 12y agoYou need to die a natural death and have been seen by your physician within the last year and they have to be willing to sign the death certificate. All other bodies become the coroner's jurisdiction. They can waive them, or they may do an external examination only, but once they have jurisdiction, it's out of your hands. Even then, at least in San Diego, the medical examiner reviews all death certificates and they occasionally pull one in due to something sounding fishy.
- mapt 12y ago"Not really; not always; and sometimes not even with causes of death you’d think would show up easily in a good scan. Doctors take far too much confidence in scan results, feeling they see everything with certainty. They don’t. As a Florida coroner told me a few years ago, “We get this all the time. The doctors get our report and call and say, ‘But there can’t be a lacerated aorta. We did a whole set of scans.’" I would note that postmortem scans, done once the patient is deceased, can be substantially higher fidelity, because there is no concern about radiation exposure in X-ray tomography of arbitrary contrast and number of slices, and after that metal bits can be removed at will for MRI of arbitrary strength, duration, and confinement on a nonmoving subject. Blood tests can be run in standard panels. DNA tests can reveal CoD correlations. All of this, streamlined, without a surgical autopsy & reporting being performed, seems like a tractable middle ground.
- fragsworth 12y agoWow, that would be an incredible source of data and a boon to the world. Imagine if it were 1) required by all deaths, and 2) freely released to researchers (for research purposes).
- infogulch 12y agoEven better if it included doctors' notes, diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment before death.
- niels_olson 12y agoWe do postmortem scans of all autopsies at our hospital. We still do the actual autopsy too. Lots of stuff is still required such as toxicology specimens (including toxicology of solid organ tissue like liver), There's also a fair amount of artifact in autopsy scans due to lack of blood flow, medical interventions (CPR-induced lung contusions, broken ribs, hemorrhages, etc)
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoI understand that there are 1400 different brands of over-the-counter medication that contain acetaminophen. That's what destroyed my father's liver.
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoIs there some rational reason you downvoted this? He was taking tylenol for neuralgia. It harmed his liver so bad he had severe jaundice. He was barely able to walk and was completely unable to speak. He died at the age of 68.
- mikeash 12y agoMaybe because it's completely off topic?
- niels_olson 12y agoIt isn't really off-topic, but he didn't show the connection. I'm starting to think a lot of what gets perceived as trolling is people trying to make a contribution but failing to show the connection from where the group is to where they are. Then the group comes down hard and then the "troll" gets defensive.
- jkha78fnc 12y agoThank you for taking the time to state this. I read what you wrote, then what OP wrote, and realized that you were very correct in my case. Have an upvote for both of you :). @Michael - I suspect the downvoting is a reaction to your tone. The certainty with which you prevented your statement, along with its (on-the-surface) appearance of being unrelated to the conversation made it appear as if you had an axe to grind. The downvotes (I hope) were a (misguided) attempt to rectify this behavior. I bet that a lot of people who downvoted you would have supported your comment if your words were changed a little so the tone came across more clearly. Something like, "I wish there had been an autopsy done on my father, who died of renal failure. He had been advised to take XYZ medication, much of which contained acetaminophen. His autopsy could have supported science that brought awareness of cumulative acetaminophen ingestion." I am sorry for your loss. Thank you for sharing your experience -- it led me to research acetaminophen toxicity, where I found out that the deaths caused may be greatly underreported due to a variety of factors. (http://www.propublica.org/article/tylenol-mcneil-fda-behind-the-numbers http://www.propublica.org/article/tylenol-mcneil-fda-behind-...) Better post-mortem data from autopsies in cases like your fathers would go a long ways towards understanding the scope of the problem.
- goodcanadian 12y agoI find this thought provoking. When my father-in-law died, the coroner declined to do an autopsy as he was over 70. Essentially, for anyone old enough, an autopsy is considered unnecessary as death isn't all that unlikely. In some respects, that is a sensible position. However, my father-in-law's death was slightly mysterious (in the medical sense; no suspicion of foul play) as he was extremely healthy and HIS father is still alive at 100.
- niels_olson 12y agoThe coroner may have decided it was better for the family's closure to let it go. Particularly if a physician had already signed the death certificate.
- goodcanadian 12y agoNo, the decision was based entirely on his age (and standard department policy); the coroner was not subtle about it. He died at home.
- tajen 12y agoHowever, the pyramid of ages shows that our generation had 95% chances of being alive at 70. Followed by a sharp decline.
- starving_coder 12y ago"In the United States, we usually don’t autopsy people unless the cause of death is mysterious or foul play is suspected." In any case, health insurance doesn't cover autopsy. Turns out its classified as postmortem to deny insurance coverage. there was an hour long special on NPR sometime in 2014.
- sokoloff 12y agoWhy should health insurance cover autopsy? Given no chance of "recovery" from the condition, there's no health interest to the subscriber, right?
- mikeash 12y agoIf it's for the public good then it ought to be paid from taxes. If it's just to satisfy the curiosity of friends and family then maybe they could pay for it themselves. Unless it'll somehow bring the deceased back to life, it would be weird for health insurance to cover an autopsy.
- kinghajj 12y agoNot to the subscriber that has passed, but insurance companies may benefit from the knowledge acquired from autopsies. Analysis could reveal that if the company covered some drug/procedure, the overall usage rate per subscribe decreases, saving them money in the long run.
- Terr_ 12y agoIn an amoral economic sense, insurance companies don't profit by helping people eke out their problem-prone later years, versus helping generally-healthy people avoid death and stay customers. There are probably scenarios where their best-case scenario is to say: "Oh well, I guess it was his time to go" and move on.
- altcognito 12y agoIf you believe that subscribers don't have an interest in improving medicine, then yes. But medical care and the health care industry as a whole are more complicated than this.
