4 ms·
So he thinks emails can't be spied on. He doesn't mention which computer runs the email wget-like program, but if it's traceable to him, then it's trackable, or
by ikeboy 12y ago
So he thinks emails can't be spied on. He doesn't mention which computer runs the email wget-like program, but if it's traceable to him, then it's trackable, or if the email isn't encrypted at any step. He doesn't mention using PGP for that, and without that it's likely that the emails are in plain-text.
About DRM: he seems to say that if you can break it, it's ok to use it, even if it's unfree. Also, is Netflix breakable? I don't use it myself, but I was once told you can rip the movies with some programs.
- upofadown 12y ago>So he thinks emails can't be spied on. That seems very unlikely. Since the stuff in the emails is publicly available on the net there would be no point in encrypting them. You might be able to determine what RMS is interested in, but everyone already knows what RMS is interested in ... in some detail.
- ikeboy 12y ago>One consequence of this method is that most of the survellance [sic] methods used on the Internet can't see me. is right after the description of how he browses. It sounds like he doesn't want people knowing what he's browsing. Although "most" could exclude the NSA and anyone capable of intercepting emails.
- jordigh 12y ago> So he thinks emails can't be spied on Quite the contrary. Since the Snowden revelations, all of his emails have the following header: [[[ To any NSA and FBI agents reading my email: please consider ]]] [[[ whether defending the US Constitution against all enemies, ]]] [[[ foreign or domestic, requires you to follow Snowden's example. ]]]
- ikeboy 12y ago>One consequence of this method is that most of the survellance [sic] methods used on the Internet can't see me. That's what I based my comment on. Although he's changed, apparently, according to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9559834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9559834
- simoncion 12y agoCompare the number of government-level full-take Internet surveillance programs to the number of surveillance programs run by small "analytics" and "customer engagement" companies. By this measure, browsing the web through an email proxy renders most surveillance methods blind to your activities.
- ikeboy 12y agoIt would still depend on where the email proxy is running, though. Anyway, a regular free vpn (from his description, I'm sure he'd never exceed the limits) would achieve the same goals (and he could still use lynx et al and browse offline). Hell, browsing with javascript and cookies turned off shoud already defeat most surveillance, plus maybe change your IP every so often.
- simoncion 12y agoI agree with your comments in the second sentence of your second paragraph. However, you're moving the goalposts. You said: "So [RMS] thinks emails can't be spied on [because he said 'One consequence of <my internet browsing> method is that most of the survellance methods used on the Internet can't see me.'". My comment illuminated the reasoning behind RMS's use of the word "most" and addressed your misunderstanding of the same.
- ikeboy 12y agoThat's fair. My reasoning was something like "this seems specifically designed to obscure IP, the only attackers likely to be able to do something about IP can also read email, therefore RMS doesn't know what he's talking about with regard to a threat model here". This was mostly implicit, which lead to my claim above that he thinks email is secure; it seemed like the only way to justify his claims for any threat model.
- simoncion 12y agoI hope that you now understand that your initial claim was mistaken. :)
- ohitsdom 12y agoThis is what I don't get. Why browse the web through this URL email method? It doesn't hide him from the government (arguably easier to track emails from a specific address instead of a changing IP). I guess it'd disguise him from the viewpoint of websites, but wouldn't Tor or a VPN accomplish the same? Seems like a lot of work for little (if any) benefit. EDIT: nevermind, just read elsewhere that this technique was for offline browsing and now he does use a browser.
- rsync 12y ago"So he thinks emails can't be spied on." Actually... if you use a console based email program (like pine) that you use over SSH, then all of your email to other users on the same system never traverse a network. If it's a web based interface, then you need to worry about stripping SSL and rogue CAs and all of those threats. But if two people SSH into the same system and send email to each other with pine (or elm or whatever), the email itself never traverses a network (it's just a local copy operation) and the reading of the email is over SSH. It may interest you to know that not one single piece of rsync.net internal company email has ever traversed a network.