4 ms·
The AV system we voted on wasn't actually PR, any kind of PR got veto'd by the conservatives, and the Lib-Dems were perhaps foolish to try to continue with such
by ZeroGravitas 12y ago
The AV system we voted on wasn't actually PR, any kind of PR got veto'd by the conservatives, and the Lib-Dems were perhaps foolish to try to continue with such a meagre reform, as it now gets used as an excuse to not implement PR in future as "the country voted against it" (except of course they didn't, as it wasn't one of the two options they were allowed to vote for).
- JupiterMoon 12y agoI find it very sad this referendum was basically what the Lib Dems traded tuition fees for.
- EliRivers 12y agoMore sad, surely, that the UK population (and I speak as one) are stupid and easily led. We are. We really are. I despise us.
- JupiterMoon 12y agoI'm not sure that we are that stupid. I think that many people agreed with me that AV was a needlessly confusing system that the LibDems wanted only because it would boost their electoral chances in a country where there were at the time two left of centre parties and one right of centre one. (I am a supporter of single transferable vote and I didn't see it on my referedum voting sheet only FPTP [rubbish] and AV [?more/less? rubbish but still rubbish].)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rmc 12y ago> (I am a supporter of single transferable vote and I didn't see it on my referedum voting sheet only FPTP [rubbish] and AV [?more/less? rubbish but still rubbish].) Really? Because AV is what Ireland uses and called it PR-STV.
- po8crg 12y ago>Really? Because AV is what Ireland uses and called it PR-STV. This is not correct. PR-STV requires multi-member constituencies (as they have in Ireland). AV is single-member constituencies and isn't PR.
- rmc 12y agoFor elections to President of Ireland, there is only one 'seat' available. And it is elected under PR-STV. The PR-STV system works fine with only one seat. You select the quota the same way, you do transfers the same way. Ireland uses PR-STV for single-member constituancies just fine.
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoThis is, at the end of the day, mostly semantics but you can't have proportional representation, in a vote that only elects one person. It's not possible for someone to be 40% blue party and 60% red party, because there's only one of them. So, in Ireland votes for the president, and for by-elections to replace a single member use AV. STV and AV (and a bunch of variants of each) are closely related, but they do have differences, and repeatedly claiming that one is the other, when they're not, isn't that helpful to the conversation.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> This is, at the end of the day, mostly semantics but you can't have proportional representation, in a vote that only elects one person. Proportional representation is really a matter of degree rather than a binary categorization -- a system doesn't magically become proportional when you apply it to a two-member constituency that would be not-proportional when applied to a single-member constituency. OTOH, the maximum degree of proportionality you can achieve in an electoral system increases with the number of seats that are elected by the same set of ballots. STV is an election method defined for any arbitrary number of seats, IRV/AV is exactly STV applied to a single-seat election.
- po8crg 12y agoWe didn't want AV. It was the least-worst system we could talk the Tories into voting for a referendum on. We wanted STV. We also thought that AV would probably increase the number of pro-PR MPs and therefore increase the chances of getting actual PR later.
- JupiterMoon 12y ago> We also thought that AV would probably increase the number of pro-PR MPs and therefore increase the chances of getting actual PR later. Ahh I didn't think of it like this. I thought that AV would allow the Tories and Labour to say that we'd had electoral reform and that would be it for another 100 years... I'm hoping that the pressure will build against FPTP now - especially after the farce of an election we just had. I do hope that we don't go full PR or even region based PR for the commons though (maybe for the Lords if it ever gets reformed?). Political parties already have enough power in deciding who gets to run. I don't want them controlling the list order as well. I want voters to control the list order with their ballots.
- rmc 12y agoYeah they clearly bet the farm on it, lost it, and got hammered in the election. But had it passed, the Lib Dems could have been reaping the rewards for decades, since they'd almost certainly gain more seats.
- EliRivers 12y agoThe AV system we voted on wasn't actually PR Yes, that's why I said I wept as people left the polling station having thought that's what they were voting about. That's my point. Lots of people didn't know. They thought that's what they were voting on. My particular hatred was for the people who chanted "One man, one vote", like only being able to express yourself in favour of one candidate was some kind of superior state of being, rather than the kind of democracy you have to introduce to a society coming out of a millenium of dictatorship to get them used to the idea before they can move on to a grown-up political system.
- rmc 12y ago> The AV system we voted on wasn't actually PR Yes it is. It's what Ireland uses (that and multi-seat constituancies) and it is called PR. (Technically PR-STV). "PR" covers a lot of voting schemes.
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoIt does cover multiple schemes, but not the one the UK voted to not introduce. http://www.electoral-reform.org.uk/alternative-vote http://www.electoral-reform.org.uk/alternative-vote "AV is not proportional representation and in certain electoral conditions, such as landslides, can produce a more disproportional result than First Past the Post (FPTP)"
- learnstats2 12y agoAlternative Vote is a single member constituency version of STV, that is therefore not proportional in any way. It is perhaps the only form of democracy that's typically less proportional than FPTP. I support electoral reform wholeheartedly and I voted for AV only reluctantly.