3 ms·
I completely agree, but I feel it should be mandatory. (I've proposed this same "explain why" mechanism for downvotes a few times in the past.) Currently downv
by pavlov 12y ago
I completely agree, but I feel it should be mandatory. (I've proposed this same "explain why" mechanism for downvotes a few times in the past.)
Currently downvoting has unbalanced incentives. You need a fairly high level of karma to use the feature, which suggests that it's considered a privilege. Yet, once you have it, there's no responsibility attached to the privilege.
This can make downvoting kind of sophomoric: "I was unreasonably downvoted when I was a newbie, now it's payback time!"
- amirmc 12y agoYou're assuming that HN isn't keeping track of how often you downvote (or any patterns). Without knowing the set up, it's difficult to infer much. Of course, revealing that info might lead to gaming the system.