6 ms·
The case for drinking whole milk
- MindTooth 12y agoWould not really be surprised if new research leads us to rethink the last few decades of "research". One might wonder what has really caused the obesity epidemic. I personally prefer milk straight from the tank. Cold and non-processed :-)
- kaffeemitsahne 12y agoI drink milk straight from the cow, get on my level.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoIt's dirty (literally) down there.
- atomical 12y agoWouldn't it be warm?
- MindTooth 12y agoThey pump the milk out of the cow, into a tank. And periodically the milk company comes and take all of it. I guess it is to preserve it inbetween pick-up. So, it is cold in the tank. And taste really good!
- kalleboo 12y agoI'm never really satisfied when people quote these studies that just observed what people drank and concluded "skim milk makes you obese!" when it seems obvious the causation makes just as much sense the other way around - people who are overweight switch to skim milk as a way to cut calories from their diet.
- thespace12 12y agoCalories in < calories burned == healthy hacker
- rimantas 12y agoOr just thin hacker.
- kaybe 12y agoOr even dead hacker if kept up long enough. I also like me some moderate energy reserves; it improves almost keeling over from low blood sugar when forgetting to eat or no food is available for a few hours tremendously.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoNot if they're all Big Mac calories. Quality matters.
- pizza234 12y agoThe exact same concept applies to premature optimization, except that in case, it would be obvious that the person is a poor programmer. When you put in context saving, say, 150 calories (500 ml whole vs. skim milk) in the diet of an obese person who stuffs 4000+ calories in his belly, and practices no sports ("walking a lot" is not included, sorry), then we're talking about mental masturbation, not meaningful, rational, strategies.
- pluma 12y agoExcept it's not quite that simple. First of all, quality matters. You could satisfy your entire calorie requirement with lard, but that would be extremely detrimental to your health. Also, how our bodies process food is still not well-understood in detail (although there are tons of self-titled experts claiming otherwise). In other words, excess calories == weight gain and insufficient calories == weight loss don't work out just as nicely as you'd think (I think there was an article on HN recently that even pointed out different people have different "default weights" they would find very difficult to stray from in either direction). Additionally simply not eating that much can be very difficult. Not everyone has the time, energy and money to ensure they eat healthy (and the right things eat the right times of the day) -- although of course for energy this can be somewhat of a catch-22 (bad eating habits lead to lack of energy leading to bad eating habits). And there's also the problem of satiation and rabbit starvation: it's hard to stick with a diet if your body signals you that you're starving and must eat. As a rule of thumbs, sure, just eat less calories if you're overweight. But good luck sticking with that if you don't have the time, energy and money to experiment with how you can make that sustainable. Otherwise the "yo-yo effect" wouldn't be such a widespread and widely-known problem.
- soggypopsicle 12y agoA case for not drinking any milk: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milk#Criticism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milk#Criticism
- wglb 12y agoAnd there is this highly-opinionated site http://www.notmilk.com/ http://www.notmilk.com/
- jmnicolas 12y agoA doctor once told me : cow milk is for calf, look how quickly they add mass.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoDoctors don't practice science. But I've heard the same thing, and it stands to reason like any piece of common sense.
- stefantalpalaru 12y agoIt's also for the species that conquered the world by relying on smart use of animal resources for survival. I see two legitimate uses nowadays for "cow milk is for calves": raising awareness about the cruel aspects of our relation with other animals and promoting breast feeding.
- ska 12y agoHow much do they consume? What else do they consume? That saying has been around for ages, but strikes me as one of those superficially smart sounding but actually kind of fundamentally misguided phrases that sometimes become popular. Unless someone is suggesting an all cows milk diet, I suppose.
- dorfsmay 12y agoShould we also stop eating green vegetables? Passed six months, cows only consume grass, and look how quickly they add mass.
- jqm 12y agoStrongest case point for drinking whole milk (in my opinion)? It tastes a lot better.
- noisy_boy 12y agoFood habits during the growing years also contribute to the perception of taste. I had whole milk while growing up and I still prefer that. One of my friends grew up on the low-fat variety and likes it that way; he even tried whole on my recommendation and went back to low-fat because, "it didn't taste good".
- pistle 12y agoI grew up with whole milk, weened myself to skim (and came to NOT like the heft of whole or 2%), then essentially stopped milk altogether. With kids, milk was brought back into the fridge (whole). Now, I prefer whole (certain premium organic brands are just other-worldly), but it only goes into recipes and the occasional bowl of cereal (like a dessert of fat and sugar). Most things in moderation and you can focus on the pleasure aspect vs. the health. Whole has more pleasure to it. If you're going to drink from the bosom of a cow, might as well go fully creepy.
