3 ms·
"Selling live shows, selling merchendise, selling music in a form that makes it a "collectable", even music for films etc..." Many of which are not really maki
by Tichy 17y ago
"Selling live shows, selling merchendise, selling music in a form that makes it a "collectable", even music for films etc..."
Many of which are not really making music, though. What if you simply want to make music? You might as well say "musicians can get paid for doing TV commercials for facial creams" - maybe they can, but I doubt it is what they had in mind when they went into music.
In fact, if I was looking for a cleaning lady, and Bjork as well as some unknown woman would apply, I would probably prefer Bjork. So in that sense "musicians can make money by becoming room cleaners".
- ABrandt 17y agoAs much as I would like to not put this so bluntly--that's the free market for you. "Simply making music" is fine, but that has never exactly put food on the table. The internet isn't destroying the value of music itself, its just altering the industry's viable business model. This is the same line of thinking that we are constantly applying to web apps here on HN. Sure you can make a neat little functional application, and it will take you time and effort to do so, but that doesn't just automatically mean it should pay the bills for you.
- Tichy 17y agoI actually believe in the free market, and of course it is nowhere set in stone that musicians are entitled to make money off their music. I just wanted to point out that to say "but see, they have more ways of making money than ever" is a bit besides the point. I suppose some artists will find ways to survive, but just because somebody is a talented musician doesn't make them talented T-Shirt designers or even talented live show performers (making music does not imply performing anymore these days). Film music is also not a good way out, because film is plagued from the same problems as music.