3 ms·
Playing devils advocate, maybe the students were being rational, but based their reaction on the information at their disposal. I taught college once, and obser
by analog31 12y ago
Playing devils advocate, maybe the students were being rational, but based their reaction on the information at their disposal. I taught college once, and observed that students make rational and sophisticated decisions based on what grades they expect to receive from their courses. They are also justifiably insecure about their math skills.
They have to decide under time pressure whether this is a good teacher or a bad one, easy grader or hard, fair or unfair, etc. The students have to combine what they know about the mechanics of the grading scale, with their own internal information about whether they trust this guy -- especially if it's before the deadline for dropping the class. Introducing an unorthodox or weird grading scale could influence this judgment. The students may have a rational interest in nudging teachers towards a more favorable grading system.
I have a couple of major misgivings about psycho-economics. First, any empirical failure of theory could be blamed on irrational behavior, when the theory itself is wrong for other reasons. We might just not be considering all of the information that people have at their disposal. Likewise, psychology could be blamed for any failure of economic policy, or of entire economies.
Second, deciding who is capable of rational decision making, based on sex, race, or social class, has a long and sorry history. I'd rather let economics be the study of that which can be understood based on the behavior of rational actors, and put bigger error bars around the predictive ability of economic models.