4 ms·
But that's completely understandable. (Inb4 personal attacks, I'm a drop-out myself, and my first job, that I had for almost a year, paid $500 a month.) Consid
by golergka 12y ago
But that's completely understandable. (Inb4 personal attacks, I'm a drop-out myself, and my first job, that I had for almost a year, paid $500 a month.)
Consider asymmetry of information. There were two versions of you: (1) fresh uni drop-out, and (2) uni drop-out with programming experience and open-source contributions. These descriptions summarise information that potential employers had about you. You also was a hard-working and intelligent person the whole time; however, employers didn't have this information per se, because they had no simple way of being sure of these characteristics.
However, these characteristics are what employers are looking for. Now, information (1) gives almost no certainty that you have these characteristics: there are a lot of top programs drop-outs out there, and an employer would have to go through hundreds of them and spend a lot of time and effort on evaluating them to find one you. On other hand, if employer limited search to someone who fits (2), the odds of finding a person with these characteristics would be much higher, and the interview process would be easier.
> I have little sympathy for companies that choose to operate that way.
Are you really surprised that (2) got a lot more offers?
Do you really think that employer should be "fair" to potential employees, if that decision costs him (and his shareholders) more money? In other words, do you think that for a for-profit business, social obligations (in this case, to an intelligent drop-out) should be more important that obligations to their investors and shareholders?
Essentially, that's one of the reasons experienced developers get so much money: it's actually _cheaper_ (consider not only the cost of hiring process, but also the potential cost of a bad developer working in your team) to hire someone you can be relatively sure from other factors is intelligent and hard-working than trying to find such person from a wider pool.
- hrktb 12y agoI understand the point you are making, but it feels like employer lazyness to me. A decent employer should be able to see the potential (2) when meeting (1), at least within two or three interviews. That lazyness can be appropriate if as an employer you have an infinite supply of very good candidates. But IMO that's a pretty rare case, and even then you have to weed out good candidates from not so good ones, and pay attention to a mountain of other non obvious factors. Like, past performance is not everything. You might get better work from someone stepping up to a new position than a burned out veteran holding that same position for years already. Or someone unemployed for a long time seeking back a job might stay longer than the freshman already choosing between a dozen of other companies. And even if the candidate inps not the best fit for the job, you might want him/her for diversity in your team, etc. etc. There's so many things that could impact how an employee is doing in your job, focusing only on 'proven' skills when choosing candidates is usually a bad choice IMO. The exception would be if you don't intend to keep the new employee for too long anyway, but then that's a bad sign for you business I think.
- golergka 12y ago> I understand the point you are making, but it feels like employer lazyness to me. A decent employer should be able to see the potential (2) when meeting (1), at least within two or three interviews. It's not lazyness, it's a different strategy. Some companies decide to spend a lot of resources on hiring, and they are able to find great candidates where others wouldn't look, and thus they get a strategic advantage. Usually, that's a part of their overall strategy. But other companies decide that they are in a different situation, and would spend their resources on different areas. These companies don't want to find a special superstar; instead of increasing reward (in hiring) they look to minimise the risks. And adjusting for correlating factors (degree, experience, etc), they get just like that: the minimise the risk. > Like, past performance is not everything. You might get better work from someone stepping up to a new position than a burned out veteran holding that same position for years already. You might. But we're speaking about company strategy here. The company will make hundreds, thousands of hiring decisions. So we should think about them in terms of a statistical sample. What these companies want is not to increase the probability of high reward, but to reduce a standard deviation on these results: even if the results will be worse on average, it's important that they won't reach a certain low limit. Overall, I'd like to suggest you to think about the process differently: don't think about it as a decision that applied in your particular case, but think about it as a set of principles that should carry the company through the years, while it hires a lot of people. I think all this makes a lot more sense this way.
- hrktb 12y agoYou are right about minimizing risks and making easier hiring decisions, having a more scalable process. But this strategy only works if you don't intend to keep employees for a long time and these employee don't individually hold much of the value you produce. They might stick for years, but it's not the case you'll be optimizing for. I think well fit employees don't stay if they don't grow with the company, but these employee won't be easy to find with a risk averse hiring process (or you have entry jobs with very low needed qualifications, but then you have very small hiring risks anyway) Then if you're ok with only keeping a decent performance in average, it will harder and harder to even keep your hiring bar at the same level, as you'll have more and more unmotivated employees in your rank, and you'll have to give more and more perks for really motivated people to come in and work for you. In my experience, even companies hiring hundreds of people every year actually spend quite a lot of time reviewing profiles and care a lot about getting the right people for the job, at least for any non entry level position.