- leoc 12y agoOne more little wrinkle: I don't think I can recall ever seeing semi-skimmed milk priced at a discount to whole milk at retail. Someone's got themselves a nice little earner selling off that removed dairy fat.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoInteresting. I wonder if handling of an easily-spoiled food isn't a big enough part of the cost to explain the parity between the whole and skim products.
- leoc 12y agoI assume (I'm not an expert) that it's fairly easily processed into butter, anhydrous milk fat https://www.fonterra.com/au/en/NZMP+Ingredients/Our+Ingredients/Milk+Fats/AMF https://www.fonterra.com/au/en/NZMP+Ingredients/Our+Ingredie... https://www.globaldairytrade.info/en/product-results/anhydrous-milk-fat/ https://www.globaldairytrade.info/en/product-results/anhydro... and other valuable and relatively non-spoiling products.
- kps 12y agoWhole milk is usually 10% – 15% more expensive where I live, though the lower-fat varieties are all priced the same. People in the Natural Golden Age™ didn't generally drink whole milk, either — they skimmed the cream off to use separately.
- leoc 12y ago> Whole milk is usually 10% – 15% more expensive where I live, though the lower-fat varieties are all priced the same. Interesting. That's not the case in the UK http://www.tesco.com/groceries/product/details/?id=254656543 http://www.tesco.com/groceries/product/details/?id=254656543 http://www.tesco.com/groceries/product/details/?id=254656399 http://www.tesco.com/groceries/product/details/?id=254656399 or Ireland http://www.tesco.ie/groceries/Product/Details/?id=250005508 http://www.tesco.ie/groceries/Product/Details/?id=250005508 http://www.tesco.ie/groceries/Product/Details/?id=250005606 http://www.tesco.ie/groceries/Product/Details/?id=250005606 .
- will_brown 12y ago>Surprise! Dairy fat actually helps avoid obesity I think the study over looks the most likely physiological reasoning for this, primarily suggesting it is a matter of satiety (feeling fuller consuming less). People like to hinge on the concept of calories in/calories out, then highlight short term diets of ice cream and Twinkies where people still lose weight because of the caloric intake management. Notwithstanding temporary loses due to reduced calories, such diets do prime one for obesity. On the other-hand diets high in protein and fat (good fats: like almonds, chicken skin, red meats, ect...) do prime one to avoid obesity. Each body and metabolism is different. However, the rule of thumb is that sugars (Twinkies and ice cream) release insulin which enlarges things in the body including tumors and in this case fat cells which does prime a body for obesity even if one is not currently obese. But healthy fats will trigger the release of glucagon which has the opposite effect of insulin resulting in smaller fat cells which does help in avoiding obesity.
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoSatiety is everything. The reason overweight individuals have a tough time is that they are not satieted by carb laden foods and thus crave more. Many have broken that cycle with ketogenic diets which are higher in fat.
- yest 12y agoSatiety is nothing. The reason overweight individuals have a tough time is that they are VERY satieted by carb foods but because the brain produce Dopamine they crave it and can't stop. Fat people = addicted to Dopamine. They will eat cookies, sandwiches and other simple carbs every day and between meals. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2381335/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2381335/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/processed-carbohydrates-are-addictive-brain-study-suggests/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/processed-carbohydrates-are-addi...
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoCertainly true, carbs are addicting. But perhaps the satieting effect of fats can help individuals curb their hunger. http://europepmc.org/abstract/med/9683329 http://europepmc.org/abstract/med/9683329 http://www.nature.com/ijo/journal/v32/n11/abs/ijo2008166a.html http://www.nature.com/ijo/journal/v32/n11/abs/ijo2008166a.ht...
- the_chef 12y agoThe credibility of all nutrition recommendations/research has been shot to hell by decades of flip-flopping. Trans-fats are safe! No wait, they really aren't, so forget that they were in pervasive use for 25+ years. Don't eat cholesterol! No, forget about that. Coffee is healthy! No it's unhealthy! No healthy! Unhealthy! There's no way to trust any of this. Whatever decisions are made now I expect to read about the benefits of the opposite decision in ten years.
- revelation 12y agoI still remember the salt scare. Ridiculous on the face of it..
- pizza234 12y agoI haven't clear why this is being downvoted. When put into the perspective of the entire volume of nutritional research, the concepts which are established as certain are a tiny fraction of the total (for the great majority, one finds every possible opinion/research, and the opposite of it), so being skeptical is perfectly reasonable. Quoting the article: ----- > suggests that high-fat dairy consumption within typical dietary patterns is inversely associated with obesity risk. Obesity risk. > While not conclusive, the results "may provide a rationale for future research" Not conclusive. ---- Sadly, under these conditions, it's perfectly reasonable not to exclude that in 10 years, the opposite of such conclusions will be reached.