- zxcvcxz 12y agoI'm donating my body to science. I don't see much use in having a death ceremony involving my body. Will probably be much cheaper for my family too.
- niels_olson 12y agoYou may still get autopsied. If you die of an accident, unexpectedly, or as the result of a homicide, suicide, or just because you're physician won't sign a death certificate or hasn't seen you in the last year.
- stephengillie 12y agoYour family will likely want ceremonies to help them grieve and deal with your loss. Maybe just bury an empty casket.
- Devthrowaway80 12y agoExactly. Funerals are for the living, not the dead.
- gwern 12y ago"Discrepancies between clinical and autopsy diagnosis and the value of post mortem histology; a meta-analysis and review" http://www.pathkids.com/autopsy/hasleton%20on%20discrepancies.pdf http://www.pathkids.com/autopsy/hasleton%20on%20discrepancie... , Roulson et al 2005 (excerpts: https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/e983tqSEHYE https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/e983tqSE... )
- trevdarc 12y ago"Doctors, meanwhile, learned humility. If you’re a doctor, it’s one thing to know, as an abstract fact, that 10 or 20 percent of patients who seemed to die of heart attack actually died from pulmonary embolism. It is quite another to have a pathologist dissect one of your patients and tell you No, this woman you took care for 25 years, and whose husband you pass on the street each day, did not die of heart attack; she died of a pulmonary embolism, and that’s probably why she complained of shortness of breath when you examined her three months ago. An angiogram might have spotted it." If we increase the rate of autopsies, the higher degree of accountability for doctors will lead to higher stress levels in the profession. The rate of suicide in physicians is already far above average. The US should be doing more autopsies, but we should increase them in a way that supports the profession, rather than giving our culture another way to point fingers at doctors and say "your mistake killed that person".
- stephengillie 12y agoIn software development and system administration - automation, variables, and copy-paste (instead of retyping) can be used to remove the possibility for human error to occur. Instead of seeing the number "0x80007003" and accidentally retyping it as "0x80070003", we can just copy it, and paste it into the other system. Or have the systems talk to each other and take us out of the loop. How do we remove opportunities for human error in medicine and health care?
- logfromblammo 12y agoI worked for a medical software company for a couple of years a little while ago. One of the major ingredients in the mandatory corporate beverage was the concept of "patient safety". As a severe simplification, you can think of the transition from older medical processes to newer ones as like pulling all the string parameters, string parsing, and string building out of old code and replacing it with strictly typed data. In doing so, you remove all errors generated by improperly formatted strings. That, and barcoding every damned thing in the hospital. For instance, you barcode the patient's wrist tag, and you barcode everything going out of the hospital pharmacy. When the nurses go into a room to administer a patient's meds, they scan the patient, and scan the medication. The scanner bleeps either a "yes, proceed" or a "WHOA WHOA WHOA, RIGHT THERE! WRONG MED OR WRONG PATIENT!" That last measure alone saves thousands of lives every year.[0] [0] This statistic is entirely made up, but sounds about right.[1] [1] Fine. Sort through it yourself. This ought to get you started: https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=ZQ6VX_oAAAAJ&citation_for_view=ZQ6VX_oAAAAJ:d1gkVwhDpl0C https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&h... https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=Q3v-FPAAAAAJ&citation_for_view=Q3v-FPAAAAAJ:u-x6o8ySG0sC https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&h...
- gmarx 12y agoformer pathology resident here- disagree. The main reason we do fewer autopsies is because of better diagnostics while the patient is alive. The numbers they provide for significant changes in diagnosis based on autopsy seem pretty high (based only on my own experience). Even the examples they pick for the article are kind of lame- it wasn't St. louis encephalitis, it was west nile! Um...so? Do we have a treatment now for West Nile? Would they have done something different knowing that it was west nile (honestly I don't know; I've been out of the medical biz for years)
- niels_olson 12y ago> Would they have done something different knowing that it was west nile Considering it reinforced the value proposition of county, state, and federal epidemiology units, all of whom are now monitoring crow populations, and it has launched a significant amount of research, and every primary care and ER doctor now looks for symptoms, yes, I do believe something is different.
- CatDevURandom 12y ago>> former pathology resident here The implication being that you did not complete your training. I'm curious -- if you don't mind the derailment -- why not?
- gmarx 12y agoCompleted it. Never practiced as an attending. Went into the computers instead
- sampo 12y ago> The main reason we do fewer autopsies is because of better diagnostics while the patient is alive. The article claims that "About 15 to 30 percent of the time, the diagnoses at time of death are wrong".
- gmarx 12y agoMaybe, I haven't read the study, but there is a huge selective pressure here. That is, these days you tend to order autopsies only when there was something mysterious about the death.
- ams6110 12y agoStatistically, there is no reason to autopsy all deaths or even most of them and to do so would be a fantastic waste of resources. A random sampling would suffice. What we do now is probably not random, and not sure it ever could be given the need to defer to family wishes, religious requirements, etc. in cases where no foul play is suspected.
- sampo 12y ago"In fact, we [USA] autopsy less than 5 percent of all deaths." Coming from a country (Finland) where about 25% of all deaths are autopsied, this was a surprise, that not all developed countries have a similar level.
- morekozhambu 12y agoLoad of BS! This means we need more people dead (considering autopsy is done on every body), so that we get a chance to look at more bodies and hopefully reduce the death rate in the future!!??. Is it not same as having less people die now?
- arundelo 12y agoFrom the article, which you apparently didn't read: In the United States, we usually don’t autopsy people unless the cause of death is mysterious or foul play is suspected. In fact, we autopsy less than 5 percent of all deaths.
- morekozhambu 12y agoFrom my comment, which you apparently didn't read: > considering autopsy is done on every body what I meant was, even if every body is autopsied, it wouldn't make sense