9 ms·
Don’t Be So Sure the Economy Will Return to Normal
- jedharris 12y agoCowan talks about a "reset". Perhaps part of the "reset" will be putting some of benefits of productivity back in everyone's pocket.
- a3n 12y agoI think the productivity reset has already happened, but not in the way you (or I) would hope. That's why wages and confidence of individuals are stagnant, while corporations and stocks are doing well. "The recession is over" is true for corporations, but is open to debate for lots of individuals.
- csense 12y agoThe real issue here is globalization. In the post-WW2 years, US workers had a monopoly on labor provided to US firms, and thus were able to extract some of their firms' economic surplus (either through unionization or the threat of unionization). Company owners shared some of their profits with their workers because they had no other choice. Now that trade borders are relatively open, companies have the option of looking elsewhere. US workers can no longer extract the surplus because if they attempt to, their company will simply relocate operations to a different country. It's an either-or proposition: You can have free global trade, or you can have a job market that pays high wages to workers of average skill. You want both, but it's impossible; so we have to make a choice. We've chosen free global trade, and (as the article notes) there's a slow adjustment time in institutions. Figuring it began in the 1970's with Nixon opening up China, it took about 25 years to really be felt (in the dotcom bust, financial crisis and subsequent slow recovery).
- digikata 12y agoGlobalization plays it's part, but I think the real root cause is the shift in business philosophy to systematically squeeze margins for short term goals. Worker salaries are one vulnerable facet there, but between businesses margins are tighter too. It basically optimizes efficiency & profits today, but edges out a number of avenues for better long term growth - larger investments in new products within companies as well as the worker pay & savings (which in turn hurts for example self-funded small business starts). In theory, tighter margins means better purchasing power for everyone, but somehow that excess from the squeeze seems to be unevenly sticky as capital flows past the upper wealth brackets.
- pcurve 12y agoI agree with both of you, and both are equally valid reasons because ultimately they're cause & effect. I would also blame regulatory & policy screw-ups by government and central banks that cause gross mis-allocation of resources as huge contributor.
- oxymoron 12y agoThere are other factors here: Automation. East asia remains the manufacturing powerhouse of the world, but even that region is losing production jobs in absolute numbers. Low skilled labour opportunities are disappearing everywhere. Transport. Free trade doesn't cause a sudden loss of jobs to abroad. Cheap and effiecient logistics did. The incentives for moving jobs abroad is there with or without trade treaties. Regulation and incentives. Not sure if it remains the case but most of the major US tech companies including the likes of Microsoft, Dell and Intel used to be headquartered on Ireland due to tax incentives. Unions. Love 'em or hate 'em, they do cause disturbances in the market equilibriums. --- All of this has happened without treaties with either the EU nor the pacific countries. Some automotive factories may have ended up in Mexico, but NAFTA is hardly the reason that the US is where it's at.
- gonzo 12y ago> Automation > ... > Transport Now combine them. There was an article on HN yesterday about autonomous semi trucks. about the only thing that will stop this is the cost of energy, which is all but artificially low right now. If/when it climbs, the economy is in for the mother of all "resets".
- collyw 12y agoI would still say its more down to misallocation of capital. As someone else pointed out, you only need to look around you to see that there is no shortage of work needing done. Are your streets clean? Are all the roads in perfect condition? Has everyone got good healthcare?
- stegosaurus 12y ago"Normal" is hilarious in context. In the UK we have a housing crisis so acute that even "well paid" professionals are paying 50%+ of income on a 1 bedroom flat. We have a government that sees the unemployed as vermin, rats to be extinguished. A government with a puritanical "work will set you free" mindset. And overlaid on that, in the past decade we've had the Internet go mainstream. Working class kids now have an acute awareness of what the other half is up to. The whole model is bloody broken. It makes me depressed that people even engage with this tripe. It's like having a discussion about how best to cook a slab of meat that's been left out for months and has gone fuzzy and green. We can't go on with this nonsense class based serfs and lords stuff. Really, we can't. It's not just bad for the squeezed middle, it's bankrupt from top to bottom. People working in shit jobs for shit pay to die early. Middle class kids buckling themselves in with the student debt and the mortgage to spend their entire adult life under the heel of the capitalists. And now they _know_ it. It's not just 'how life is', any more. It's how life was made to be for them, by those. We don't need kebabs or movies or dry cleaning. This stuff exists and these people are working in crap conditions for the sole reason that we decided as a society that people don't deserve the basics unless they submit to the machine. It can be fixed. The difference between a landlord and a tenant is a piece of paper or a few bytes in a database.... but we cling on to the model. When and how will it end?
- jseliger 12y agoIn the UK we have a housing crisis so acute that even "well paid" professionals are paying 50%+ of income on a 1 bedroom flat. [...] When and how will it end? The UK makes it prohibitively hard to build new housing, and, consequently, in the face of a rising population and not-rising housing supply, prices rise. It will end when the UK liberalizes building: http://www.buzzfeed.com/dlknowles/britains-dysfunctional-property-market-in-gi-fm44#.jqnnnMzZml http://www.buzzfeed.com/dlknowles/britains-dysfunctional-pro... .
- myblake 12y agoIt's like San Francisco only way bigger!
- 12y ago
- jqm 12y agoI read a theory somewhere that one of the the reasons Japan and Germany did so well in the post war years was that the war had completely cleaned out the rot and corruption from their institutions and they were starting over with a clean slate. I have no idea how true this is. But I do suspect some of the troubles in America are more than economic... they are structural. Corruption in boardrooms. Profits without production. Institutions far deviated from their original purpose. Workers showing up and barely going through the motions with a sense of entitlement. Managers who have long since ceased to serve any useful function holding on to their jobs and perniciously cutting out anyone who would threaten them by innovating or producing. It's no one persons fault. It's not even the systems fault. It's just I think what happens when systems grow stale and a bit corrupt. Maybe there does inevitably have to be a real reset before things can get better again.
- meric 12y agoThe situation is getting a bit like the late Qing dynasty, the late Ming dynasty, the late Ming dynasty, the late Song dynasty and before that, the late Tang dynasty, the late Jin dynasty, and the late Han dynasty before them. The corruption amongst the wealthy and the powerful, as well as overreach of power from the central state causes instability in the empire, and with revolts, crisis and invasions abound, the empire collapses, and a new one arises like a phoenix out of ashes, along with a new era of prosperity where government officials work to the benefit of the people. Dynasties in China rarely last more than 300 years before the corruption and the reach of the state expands too much and collapse the dynasty with it. The current global hegemon is the United States of America...How long has it been since the last rebellion in the Americas, against the last global hegemon before them, the British Empire? 239 years. I am optimistic my future grandchildren will live in more optimistic times than my future children will.
- f3llowtraveler 12y ago> where government officials work to the benefit of the people. hahahahahahahaha
- 12y ago
- f3llowtraveler 12y agoThe entire financial and monetary system is a government-enforced cartel. I don't expect that to change anytime soon. Things will just keep getting worse.
- mempko 12y agoPeople of the west. The capitalists are abandoning you. They don't give a fuck about you. You live in a 'mature' economy. They are going where the growth is like China. But don't fight it. Take it like a man. Watch more TV, drink more. Weed is being legalized so you feel better about all of this.