4 ms·
A hardware engineer told me in discussions on chip subversion that BS like this is common in SOC's, too. He said they're so expensive to develop that vendors of
by nickpsecurity 12y ago
A hardware engineer told me in discussions on chip subversion that BS like this is common in SOC's, too. He said they're so expensive to develop that vendors often include the functionality of all their chips in one design. Then, they flip a switch on the chip to enable or disable specific functionality. This means they all cost the same to make but they can give you specific features at specific prices. Hard disk makers do it too where you bought a "120GB" drive that uses same eg 1TB platter as the rest but firmware restricts user to 120GB.
You can't be sure whats in it unless a company such as Chipworks tears it down piece by piece and wire by wire. Sneaky is the norm in hardware.
- ikeboy 12y ago>Hard disk makers do it too where you bought a "120GB" drive that uses same eg 1TB platter as the rest but firmware restricts user to 120GB. Why isn't some smart hacker buying these in bulk, reverse engineering the firmware to enable the full 1TB, and reselling at a 1tb price point? Would that be a good business?
- eropple 12y agoIt would be a business that requires people to trust their data to voided-warranty drives. I don't think that'd be popular.
- ikeboy 12y agoI'd buy a new 1tb HD that comes from a known manufacturer if it was much cheaper than any others I could get.
- eropple 12y agoIt wouldn't be much cheaper, though. A WD Blue 250GB on Newegg is $47. A WD Blue 1TB is $55.
- DanBC 12y agoBackblaze might be interested. If they're happy to shuck drives from external enclosures they're possibly happy to hack firmware. But I'm guessing the drive manufacturers test the platters and use faulty platters for these firmware restricted drives, like CPU makers test the cores.
- ams6110 12y agoExactly how is a "warranty" going to protect the data on your drives? Drives fail. If you aren't mitigating that fact, e.g. by using RAID and doing backups, then a warranty isn't going to bail you out.
- eropple 12y agoI trust that WD's warranties are generally formulated to last for the statistical lifetime of the drive, and operate with that in mind. (And my home NAS is in RAID6, so, sure, I agree with you.) I don't trust some dude's homebrew hard drive controller flash, and I don't trust that I have no recourse if it goes south. I definitely don't value that over eight dollars.
- magila 12y agoReformatting a hard drive to a higher capacity would be akin to overclocking a CPU. The heads and platter might operate fine at the higher capacity, or they might not. Running the risk that your HDD might be quietly losing your data is not something most people are interested in. It's a moot point anyways because reformatting an HDD to a different capacity would be an impossibly complex endeavor. Performing a low-level format on a modern HDD requires a multi-step (and multi day!) process of burn-in and calibration. None of it is documented publicly of course. Doing this outside of the factory is far beyond the realm of possibility.
- ikeboy 12y ago>The heads and platter might operate fine at the higher capacity, or they might not. If it's literally the exact same hardware, but different firmware, then they most definitely should perform exactly the same.
- userbinator 12y agoHeads would be the same, but there's a chance that they're using the platters which have defects on them, making them unusable for higher capacities. They could be serious defects too, i.e. surface abberations that would damage the heads if they ventured into that area.
- magila 12y agoHeads and media are like silicon chips in that no two units are "exactly" the same. Yield in terms of usable capacity varies from one unit to the next just like clock rate for CPUs. When you buy an HDD it has been validated to operate correctly at the rated capacity, there's no guarantee how it may handle higher densities. Besides, unless you work at an HDD factory you have no way of knowing just how similar the parts of a particular 250GB drive are to a 1TB drive. For all you know they may have gotten a particularly dodgy lot of heads or patters which definitely can't handle 1TB.
- nickpsecurity 12y agoThe firmware on the device is a black box that controls a more complex black box in an undocumented way and where errors can break it. You don't JUST swap the firmware out. Even so, he may have meant it in the context of the onboard software and modifiable hardware (eg switch they flip at factory to permanently set behavior). Sometimes a hardware engineer will call both firmware speaking shorthand. If it was the latter, you're unlikely to change it because they blow a physical fuse (antifuse?) inside the chip. Some IP vendors are also offering encryption, tamper-sensing circuitry, and obfuscation to help chip-makers protect the systems better. They really want that extra few hundred dollars. ;)
- rasz_pl 12y agoBecause its not true :) There might be some 750GB disks using 1TB platters, but the difference is never x10.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoThat's been going on for years and years and years, companies like IBM were doing it in the 60s.
- bravo22 12y agoThat's for a different reason. Let's say you have 4 models of a chip, some with more internal RAM & Flash some with less and some with a couple of peripherals and features, and some with less. It is far less expensive to design one model with everything, and then disable some features either by not bonding the chip pads it to package pins or by laser cutting fuses. One of the most expensive aspects of chip manufacturing is the setup cost, i.e. the mask and "tooling". So it is much cheaper for them to it once and have one chip that rolls of the line. Also, things like RAM and EEPROM have fabrication errors just like other parts of the chip. It isn't uncommon to have "self healing" RAM. Basically the RAM has a few more cells or address rows more than the actual capacity. As part of wafer testing certain paths are cut so you still end up with the amount of RAM you need. Although it takes up a bit more area (because you're actually manufacturing more RAM) you still end up with higher overall yield. So as chips come off the line, some get binned into lower grades, or RAM size and the rest of the features are disabled via laser cutting fuses or vias.
- nickpsecurity 12y agoYeah, that's what he said. So, that makes two of you saying this is industry standard for cost-cutting and increasing yield. I'd probably do the same if I made chips. We do it in security engineering for high assurance stuff for similar reasons: the more flexible, certified design can be reused in many applications with minimal extra work & (hopefully) max ROI.
- bravo22 12y agoRight. That makes sense too!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]