3 ms·
This is a band-aid solution to a widely acknowledged problem. But the entire concept of startup culture actively embraces the hive-mentality/cool-kids-know-bes
by stephenr 12y ago
This is a band-aid solution to a widely acknowledged problem.
But the entire concept of startup culture actively embraces the hive-mentality/cool-kids-know-best mindset so I doubt the actual problem will ever be fixed.
But sure, keep posting the same stockholm-esque defensive comments.
- DanBC 12y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1007027 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1007027 > Strictly speaking a vote does affect someone's karma. But it doesn't cause their karma to be net decreased as a result of posting a comment unless you downvote the comment below 1, which most people don't do lightly. I think of the up and downvoting as a collaboration to determine how much additional karma someone should get for posting a new comment. > This is a band-aid solution to a widely acknowledged problem. It's an easy solution, and the only solution currently available. The fact it doesn't work just proves me right: the problem isn't just with people downvoting comments for disagreement; the problem involves other people not upvoting unfairly downvoted comments.
- stephenr 12y ago> The fact it doesn't work just proves me right I didn't say your "solution" won't work, I said it's a bandaid. Maybe it wasn't clear what I meant by "bandaid solution". Let me explain a literal example: I once cut my knuckle very badly with a cheap mandolin slicer. I didn't realise at the time, but there was basically a chunk of my finger - about the size of a very large pea - missing, and because my knuckle was bent at the time it was deep. Because the blade was so ridiculously sharp, it wasn't really very painful, and due to the blood I couldn't see how deep it actually was, so I put a band-aid on it and didn't think about it. Three days later a doctor had to use silver nitrate to cauterise the wound, as it immediately started bleeding profusely whenever the pressure from the bandaid was removed. That is what I mean by "bandaid solution" - you're not solving the problem, merely covering up the issue and trying to ignore it. Upvoting any and all non-offensive comments simply to counter any possible errant down votes defeats the purpose of having votes at all - I then have to choose between keeping the conversation open and honest, and "supporting" comments I actively agree with. As a side-note, I strongly suggest against using a cheap mandolin OR having a wound cauterised with silver nitrate. I've had entire toenails removed, and part of the nailbed scraped away (it's as horrible as it sounds) as a child, and that hurt less than the cauterisation.