4 ms·
> What scares me about government, both in the US and abroad, is not the polarization of parties, but how quickly the dominant ideologies cycle from left to rig
by JoshTriplett 12y ago
> What scares me about government, both in the US and abroad, is not the polarization of parties, but how quickly the dominant ideologies cycle from left to right. The pendulum swings to fast.
That swing wouldn't inherently be a bad thing, if the parties on the right were more about the smaller government and more freedom that they market themselves with (at least in the US; I don't know if that's even part of the marketing message in the UK), and less about tearing down civil liberties.
Does the UK have any parties that are actually in favor of smaller government and preserving civil liberties? Does anyone pay attention to those parties, or are they mostly ignored like third parties in the US?
- fixxer 12y agoTotally agree. We don't have a system that benefits moderates at all. Even if you are lucky enough to find a moderate within the party system, they inevitably caucus with the group.
- _delirium 12y agoIs that even the right's marketing message in the US? I feel like the "headline" messages from the right, at least here where I'm spending some time in Houston, are demanding more law-and-order and a more authoritarian government, not a smaller, more hands-off government and more civil liberties. The two big pet issues of the right here are: 1) cracking down on illegal immigration by any means necessary, and 2) cracking down on terrorism by any means necessary. Billboards are full of advertisements from prospective politicians, elected judges (a nutty situation itself), and elected sheriffs, promising how they're going to wield the arm of government more often, and more ruthlessly, than their predecessors did. Double the number of cops, build a border fence, put drones on the border, institute surveillance of mosques, allow no-warrant stops of vehicles, require citizens to carry an ID card at all times, etc., etc. And when issues get to the Texas Supreme Court, politically it seems to almost always be various liberal groups sending in amicus briefs on the pro-civil-liberties side, and conservative groups sending in briefs on the pro-government side. The one exception is gun rights, where basically both sides are in favor (in Texas), but the right is more strongly in favor.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoMarketing messages vary. The right in the US definitely markets to fear and safety, though they're usually less direct than the recent UK government regarding issues like surveillance. But there's also a pretty strong "lower taxes, smaller government" message. (Yes, those are contradictory messages; even stranger when they appear in the same ad.) But most of the marketing is already done and widely perceived, even if it doesn't match reality. The expectation of many voters is that you vote left for more government or right for less. It's unfortunate that the reality is you'll get more government either way, and it'll just be used for different things.