- ra1n85 12y agoAgreed. The most glaring example of this was the low-fat guidance given during the 80's and 90's in the US. Sugar and high glycemic index carbohydrates were hardly discussed.
- jp555 12y agoSo true although a little ironic that you mention glycemic index, which is a VERY minor issue. Beef spikes insulin more than white rice.
- jp555 12y ago
- esolyt 12y ago> All milk sold (legally) in the US is processed, because it must undergo pasteurization So it's a choice between "processed milk" and "slightly more processed milk". I suggest making your decision based on calories instead of the amount of processing. Whole milk has almost twice the amount calories compared to skim milk.
- brenfrow 12y agoWhy do they have to knock bacon in this discussion to bring milk up? A big part of all of this is just to consume less sugar and carbs. I eat bacon, eggs, and vegetables all the time for breakfast and my blood work couldn't be better from my bagel/cereal/oatmeal days. Go eat more bacon too: http://authoritynutrition.com/is-bacon-bad-or-good/ http://authoritynutrition.com/is-bacon-bad-or-good/
- arclyte 12y agoIf you're drinking whole milk, you're getting a mix of fat and sugar. If you're drinking skim milk, you've removed the fat and kept the sugar. Skim milk's popularity is a result of the low-fat fad (perpetuated by the US government and others) which made everyone scared to eat anything with fat in it. But the fat is actually the good part of milk, so if you don't want the milk fat you're better off picking another drink entirely - like almond milk.
- bhayden 12y agoSome people want to drink milk but they don't want nearly twice the calories of whole over skim. It's fine in moderation, like anything else.
- DeBraid 12y ago65,000+ different animals on Earth weened on their mothers milk, only 1 continues to consumes milk outside of infancy (and from another animal altogether!)... Majority of adults should avoid dairy products, would be order of magnitude more healthy if calories were replaced with green vegetables.
- leonth 12y agoBut among those 65000+ animals, only one has successfully increased its average lifespan significantly in the past 1000+ years. Chief reasons being advancements in sanitation, medicine, and overall diet quality. So "going back to nature" cannot be naively taken as always good.
- kalleboo 12y agoAnd only 1 has been to the moon. Conclusion: if you want to explore space, drink milk.
- blfr 12y agoAll milk sold (legally) in the US is processed, because it must undergo pasteurization, a heating process that kills pathogens. Outside of a small group of raw milk activists, this is generally accepted as a positive. I have been drinking raw milk (just cooled) for over two years now. It's sold here (in Poland but also in Eastern Europe in general) from free-standing machines[1]. It's ~4% fat, slightly more expensive but much tastier. Doesn't keep as well as one sold in a box but you can still drink it with curd on top. I haven't heard of any epidemics. [1] https://i.imgur.com/7MhxOuZ.jpg https://i.imgur.com/7MhxOuZ.jpg
- DanBC 12y ago> I haven't heard of any epidemics. People in the US have had kidney failure as a result of raw milk. That's pretty risky considering not many people drink it. If I knew what the Polish is for "kidney failure" I could probably find the Polish children who were made very ill by parents imposing their fads.
- blfr 12y agoIt's "niewydolność nerek" and I don't see anything about it with connection to milk other than reprints of American studies.
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoYou can't have an "epidemic" from drinking raw milk, since it's not a contagious disease. However, two of my daughter's classmates were hospitalized just a few years ago from drinking raw milk. It was touch and go for a while, but they recovered and didn't need kidney transplants. http://www.oregonlive.com/health/index.ssf/2012/04/raw_milk_from_wilsonville_farm.html http://www.oregonlive.com/health/index.ssf/2012/04/raw_milk_...
- eurleif 12y ago>You can't have an "epidemic" from drinking raw milk, since it's not a contagious disease. Is that really a requirement? Wikipedia says "infectious disease", and, for example, here's a study that refers to an "epidemic" of foodborne illness: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7727673 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7727673
- atul_wired 12y agoI find this article funny. >Though it would seem to follow that consuming less fat would lead to being less fat, that’s not quite what the science says, at least when it comes to dairy—even if whole milk is more caloric than skim. It mentions about some scientific reason for it but then talks about bunch of high level case studies and that's all. On a side note, I find most of these case studies a scam, where they exaggerate and manipulate numbers to make it sound scary or utterly interesting for reader's attention.