4 ms·
You are probably not aware of the details of what he did with Emacs and GCC. The short answer is: it was possible to implement reasonably effective Lisp in Emac
by acqq 12y ago
You are probably not aware of the details of what he did with Emacs and GCC. The short answer is: it was possible to implement reasonably effective Lisp in Emacs, but it was impossible to replace the most of Unix infrastructure in it. Therefore the GCC was necessary.
It's not about the "theoretical possibilities" it's about the practical limitations.
I can't refer to you to any single resource regarding the limitations of any Lisp for implementing the free-source replacement of Unix, but if you investigate how the Lisp in Emacs was actually implemented you can get the picture. Provided you have enough basic knowledge about the low level aspects of the CPUs, compilers and interpreters and also the limitations of all the hardware before the most modern CPUs. Even today, what's "good enough" on the desktop can be "too much demanded" from the lower power systems. But the lower power systems of today are also much more advanced than what we had for decades during which GNU project grew.
GCC 1.0 was released in 1987. The 2000 USD computer had less than 1 MB of RAM then.
- melling 12y agoYes, I am aware. I didn't say that GCC wasn't necessary. Performance does matter. However, if he had a better Lisp then as Moore's Law advanced over the past 3 decades, Lisp could have become more common. Emacs Lisp is slow and it's also not a standard like Common Lisp or Scheme. We'd all agree C isn't as necessary today. Lots of great stuff is done in Ruby, Python, JavaScript, Node.js, Clojure, etc. Developers are building editors in browsers (atom.io) and Microsoft used atom with 200k of Typescript in their new cross-platform tools.
- acqq 12y agoIt doesn't matter what was before 3 decades. You have the environment that exists now. You can use better Lisp, if it's good enough now, for what you need to do. For the resource limited and performance critical stuff I still use C and a lot of actual environments still need C-level performance and the resource use patterns. And all this is not because of what RMS did or didn't do. He did great things, and I don't agree that anybody can claim that he could have done something differently given the real constrains he had.
- CHY872 12y agoThere are loads of languages like that, I don't think that you can blame rms for this. For example, the MLs are currently kinda hot, ocaml especially, and have been around for donkey's years; but in the early 1990s they were very slow. Lots of the applications written in ML are barely viable; the only reason they're performant now is due to Moore's law.
- CHY872 12y agoThere are loads of languages like that, I don't think that you can blame rms for this. For example, the MLs are currently kinda hot, ocaml especially, and have been around for donkey's years; but in the early 1990s they were very slow. Lots of the applications written in ML are barely viable; the only reason they're performant now is due to Moore's law.
- vardump 12y ago$1000 computer had 1 MB of RAM in 1987. $699 for Amiga 500 (had 512 kB) and $159 for A501 512kB memory expansion.
- acqq 12y agoMaybe I should have said "a PC" instead of "a computer." As in, something that actually had a hard disk. Did GNU software run on Amiga 500? Had it been a good decision to target it instead of the PC-compatibles? I don't think so.
- rjsw 12y agoAn Atari ST/Mega ST could have a hard disk too. I ran Franz Lisp on my Atari ST which included a native compiler.
- acqq 12y agoI don't doubt that. The topic was the platform suitable for GNU. Neither Atari nor Amiga had been a good choice then.
- vardump 12y agoAmiga 500 had A590 among others, 20 MB hard disk. Lattice C was the compiler used for Amiga.
- rjsw 12y agoSorry, I was unclear. Franz Lisp compiled to 68k binaries, there was also Cambridge Lisp for the Amiga. I just wanted to point out that this class of computers was a valid target for a good Lisp system.
- greggman 12y agoSome of the most performant games ever created were written in Lisp or a variant of it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Game_Oriented_Assembly_Lisp http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Game_Oriented_Assembly_Lisp Million polygon levels running at 60fps when the majority of games on that system had 1-2 orders of magnitude less geometry and ran at 30fps and were written in C/C++ I'm NOT saying therefore RMS should have used lisp instead of C but I am suggesting that any perf objections or memory objections are mostly not factual. It's perfectly possible to make a performant non-memory hungry lisp.
- acqq 12y agoWritten using Allegro Common Lisp, a "commercial implementation of the Common Lisp programming language developed by Franz Inc." Which was related to the Macsyma and going proprietary, and "the closing of the MIT Lisp and Macsyma efforts was a key reason Richard Stallman decided to form the Free Software Foundation." https://www.ma.utexas.edu/pipermail/maxima/2001/001119.html https://www.ma.utexas.edu/pipermail/maxima/2001/001119.html RMS: fighting proprietary software for more than 3 decades. Also interesting: the game company "transitioned to C++ for future projects" according to Wikipedia.
- lispm 12y agoStrange. Allegro CL appeared long AFTER Stallman decided to form the FSF...
- acqq 12y agoAnd apparently is still a commercial (non-free) implementation.
- lispm 12y ago> Also interesting: the game company "transitioned to C++ for future projects" according to Wikipedia. They did after Sony bought them, to improve code sharing with other Sony game developers. After they found out that this was not the case, they have been using Scheme (a dialect of Lisp) again in their development. http://www.naughtydog.com/docs/Naughty-Dog-GDC08-Adventures-In-Data-Compilation.pdf http://www.naughtydog.com/docs/Naughty-Dog-GDC08-Adventures-... http://de.slideshare.net/naughty_dog/statebased-scripting-in-uncharted-2-among-thieves http://de.slideshare.net/naughty_dog/statebased-scripting-in...